The use of deception in dementia-care robots: Should robots tell "white lies" to limit emotional distress?

Samuel Rhys Cox, Grace Cheong, Wei Tsang OoiarXiv 2023 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper explores the ethical implications of using "white lies" or deception in dementia care, particularly as assistive robots become more prevalent. It argues that human caregivers already employ such strategies to manage emotional distress and ensure care, and questions whether robots should adopt similar tactics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The world is facing an aging population and a rising number of individuals with dementia, creating a significant demand for professional caregivers. Assistive robots are being developed to help fill this gap, offering physical and social support. However, a critical challenge arises: human caregivers often resort to deception (like white lies or misdirection) to provide necessary care while minimizing emotional distress and preserving the dignity of individuals with dementia. This paper grapples with the complex question of whether and how these deceptive practices should be integrated into the capabilities of assistive robots, considering the ethical and practical ramifications.

Methods

The paper adopts a discussion-based approach, drawing upon existing literature and research in dementia care, robotics, and ethics. It reviews common deceptive techniques used by human caregivers, categorizing them and providing examples. The authors then contextualize these techniques within the realm of robotics, exploring the potential for robots to adopt similar strategies. The methodology involves analyzing philosophical and ethical viewpoints on robotic deception and discussing potential implications and concerns.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Human caregivers already use deception: The paper highlights that "white lies" and other forms of deception are not novel concepts in dementia care; they are established practices used to ensure patient well-being and facilitate care.
  • Robots may need to emulate human caregivers: As robots become more sophisticated and anthropomorphic, there's a growing expectation that they might need to adopt human-like behaviors, including deception, to be effective in caregiving roles.
  • Ethical frameworks for robotic deception are nascent: While there are discussions about the ethics of deception in healthcare, specific strategies for dementia-care robots and public perception of these are not well-understood.
  • Deception can be a tool for dignity and distress reduction: The paper suggests that in certain situations, deception can be a necessary tool to prevent emotional distress, maintain dignity, and ensure essential care is delivered to individuals with dementia.
  • Resource limitations can drive deception: The paper notes that some deceptive practices by human caregivers might stem from a lack of resources, raising questions about whether robots should be used to compensate for such deficiencies.

Key Results

The paper does not present quantitative results from experiments or studies. Instead, its key findings are qualitative insights derived from the literature review and discussion:

  • Therapeutic lying is a recognized practice in dementia care, used to simplify medication intake, avoid aggressive behavior, and alleviate stress.
  • Informal restraint techniques, such as diverting attention or using "grey-zone" constraints (e.g., a deep chair to prevent wandering), are employed by human caregivers.
  • The acceptability of robotic deception might increase with greater exposure and familiarity with robots in care settings, similar to how attitudes towards robot pets evolved.
  • The paper raises concerns about the ethical defensibility and desirability of certain deceptive techniques if used by robots, especially if they are a consequence of resource limitations.
  • A significant challenge for robots is the ability to differentiate and perceive the cognitive abilities of individuals to determine when deception is appropriate and when reality-orientation is better.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited empirical data on robotic deception: The paper acknowledges that while human caregiver deception is studied, the acceptability and effectiveness of deception by assistive robots are not well-investigated.
  • Ethical concerns regarding robot-human relationships: The potential for individuals with dementia to not distinguish between relationships with robots and humans raises ethical questions about deception.
  • Legal implications: The paper points to potential legal issues surrounding liability if deceptive robotic interventions are deemed harmful, distressing, or coercive.
  • Need for further research: The authors emphasize the need for more studies on robotic ethics in innovative contexts, particularly concerning the potential adoption of deceptive techniques by assistive robots. Future work should focus on developing clear guidelines and understanding public perception of these practices.

Summary updated

Abstract

With projections of ageing populations and increasing rates of dementia, there is need for professional caregivers. Assistive robots have been proposed as a solution to this, as they can assist people both physically and socially. However, caregivers often need to use acts of deception (such as misdirection or white lies) in order to ensure necessary care is provided while limiting negative impacts on the cared-for such as emotional distress or loss of dignity. We discuss such use of deception, and contextualise their use within robotics.
BibTeX
@misc{cox2023use,
  author = {Samuel Rhys Cox and Grace Cheong and Wei Tsang Ooi},
  title = {{The use of deception in dementia-care robots: Should robots tell "white lies" to limit emotional distress?}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2309.04267},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04267},
}
Figure