The Transformation of Social Class Determinants for Environmental Willingness to Pay: Evidence from China (2010 & 2021)

Kaichun Lei, Xiaonan WangJournal of Management and Social Development 2025 · DOI

Abstract: This study uses data from the 2010 and 2021 China General Social Survey (CGSS) to examine the impact and changes of different social class factors (traditional, local, and subjective) on the willingness of Chinese residents to pay for environmental protection. The results show that, compared to 2010, Chinese residents' willingness to pay for environmental protection in 2021 is higher. In 2010, individuals in higher occupational classes, those with a political affiliation, and those with a stronger future class identity had a higher willingness to pay for environmental protection, while individuals in the middle-income group had a relatively lower willingness. However, in 2021, only individuals with a political affiliation, and those with a stronger childhood and future class identity, had significantly higher willingness to pay for environmental protection. The study suggests that, while overall willingness to pay for environmental protection has increased, the influence of traditional social class factors has weakened. Meanwhile, the influence of local class factors, such as political affiliation, and subjective class factors, such as childhood and future class identity, has become stronger.

Introduction

As China transitioned through a decade of rapid economic growth and intensifying environmental regulation, the social drivers of environmental support underwent a significant transformation. Traditionally, environmentalism has been viewed through a "post-materialist" lens, suggesting that as individuals achieve higher economic status, they prioritize environmental quality. This study investigates whether this paradigm holds true in the unique sociopolitical context of China by comparing data from 2010 and 2021. The research reveals a profound shift: environmental commitment has evolved from a concern primarily associated with the elite to a broad social value driven by political identity and future aspirations.

Methodology

The study utilizes two waves of the China General Social Survey (CGSS): the 2010 wave (n=2,085) and the 2021 wave (n=1,380). The researchers employed stepwise Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) regression to analyze the impact of three distinct social class frameworks on "Willingness to Pay" (WTP):

  1. Traditional Class Variables (TCV): Education, occupation, and income.
  2. Native/Localized Class Variables (NCV): Hukou status, political affiliation, state-sector employment, and homeownership.
  3. Subjective Class Variables (SCV): Self-assessed social standing during childhood (age 14), the present, and the predicted future (10 years from now).

WTP was measured as a composite factor score derived from three indicators: willingness to pay higher prices, pay higher taxes, and accept a lower standard of living for environmental protection.

The Rise of Environmental Commitment

Between 2010 and 2021, the overall willingness of Chinese residents to contribute financially to environmental protection increased. The mean composite WTP score rose from 49.76 to 51.27. Interestingly, while the willingness to pay higher prices and taxes increased, the willingness to accept a lower standard of living showed a slight decline, suggesting a public preference for "green growth" over personal sacrifice.

Willingness to Pay (WTP) Items and Composite Scores (2010 vs 2021)

The Shifting Drivers of WTP

The regression analysis reveals a clear weakening of traditional class markers and a strengthening of political and subjective factors over the decade.

Weakening of Traditional Markers

In 2010, occupational class was a strong predictor of WTP, with managers and professionals showing significantly higher commitment. By 2021, these effects largely vanished. Similarly, the "U-shaped" income curve observed in 2010—where both high and low-income groups showed higher WTP than the middle class—disappeared by 2021, indicating a narrowing of class-based environmental attitudes.

Strengthening of Political and Subjective Identity

One of the most striking findings is the increased influence of political affiliation. The regression coefficient for political membership rose significantly from 2010 to 2021, suggesting that political identity now carries a stronger internalized expectation of social responsibility regarding national environmental goals.

Furthermore, subjective class perceptions have become critical. Future Class Identity—the belief that one will move up the social ladder—remains a consistent and strong predictor of WTP. Additionally, Childhood Class Identity emerged as a significant positive factor in 2021, highlighting the long-term impact of early-life socialization on environmental values.

Regression Analysis of Factors Influencing Environmental WTP

Conclusion

The findings suggest that environmentalism in China is no longer a "luxury" concern of the elite but has become a cross-cutting social value. The influence of objective economic status has been superseded by political identity and subjective aspirations. As China continues to promote its "Ecological Civilization" strategy, environmental protection is increasingly viewed not just as a financial burden, but as a shared social responsibility and an investment in a better future.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study uses data from the 2010 and 2021 China General Social Survey (CGSS) to examine the impact and changes of different social class factors (traditional, local, and subjective) on the willingness of Chinese residents to pay for environmental protection. The results show that, compared to 2010, Chinese residents' willingness to pay for environmental protection in 2021 is higher. In 2010, individuals in higher occupational classes, those with a political affiliation, and those with a stronger future class identity had a higher willingness to pay for environmental protection, while individuals in the middle-income group had a relatively lower willingness. However, in 2021, only individuals with a political affiliation, and those with a stronger childhood and future class identity, had significantly higher willingness to pay for environmental protection. The study suggests that, while overall willingness to pay for environmental protection has increased, the influence of traditional social class factors has weakened. Meanwhile, the influence of local class factors, such as political affiliation, and subjective class factors, such as childhood and future class identity, has become stronger.
BibTeX
@article{lei2025transformation,
  author = {Kaichun Lei and Xiaonan Wang},
  title = {{The Transformation of Social Class Determinants for Environmental Willingness to Pay: Evidence from China (2010 \& 2021)}},
  journal = {Journal of management and social development.},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.62517/jmsd.202512515},
}
Figure