The $U(1)_{L_μ-L_τ}$ breaking phase transition, muon $g-2$, dark matter, collider and gravitational wave

Jie Wang, Jinghong Ma, J. Gao, Xiao-Fang Han, Wang, LeiarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper explores an extension of the Standard Model using $U(1)_{L_\mu-L_\tau}$ gauge symmetry to simultaneously resolve the long-standing muon $g-2$ anomaly and provide a viable dark matter candidate. The authors demonstrate that this symmetry-breaking process in the early universe can trigger a first-order phase transition, producing a stochastic gravitational wave background potentially detectable by future space-based observatories like U-DECIGO.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern physics faces two major "cracks" in the Standard Model (SM): the nature of Dark Matter (DM) and the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon (muon $g-2$). Recent experiments at Fermilab have confirmed a significant discrepancy (5.1$\sigma$) between the SM prediction and experimental results for the muon's magnetic moment.

While many models address these separately, this paper tackles them jointly using a $U(1)_{L_\mu-L_\tau}$ symmetry. This specific symmetry is "anomaly-free," meaning it integrates mathematically into the SM without breaking it. It naturally explains why muons and taus might interact with new physics while electrons do not. Furthermore, the paper connects these particle-level mysteries to cosmology by asking: How did this new symmetry break in the early universe, and did it leave a "ringing" sound in the form of gravitational waves?

Methods

The authors construct a model adding several new fields to the SM:

  • Vector-like leptons ($E_1, E_2, N$): These mediate interactions that contribute to the muon $g-2$ value.
  • New Scalars ($S, X$): $S$ breaks the new symmetry, while $X$ provides the dark matter candidate ($X_I$).
  • New Gauge Boson ($Z'$): The force carrier for the $U(1)_{L_\mu-L_\tau}$ symmetry.

To validate the model, they employed a multi-pronged numerical approach:

  1. Parameter Scanning: They performed a random scan over the mass and coupling parameters, ensuring vacuum stability and perturbativity.
  2. Dark Matter Physics: Used micrOMEGAs to calculate the DM relic density and ensure it matches Planck satellite observations.
  3. Thermal Effective Potential: They calculated the finite-temperature effective potential (including 1-loop Coleman-Weinberg and "daisy" corrections) to track how the universe transitioned from a symmetric state to the current broken state.
  4. Collider Simulation: They simulated LHC collisions using MadAnalysis5 and MG5_aMC to see if their predicted particles would have been excluded by existing ATLAS data (specifically searches for two leptons plus missing transverse energy).

Datasets

The study relies on constraints from several high-profile experimental datasets and theoretical bounds:

  • Muon $g-2$: Combined data from Fermilab (E989) and Brookhaven (E821).
  • DM Relic Density: Planck 2018 results ($\Omega_c h^2 = 0.1198 \pm 0.0015$).
  • LHC Data: ATLAS analysis of $2\ell + E_T^{miss}$ with $139 \text{ fb}^{-1}$ of integrated luminosity.
  • Neutrino Trident Process: Constraints on the $Z'$ coupling from neutrino scattering experiments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Mass Gap" Constraint: A joint explanation for DM and muon $g-2$ is only possible if the new particles (vector-like leptons and the $Z'$ boson) are not significantly heavier than the DM candidate itself. If they are too heavy, the interactions required to fix the muon $g-2$ would lead to an overabundance of dark matter in the early universe.
  • First-Order Phase Transitions (FOPT): The model can achieve a strong FOPT, which is characterized by the formation and collision of "bubbles" of the new vacuum state in the early universe.
  • Sensitivity to $\lambda_S$: The strength of this phase transition is highly sensitive to the scalar self-coupling $\lambda_S$. Smaller values of $\lambda_S$ lead to a lower critical temperature and a much stronger phase transition, which in turn produces louder gravitational waves.
  • LHC "Blind Spots": The LHC's ability to exclude this model drops when the mass difference between the vector-like leptons and the DM candidate is small. In these "compressed spectra" regions, the resulting muons have very low energy ("soft"), making them difficult for detectors to distinguish from background noise.

Key Results

  • Gravitational Wave Signature: The predicted gravitational wave spectra from the phase transition peak between $0.003 \text{ Hz}$ and $0.2 \text{ Hz}$. While these signals are generally below the sensitivity of LISA or BBO, they are within the reach of the proposed U-DECIGO (Ultimate DECIGO) detector.
  • LHC Bounds: Direct searches at the LHC impose a lower bound on the DM mass of approximately $100 \text{ GeV}$ in most scenarios, though this varies based on the mass of the vector-like lepton partners.
  • Benchmark Points: The authors identified two specific benchmark points (BP1 and BP2) that satisfy all current experimental constraints while providing a clear roadmap for future gravitational wave detection.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Detection Gap: The primary limitation is that the predicted gravitational wave signal is quite faint, requiring "ultimate" generation detectors that are decades away from deployment.
  • Simplified Couplings: To avoid stringent direct detection bounds for DM, the authors assumed certain Higgs-DM couplings were zero. Future studies could explore the "blind spots" where these couplings are non-zero but still evade detection.
  • Sound Wave Dominance: The GW analysis focused primarily on sound waves in the plasma. While usually the dominant source, a more exhaustive study could include the contributions from magneto-hydrodynamics turbulence in greater detail.

Summary updated

Abstract

Combining the dark matter and muon $g-2$ anomaly, we study the $U(1)_{L_μ-L_τ}$ breaking phase transition, gravitational wave spectra, and the direct detection at the LHC in an extra $U(1)_{L_μ-L_τ}$ gauge symmetry extension of the standard model. The new fields includes vector-like leptons ($E_1,~ E_2,~ N$), $U(1)_{L_μ-L_τ}$ breaking scalar $S$ and gauge boson $Z'$, as well as the dark matter candidate $X_I$ and its heavy partner $X_R$. A joint explanation of the dark matter relic density and muon $g-2$ anomaly excludes the region where both $min(m_{E_1},m_{E_2},m_N,m_{X_R})$ and $min(m_{Z'},m_S)$ are much larger than $m_{X_I}$. In the parameter space accommodating the DM relic density and muon $g-2$ anomaly, the model can achieve a first order $U(1)_{L_μ-L_τ}$ breaking phase transition, whose strength is sensitive to the parameters of Higgs potential. The corresponding gravitational wave spectra can reach the sensitivity of U-DECIGO. In addition, the direct searches at the LHC impose stringent bound on the mass spectra of the vector-like leptons and dark matter.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2023u,
  author = {Jie Wang and Jinghong Ma and J. Gao and Xiao-Fang Han and Wang, Lei},
  title = {{The $U(1)\_\{L\_μ-L\_τ\}$ breaking phase transition, muon $g-2$, dark matter, collider and gravitational wave}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2309.09210},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09210},
}

Loading related content...

Figure