The use of feedback in lab energy conservation: fume hoods at MIT

Daniel Edward Wesolowski, Elsa Olivetti, Amanda Graham, Steve Lanou, Peter Cooper, Jim Doughty, Rich Wilk, Leon R. GlicksmanInternational Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper details a successful campaign at MIT's Chemistry Department to reduce energy consumption by providing monthly feedback on fume hood usage to lab principal investigators. The intervention led to a significant reduction in sash opening, saving an estimated $41,000 annually and averting 160 tons of CO2 emissions, demonstrating the effectiveness of targeted feedback for behavioral energy conservation in labs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Laboratory spaces are notoriously energy-intensive, consuming significantly more energy per square foot than typical office spaces. A major contributor to this high energy demand is the extensive use of fume hoods, which require substantial airflow for safety. This constant ventilation, even when hoods are not actively in use, leads to significant energy waste through heating, cooling, and fan operation. The challenge is to find effective, scalable methods to encourage lab users to adopt more energy-conscious behaviors regarding fume hood usage without compromising safety.

Methods

The study employed a feedback-based intervention. Sash position sensors on variable air volume (VAV) fume hoods in the MIT Chemistry Department were used to collect data on sash height at 15-minute intervals. This data was compiled monthly and presented to the principal investigators (PIs) of each lab in the form of a report. These reports included charts showing the lab's average sash position over time, a comparison to the highest and lowest-using labs in the department, and a frequency histogram of sash positions before and after the intervention. The feedback was delivered through the existing Environmental Health and Safety (EHS) management system, leveraging the EHS coordinator and lab representatives.

Datasets

The primary dataset used was the 15-minute interval average fume hood sash position data collected from sensors in the MIT Chemistry Department. This data was collected both before (baseline period: November 2006 - June 2007) and during the intervention period (starting August 2007). The paper also references historical data and analyses from other institutions (Duke, Harvard, UC-Irvine) for comparative purposes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Feedback is potent, even in efficient settings: The study demonstrates that even in a department with relatively efficient VAV fume hoods and a generally good baseline of user behavior, targeted monthly feedback can still drive significant energy savings.
  • Hood design matters: The type of fume hood significantly impacts the potential for savings. Combination sash hoods, which are more efficient by design and encourage better user habits, yielded less dramatic percentage savings compared to labs with less efficient vertical sash hoods, even though the absolute savings were still substantial.
  • Behavioral change is not uniform: While the overall department saw savings, a few highly active labs contributed disproportionately to the total savings, highlighting the importance of focusing efforts on the most intensive users.
  • Nighttime usage is a key target: A significant portion of energy savings came from reducing sash opening during inactive periods (e.g., overnight), indicating that users were not consistently closing hoods when not in use.
  • Social and institutional context is crucial: The success of the feedback program was amplified by its integration into MIT's established EHS management system and the support of key faculty members, lending credibility and authority to the initiative.

Key Results

  • Overall sash height reduction: Average sash height across the department was lowered by 26%, from 16.3 ± 0.85% open to 12.1 ± 0.39% open.
  • Energy and cost savings: This reduction resulted in an estimated annual savings of $41,500 for the entire department, with Building 18 alone saving $24,000.
  • CO2 emission reduction: Approximately 160 metric tons of CO2 were averted department-wide annually, with 93 tons from Building 18.
  • Reduced inactive period usage: Sash position during inactive periods decreased from 9% to 6% open.
  • Significant savings from top contributors: Half of the total department savings came from just four labs, which were among the most active users.
  • Initial investment: The program required an initial investment of approximately $12,000.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Hood type variability: The study acknowledges that comparing results across different institutions is challenging due to variations in fume hood types and lab environments. The efficiency of combination sash hoods at MIT meant that the percentage reduction in airflow was less dramatic than in studies with less efficient hood designs.
  • Overestimation of potential savings: The initial estimates of potential savings were significantly higher than realized, partly due to assumptions about hood types and manual counting methods, which are less reliable than electronic monitoring.
  • Behavioral vs. Utility Data: While the study showed a clear behavioral change (sash position reduction), directly linking this to utility bill changes was complex due to ongoing building efficiency upgrades. Future work could involve more direct correlation of sash position data with utility consumption.
  • Long-term effectiveness: The paper notes that static prompts (like stickers) have limited long-term effectiveness due to habituation. While the feedback was effective, ongoing monitoring and potential re-engagement strategies might be necessary to maintain savings over time.
  • Further Savings Potential: The authors suggest that further savings could be achieved by completely closing hoods when inactive, which could avert an additional 2740 CFM. They also point to the potential of reducing baseline air exchange rates in labs, a significant energy consumer, through measures like occupancy sensors.

Summary updated

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to report on the results of an Massachusetts Institute of Technology Chemistry Department campaign to reduce energy consumption in chemical fume hoods. Hood use feedback to lab users is a crucial component of this campaign. Design/methodology/approach Sash position sensor data on variable air volume fume hoods are remotely collected. A 15 minutes average fume hood sash positions for each laboratory are recorded. Data are compiled monthly and a report with average sash position over time and relative frequency of hood position are delivered to the principal investigators of the labs. Findings Average sash height is lowered by 26 percent (from 16.3±0.85 percent open to 12.1±0.39 percent open) throughout the department, saving an estimated $41,000/year. Sash position during inactive periods is lowered from 9 to 6 percent open. Half of all department savings occurred in four (of 25) labs. Energy savings are substantially less than original expectations because most installed fume hoods use combination sashes. Labs with vertical sashes use the most energy, and see the most savings from the intervention. Practical implications Monthly feedback is an effective tool for encouraging better hood use behavior. Potential savings from even large behavior changes can be limited if existing equipment is relatively efficient, so conservation programs should be tailored to the existing conditions. Originality/value The present analysis provides data on the impact of a program in a relatively efficient setting compared to other fume hood conservation reports. The results have cautionary value for designers of similar programs. A breakdown of a laboratory building utility use is also provided.
BibTeX
@article{wesolowski2010use,
  author = {Daniel Edward Wesolowski and Elsa Olivetti and Amanda Graham and Steve Lanou and Peter Cooper and Jim Doughty and Rich Wilk and Leon R. Glicksman},
  title = {{The use of feedback in lab energy conservation: fume hoods at MIT}},
  journal = {International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1108/14676371011058523},
}

Loading related content...

Figure