The unidirectional causality influence of factors on PM2.5 in Shenyang city of China

Hongmei Yang, Qin Peng, Jun Zhou, Guojun Song, Xinqi GongScientific 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Air quality issues, specifically particulate matter pollution ($PM_{2.5}$ and $PM_{10}$), represent a significant environmental challenge in China. As a critical industrial and economic hub, Northeast China has faced severe air pollution in recent years, impacting both local public health and the broader East Asian atmospheric environment. This study investigates the temporal-spatial characteristics of particulate matter in Shenyang and analyzes the underlying causal factors. Results indicate that while $PM_{2.5}$ and $PM_{10}$ follow similar variation trends, their annual, monthly, and daily distributions exhibit distinct characteristics. Pollution levels generally decrease from south to north and west to east. Path analysis revealed a complex unidirectional causal relationship between particles and various factors, identifying $NO_2$ and $CO$ as primary drivers of $PM_{2.5}$ concentrations. These findings underscore the need for strategic industrial layout planning and joint prevention measures to mitigate air pollution.

Introduction

While numerous studies have established correlations between air quality, meteorological conditions, and various pollutants, most rely on simple correlation coefficients. These methods often fail to distinguish between direct causal links and indirect associations. This research addresses the complexity of air pollution in Shenyang, a city characterized by a heavy industrial base and significant heating requirements during cold winters. By moving beyond simple correlations, this study maps the "unidirectional causality" of air pollution to better understand the drivers of $PM_{2.5}$ and $PM_{10}$ levels.

Methodology

The study utilized 2017 data from 11 monitoring stations across Shenyang, encompassing rural, urban, and industrial zones. Meteorological data, including atmospheric pressure, temperature, and wind speed, were sourced from the China Meteorological Administration. The analytical framework included:

  • Spearman Correlation: To identify general relationships between pollutants and weather factors.
  • Path Analysis: The core methodology used to decompose relationships into direct and indirect effects.
  • Spatial Autocorrelation (Moran’s I): To identify geographic "hot spots" and "cold spots" of pollution.
  • Statistical Fitting: Binomial and quadratic models were used to analyze annual and daily trends.

Spatial and Temporal Distribution

Pollution in Shenyang follows predictable temporal rhythms. Annually, concentrations form a "saddle" shape, peaking in winter due to coal-based heating and reaching a minimum in summer. Daily distributions are "bimodal," with peaks coinciding with morning rush hour (9:00–10:00 AM) and evening activities.

Spatially, a clear gradient is observed. Pollution levels are highest in the southwest and central regions—areas dominated by industrial activity and high traffic volume—and decrease toward the north and east. Interestingly, these "hot spots" remained remarkably stable across all four seasons, suggesting that local emissions sources outweigh seasonal weather shifts in determining where the air quality is poorest.

Spatial distribution of PM2.5 and PM10 concentrations across Shenyang, showing higher values in the southwest and central regions.

Causal Drivers of Pollution

The application of path analysis provided deeper insights into the factors actually driving $PM_{2.5}$ levels:

  • Gaseous Precursors: $NO_2$ and $CO$ were identified as the primary causal drivers. $NO_2$, largely from vehicle exhaust, showed the strongest direct effect in spring and autumn. $CO$, linked to incomplete combustion, was the dominant factor in winter.
  • Meteorological Inhibitors: Wind speed emerged as the most critical natural cleaning mechanism. High wind speeds consistently showed a strong negative correlation with particulate matter. Conversely, temperature had a negative direct action, as higher temperatures often facilitate convective dispersion.
  • Wind Direction: High $PM_{2.5}$ levels were frequently associated with southwest winds, while cleaner air was typically brought by northwest winds.

Conclusion

The study demonstrates that local emission sources, particularly from industry and transportation, are the primary determinants of pollution "hot spots." The mean annual concentrations of $PM_{2.5}$ ($49 \mu g/m^3$) and $PM_{10}$ ($84.9 \mu g/m^3$) highlight the ongoing challenge of meeting international health guidelines. Effective mitigation will require a combination of industrial restructuring, improved layout planning, and regional joint prevention and control strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Air quality issue such as particulate matter pollution (PM<sub>2.5</sub> and PM<sub>10</sub>) has become one of the biggest environmental problem in China. As one of the most important industrial base and economic core regions of China, Northeast China is facing serious air pollution problems in recent years, which has a profound impact on the health of local residents and atmospheric environment in some part of East Asia. Therefore, it is urgent to understand temporal-spatial characteristics of particles and analyze the causality factors. The results demonstrated that variation trend of particles was almost similar, the annual, monthly and daily distribution had their own characteristics. Particles decreased gradually from south to north, from west to east. Correlation analysis showed that wind speed was the most important factor affecting particles, and temperature, air pressure and relative humidity were key factors in some seasons. Path analysis showed that there was complex unidirectional causal relationship between particles and individual or combined effects, and NO<sub>2</sub> and CO were key factors affecting PM<sub>2.5</sub>. The hot and cold areas changed little with the seasons. All the above results suggests that planning the industrial layout, adjusting industrial structure, joint prevention and control were necessary measure to reduce particles concentration.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2020unidirectional,
  author = {Hongmei Yang and Qin Peng and Jun Zhou and Guojun Song and Xinqi Gong},
  title = {{The unidirectional causality influence of factors on PM2.5 in Shenyang city of China}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-020-65391-5},
}
Figure