The terrestrial carbon cycle: Implications for the Kyoto Protocol

Will Steffen, Wolfgang Crämer, Josep G. Canadell, Graham D. Farquhar, Ernst‐Detlef Schulze, Jarvis, P.g., Dennis Baldocchi, Philippe Ciais, J. R. Ehleringer, Christopher B. Field, Ahmad Nauman Ghazi, R. Gifford, Martin Heimann, R. A. Houghton, P. Kabat, Christian Körner, Éric F. Lambin, S.p. Linder, Harold A. Mooney, Daniel Murdiyarso, W. M. Post, I. Colin Prentice, Michael Raupach, David Schimel, А. Shvidenko, Riccardo ValentiniSocio-Environmental 1998 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper critically examines the Kyoto Protocol's approach to terrestrial carbon sinks, arguing that its narrow focus on "Kyoto forests" is insufficient for effectively stabilizing atmospheric greenhouse gases. The authors advocate for a comprehensive, full-system carbon budget approach to accurately account for all terrestrial sources and sinks, ensuring the protocol's long-term effectiveness.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Kyoto Protocol, established to combat climate change by reducing greenhouse gas emissions, includes provisions for terrestrial carbon sinks. However, the protocol's definition of these sinks is limited to specific activities like afforestation and reforestation within a defined period ("Kyoto forests"). This narrow scope presents a significant problem because it overlooks the vast and dynamic role of the entire terrestrial biosphere, including soils and unmanaged ecosystems, in regulating atmospheric CO2. The paper highlights the risk that this limited accounting system could lead to counterproductive actions and ultimately fail to achieve the protocol's overarching goal of stabilizing greenhouse gas levels. The authors aim to demonstrate the limitations of the Kyoto Protocol's approach and propose a more holistic framework for carbon accounting.

Methods

The paper doesn't present novel experimental methods or algorithms in the traditional sense. Instead, it focuses on a critical analysis and conceptual framework for carbon accounting. The authors draw upon existing scientific understanding of the terrestrial carbon cycle, including concepts like Gross Primary Production (GPP), Net Primary Production (NPP), Net Ecosystem Production (NEP), and Net Biome Production (NBP). They advocate for the application of a "full carbon budget" approach, which involves:

  • Comprehensive Accounting: Including all terrestrial ecosystems (managed and unmanaged) and all carbon fluxes (sources and sinks).
  • Long-Term Perspective: Considering carbon storage over sufficient time scales to reflect changes in NBP, rather than focusing solely on short-term commitment periods.
  • Integrated Measurement Systems: Utilizing a combination of direct flux measurements (e.g., eddy covariance), satellite remote sensing, and ecosystem/biospheric models to extrapolate data and improve understanding across various spatial and temporal scales.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on existing scientific literature and data to support its arguments about the terrestrial carbon cycle and the Kyoto Protocol.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Kyoto Protocol's "Kyoto Forests" are a small subset: The protocol's focus on afforestation, reforestation, and deforestation in Annex 1 countries represents only a fraction of the total terrestrial carbon budget.
  • Terrestrial sinks are temporary buffers, not permanent offsets: While terrestrial sinks can temporarily absorb fossil fuel emissions, they are part of an active biological cycle and are vulnerable to returning carbon to the atmosphere. They buy time, but don't eliminate the need to reduce fossil fuel emissions.
  • The "gross-net disparity" is a loophole: The protocol's baseline for emissions reduction targets excludes terrestrial sinks, creating a "gross-net disparity" that can reduce the perceived need for fossil fuel emission reductions for some nations.
  • Partial budgets create perverse incentives: Applying a carbon budget to discontinuous "commitment" periods can lead to counterproductive actions, such as emissions occurring between periods not being counted.
  • A full carbon budget is essential for effectiveness: To truly stabilize greenhouse gases, accounting must encompass all terrestrial ecosystems, both managed and unmanaged, to identify and potentially enhance all sinks, minimize sources, and avoid surprises from unmanaged systems.
  • Integrated measurement and modeling are crucial: Combining direct flux measurements, remote sensing, and ecosystem models is necessary to accurately assess carbon stocks and fluxes across scales and over time.

