The Time Preference of Chinese Tend to be Less Affected by Positive Emotions: As Proved by an Experimental Study

Yingnan Shi, Xinghao LiJournal of Economics and Behavioral Studies 2017 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigates whether positive emotions influence the intertemporal choices of Chinese participants differently than their American counterparts. Using a controlled experiment with 60 Chinese students, the research explores the intersection of culture, emotion, and economic "patience." Results indicate that while positive affect does increase patience in Chinese subjects, the effect is significantly dampened compared to American benchmarks. Additionally, risk neutrality was found to be a strong predictor of lower time preference.

Introduction: The Cultural Dimension of Economic Patience

In behavioral economics, "Time Preference" (TP) quantifies how individuals discount future rewards relative to immediate ones. A high TP indicates a preference for "now," while a low TP suggests greater patience. Previous research, notably by Ifcher and Zarghamee (2011), demonstrated that positive emotions significantly reduce TP in American subjects, making them more forward-looking and patient.

Benchmark data from American studies showing the relationship between imputed discount factors and time horizons.

However, cultural psychology suggests that Chinese national characteristics—often described as "inward-oriented" with an emphasis on emotional moderation—might alter this emotional-economic link. This paper tests the hypothesis that cultural background serves as a buffer, reducing the impact of transient emotions on long-term financial decision-making. Understanding this gap helps explain cross-cultural differences in consumer behavior, such as credit card usage and long-term investment strategies.

Methodology

The researchers conducted a controlled experiment with 60 undergraduate students in Zhuhai, China. The study employed several rigorous mechanisms:

  • Mood Induction: Participants were randomly assigned to watch either a funny film clip (treatment) or a neutral clip (control) to induce specific affective states.
  • Risk Preference Assessment: Using a Multiple Price List (MPL) method, participants were categorized as risk-averse, risk-neutral, or risk-seeking based on lottery choices.
  • Time Preference Measurement: Participants evaluated 15 intertemporal choices (e.g., receiving ¥15.20 today versus in 41 days).
  • Incentive Compatibility: The Becker-DeGroot-Marschak (BDM) mechanism was used to ensure truthful reporting. Participants' actual payouts were determined by comparing their stated values against a random draw, making honest valuation the mathematically optimal strategy.

Key Results and Insights

The study confirmed that positive emotions do increase patience among Chinese participants, but the magnitude is smaller than that seen in Western cohorts.

Mean present value (D) as a function of time (t) for various reward amounts (m) in the Chinese cohort.

The "Happiness Buffer"

The positive-affect treatment increased the subjective present value of future payments by an average of 1.44 units. While statistically significant, this shift is less pronounced than in American studies, supporting the theory of cultural emotional moderation. The PNAS (Positive and Negative Affect Schedule) confirmed that the funny clips successfully raised the "net positive affect" to 7.069 in the treatment group, compared to 2.571 in the control group.

The Role of Risk Neutrality

A primary finding was the "Risk-Neutral Advantage." Risk-neutral individuals exhibited the highest levels of patience. Specifically, they valued future payments ¥2.91 higher (in present equivalent terms) than risk-averse participants. This suggests that those who are indifferent to risk are also more capable of objective intertemporal valuation, whereas risk-takers may seek immediate capital and risk-avoiders may fear future uncertainty.

Demographic Correlations

  • Gender: Males demonstrated higher patience (lower TP) than females, valuing present equivalents ¥2.02 higher on average.
  • Socioeconomics: Higher family income correlated with lower TP, suggesting that financial security facilitates a longer-term outlook.
  • Health: The relationship between health and patience followed an inverted U-shape; while generally healthy individuals were more patient, the "healthiest" group showed a slight increase in time preference.

Conclusion and Limitations

This research highlights that economic models of emotion must account for cultural context. The dampened effect of happiness on Chinese time preference may help explain broader economic phenomena, such as high savings rates and different credit card usage patterns in China compared to the US.

Limitations: The study's reliance on a student population may limit generalizability to the broader Chinese demographic. Furthermore, the study focused exclusively on positive emotions; the impact of negative affect (e.g., stress or sadness) and the differing purchasing power of currencies remain areas for future investigation.

Published in the Journal of Economics and Behavioral Studies, Vol. 9, No. 4, August 2017.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper aims at testing whether positive emotions have a different impact on Chinese participants’ time preference choices from American respondents on average, considering that the Chinese people own a different culture background and more inward-oriented national characteristic. The researcher conducted a controlled experiment based on random assignments, and the experiment is specifically adapted for Chinese participants. Further, in order to approach to a more accurate result, the research also determines such effect is influenced, if any, by personality factors such as risk preference. The BDM (Becker-DeGroot-Marschak) and an MPL(Multiple Price List)methods were utilized to gather sufficient data and to ensure accurate measures. This paper indicates that, on average, for a Chinese participant, positive emotion will still reduce their time preference over intertemporal decision regarding to cash payment, but in a smaller amount on average, compared to an American respondent. Also, the result shows that, risk preference does play a role and tend to risk neutral persons have a weaker time-preference, compared to risk-takers and risk-avoiders. Moreover, several other factors, such as the health state, family income, and gender may also have correlation with time preferences. Alternative explanations are proposed at the end. This research may contribute to explain the differences of credit card usages preferences between the Chinese and American consumers and to explicate the reasoning of the Chinese economic miracles in the recent decades.
BibTeX
@article{shi2017time,
  author = {Yingnan Shi and Xinghao Li},
  title = {{The Time Preference of Chinese Tend to be Less Affected by Positive Emotions: As Proved by an Experimental Study}},
  journal = {Journal of Economics and Behavioral Studies},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.22610/jebs.v9i4(j).1834},
}
Figure