The unusual eruption of the extragalactic classical nova M31N 2017-09A

C. Lloyd, Lewis M. Cook, S. Kiyota, H. Tan, Dan Hu, W. B. Shi, M. Zhang, S. Zhang, X. Zhang, Junming Zhao, G. Sun, Xing GaoObservatory 2020

TL;DR

This paper presents a detailed photometric analysis of the unusual extragalactic classical nova M31N 2017-09A, observed for 160 days. The nova exhibited a complex light curve with multiple bright secondary outbursts and a long decline time, suggesting it might belong to the "jitter" class of novae.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Classical novae are stellar explosions resulting from thermonuclear runaways on white dwarfs. While their recurrence times are typically long (thousands of years), some systems, known as recurrent novae, have much shorter intervals. Understanding the diversity of nova eruptions, their light-curve evolution, and their underlying physics is crucial for comprehending stellar evolution and the pathways to more extreme events like Type Ia supernovae. M31N 2017-09A presented an opportunity to study an extragalactic nova with a particularly complex and prolonged eruption, allowing for a deeper investigation into nova behavior beyond the initial outburst.

Methods

The study relies on extensive photometric observations of M31N 2017-09A collected by a network of observers using various telescopes and CCDs. The data, primarily in unfiltered (CV) or broadband (BVRI) filters, were processed by individual observers before being compiled. The core of the analysis involves fitting power-law models to the light-curve's lower envelope to characterize the decline rate. Two scenarios for fitting the power-law were explored: one assuming the eruption was caught on the rise, and another assuming it occurred between the first two observed points. The researchers also compared the observed parameters with classifications and theoretical models from previous studies, particularly the "jitter" class of novae identified by Strope et al.

Datasets

The primary dataset consists of photometric observations of M31N 2017-09A collected over approximately 160 days following its initial eruption. These observations were contributed by multiple observers and observatories, including the XOSS Group, CBA Concord Observatory, and West Challow Observatory, among others. Additional data from previous studies, such as R-band observations reported by Valcheva et al. and BVRI magnitudes from the XOSS team, were also incorporated.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unusual Complexity: M31N 2017-09A displayed a remarkably complex light curve, deviating from the typical smooth decline of many classical novae. The presence of multiple significant secondary outbursts, nearly as bright as the initial peak, is a key characteristic.
  • "Jitter" Class Candidate: The nova's behavior, particularly its prolonged activity and the nature of its secondary outbursts, strongly suggests it belongs to the "jitter" class of novae, characterized by erratic and extended light curves.
  • Power-Law Decline: Despite the complexity, the lower envelope of the eruption could be reasonably described by a single power-law, indicating an underlying physical process governing the decline.
  • Long Decline Times: The measured $t_2$ (time to decline by 2 magnitudes from peak) and $t_3$ (time to decline by 3 magnitudes from peak) were among the largest observed in similar studies, further supporting its unusual nature.
  • Potential for Understanding Nova Evolution: The detailed analysis of this extragalactic nova provides valuable data for refining models of nova eruptions and understanding the evolutionary pathways of white dwarf systems.

Key Results

  • The eruption was observed for approximately 160 days.
  • The light curve showed continual variation with daily excursions of at least 0.5 magnitudes.
  • The lower envelope of the eruption could be described by a single power-law with a slope ($a_1$) of approximately 0.9.
  • The decline times were measured as $t_2 = 111$ days and $t_3 = 153$ days, which are considered long.
  • The nova is likely a member of the "jitter" class of novae, based on its light-curve characteristics.

Limitations and Future Work

  • CV vs. V Magnitudes: The paper acknowledges that using unfiltered (CV) magnitudes as a proxy for V magnitudes might introduce some uncertainty, although it is argued that for much of the eruption, CV $\approx$ V $\approx$ R. The potential impact of reddening on these measurements is also discussed.
  • Fragmentary Data for Lower Envelope: While M31N 2017-09A is considered one of the best-observed novae in M31 in recent years, the sampling of the lower envelope of the eruption is noted as being fragmentary. This limits the precision with which the underlying power-law can be determined.
  • Comparison with Theoretical Models: The authors suggest that further theoretical work is needed to fully understand the complex behavior observed, particularly the nature and recurrence of the secondary outbursts. Future observations of similar extragalactic novae would be valuable for confirming the classification and refining the understanding of their eruptive processes.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{lloyd2020unusual,
  author = {C. Lloyd and Lewis M. Cook and S. Kiyota and H. Tan and Dan Hu and W. B. Shi and M. Zhang and S. Zhang and X. Zhang and Junming Zhao and G. Sun and Xing Gao},
  title = {{The unusual eruption of the extragalactic classical nova M31N 2017-09A}},
  booktitle = {Observatory},
  year = {2020},
}
Figure