Key Results

The paper does not present quantitative results in the form of experimental outcomes. Instead, its key "results" are conceptual and analytical:

  • Identification of flaws in the Kyoto Protocol's accounting framework: The paper clearly articulates the limitations and potential negative consequences of the protocol's narrow definition of terrestrial carbon sinks.
  • Quantification of the terrestrial carbon budget: The paper provides figures for the annual increase in atmospheric CO2 driven by fossil fuels and deforestation, and the absorption by terrestrial ecosystems and oceans, highlighting the net accumulation of CO2 in the atmosphere. For example, it states that fossil fuels and industrial activity contribute 5.5 Gt (now 6.5 Gt) of carbon per year, deforestation adds 1.6 Gt, and terrestrial ecosystems and oceans absorb some, resulting in an average accumulation of 3.4 Gt per year.
  • Advocacy for a comprehensive accounting system: The paper strongly argues that a full carbon budget, applied over sufficient time scales, is the appropriate basis for any accounting system for terrestrial carbon.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • Uncertainty in measurements: The paper acknowledges that differences in stock estimates made only 5 years apart may not be sufficiently accurate for measuring fluxes without supportive measurements.
  • Complexity of the terrestrial carbon cycle: The paper highlights the inherent uncertainties in estimating carbon fluxes associated with land-use change and forestry.
  • Protocol's reliance on 1990 estimates: The use of 1990 estimates as a baseline for emission reduction targets is noted as a point of contention.

Future Work:

  • Clarification of protocol clauses: The paper calls for clarification on which carbon stocks are included in the protocol's measurements.
  • Development of supportive measurements: The need for additional measurement techniques to accurately assess carbon fluxes is emphasized.
  • Application of appropriate inventory techniques: The authors suggest that these techniques can reduce uncertainties in estimating carbon fluxes.
  • Integration of ecosystem and biospheric models: The paper advocates for using these models, coupled with remote sensing data, to extrapolate flux and process measurements to regional, national, and global scales.
  • Inclusion of all terrestrial ecosystems: The authors strongly recommend that eventually, all terrestrial ecosystems, both managed and unmanaged, should be included in accounting systems.
  • Improvement of measurement and verification tools: The paper suggests that an integrated system of monitoring carbon stocks and direct flux measurements, with improvements over the next decade, will provide a verification tool for a full carbon budget.

Summary updated

Abstract

Author: IGBP Terrestrial Carbon Working Group et al.; Genre: Journal Article; Issued: 1998; Keywords: Multidisciplinary Multidisciplinary Multidisciplinary; Title: The terrestrial carbon cycle: implications for the Kyoto protocol
BibTeX
@inproceedings{steffen1998terrestrial,
  author = {Will Steffen and Wolfgang Crämer and Josep G. Canadell and Graham D. Farquhar and Ernst‐Detlef Schulze and Jarvis, P.G. and Dennis Baldocchi and Philippe Ciais and Wolfgang Crämer and J. R. Ehleringer and Graham D. Farquhar and Christopher B. Field and Ahmad Nauman Ghazi and R. Gifford and Martin Heimann and R. A. Houghton and P. Kabat and Christian Körner and Éric F. Lambin and S.P. Linder and Harold A. Mooney and Daniel Murdiyarso and W. M. Post and I. Colin Prentice and Michael Raupach and David Schimel and А. Shvidenko and Riccardo Valentini},
  title = {{The terrestrial carbon cycle: Implications for the Kyoto Protocol}},
  booktitle = {Socio-Environmental},
  year = {1998},
  doi = {10.1126/science.280.5368.1393},
}
Figure