The transdiagnostic structure of mental effort avoidance

Edward H. Patzelt, Wouter Kool, Alexander J. Millner, Samuel J. GershmanScientific 2019 · DOI

Abstract

The law of least mental effort states that, everything else being equal, the brain tries to minimize mental effort expenditure during task performance by avoiding decisions that require greater cognitive demands. Prior studies have shown associations between disruptions in effort expenditure and specific psychiatric illnesses (e.g., schizophrenia and depression) or clinically-related symptoms and traits (e.g., anhedonia and apathy), yet no research has explored this issue transdiagnostically. Specifically, this research has largely focused on a single diagnostic category, symptom, or trait. However, abnormalities in effort expression could be related to several different psychiatrically-relevant constructs that cut across diagnostic boundaries. Therefore, we examined the relationship between avoidance of mental effort and a diverse set of clinically-related symptoms and traits, and transdiagnostic latent factors in a large sample (n = 811). Only lack of perseverance, a dimension of impulsiveness, was associated with increased avoidance of mental effort. In contrast, several constructs were associated with less mental effort avoidance, including positive urgency, distress intolerance, obsessive-compulsive symptoms, disordered eating, and a factor consisting of compulsive behavior and intrusive thoughts. These findings demonstrate that deviations from normative effort expenditure are associated with a number of constructs that are common to several forms of psychiatric illness.

Introduction

The human brain is often described as a "cognitive miser," generally preferring the path of least resistance when faced with tasks requiring mental effort. This "law of least mental effort" suggests that we naturally seek to minimize cognitive demand. In clinical psychology, disruptions to this law are common; for instance, individuals with depression may exhibit avolition, while those with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) might exert excessive effort on non-adaptive behaviors.

Historically, research has focused on single diagnostic categories. However, mental health symptoms frequently transcend the boundaries of traditional diagnostic frameworks. This study adopts a transdiagnostic approach, investigating how specific traits and "latent factors"—symptom clusters that cut across different disorders—relate to the avoidance of mental effort in a large, diverse sample.

Methods

The researchers recruited 811 participants via Amazon Mechanical Turk to perform the Demand Selection Task (DST). In this task, participants were presented with two visual cues. One cue (high-demand) led to a task requiring frequent "task switching" (90% of the time), while the other (low-demand) required switching only 10% of the time. Task switching serves as a well-established proxy for cognitive effort.

The Demand Selection Task (DST) trial sequence. Participants choose between high-effort (90% switching) and low-effort (10% switching) cues.

Participants also completed 19 self-report scales covering a wide range of psychiatric symptoms, including depression, social anxiety, impulsivity, and eating disorders. The relationship between these traits and effort avoidance was analyzed using Bayesian linear regression and Elastic Net regularization. Additionally, Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) was used to group symptoms into three transdiagnostic factors: anxious depression, compulsive behavior and intrusive thought, and social withdrawal.

Results

On average, participants selected the low-effort option 65% of the time, confirming the general bias toward minimizing effort. As shown in the behavioral data, participants learned to prefer the low-demand option over the course of the trials, with a clear distribution of preferences across the sample.

Behavioral results showing the learning of demand preferences (A) and the distribution of low-demand choices across participants (B).

Key findings include:

  • The Compulsivity Paradox: Individuals scoring high on the "compulsive behavior and intrusive thought" factor, as well as those with obsessive-compulsive symptoms and disordered eating, showed less avoidance of mental effort (99.1% posterior probability). This suggests that some forms of psychopathology involve over-exertion or a failure to properly weigh cognitive costs.
  • Perseverance and Avoidance: "Lack of perseverance" was the only trait significantly associated with increased effort avoidance (96% probability), bridging subjective self-reports with objective behavioral data.
  • Intelligence and Cost Sensitivity: Higher IQ was associated with greater demand avoidance, suggesting that more cognitively capable individuals may be more sensitive to cognitive costs and seek to optimize resources.
  • Other Associations: Distress intolerance (98% probability) and positive urgency (98.1% probability) were also linked to increased effort expenditure.

Discussion

These findings demonstrate that deviations from normative effort expenditure are a hallmark of various psychiatric traits, though the direction of deviation depends on the specific symptom cluster. The study highlights the importance of looking beyond single diagnoses to understand the cognitive mechanisms underlying psychopathology.

Future work should address potential confounds, such as whether participants choose high-effort tasks due to a preference or a deficit in estimating costs versus error risks. Additionally, while the large MTurk sample provides robust data, replication in formal clinical populations is necessary to confirm these transdiagnostic patterns. Understanding whether these associations stem from deficits in cost-benefit analysis or failures in maintaining mental representations will be a key next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

The law of least mental effort states that, everything else being equal, the brain tries to minimize mental effort expenditure during task performance by avoiding decisions that require greater cognitive demands. Prior studies have shown associations between disruptions in effort expenditure and specific psychiatric illnesses (e.g., schizophrenia and depression) or clinically-related symptoms and traits (e.g., anhedonia and apathy), yet no research has explored this issue transdiagnostically. Specifically, this research has largely focused on a single diagnostic category, symptom, or trait. However, abnormalities in effort expression could be related to several different psychiatrically-relevant constructs that cut across diagnostic boundaries. Therefore, we examined the relationship between avoidance of mental effort and a diverse set of clinically-related symptoms and traits, and transdiagnostic latent factors in a large sample (n = 811). Only lack of perseverance, a dimension of impulsiveness, was associated with increased avoidance of mental effort. In contrast, several constructs were associated with less mental effort avoidance, including positive urgency, distress intolerance, obsessive-compulsive symptoms, disordered eating, and a factor consisting of compulsive behavior and intrusive thoughts. These findings demonstrate that deviations from normative effort expenditure are associated with a number of constructs that are common to several forms of psychiatric illness.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{patzelt2019transdiagnostic,
  author = {Edward H. Patzelt and Wouter Kool and Alexander J. Millner and Samuel J. Gershman},
  title = {{The transdiagnostic structure of mental effort avoidance}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-018-37802-1},
}
Figure