The Temporal–Spatial Dynamic Distributions of Soil Water and Salt under Deep Vertical Rotary Tillage on Coastal Saline Soil

Wenxiu Li, Jingsong Yang, Chong Tang, Xiaoyuan Liu, Wenping Xie, Rongjiang Yao, Xiangping WangWater 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how deep vertical rotary tillage, a novel soil cultivation technique, impacts water and salt movement in coastal saline soils with shallow groundwater. The findings demonstrate that deeper vertical tillage (40 cm) significantly enhances water infiltration, soil water retention, and salt leaching compared to traditional methods, offering a promising solution for improving saline agricultural lands.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coastal regions often face significant challenges with soil salinization, which severely limits agricultural productivity. Traditional tillage methods can sometimes exacerbate these issues by creating dense soil layers that hinder water infiltration and salt leaching. While deep vertical rotary tillage has shown promise in improving soil structure and water movement, its specific effects on the temporal and spatial distribution of soil water and salt, particularly in areas with shallow, mineralized groundwater, remain under-explored. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by evaluating the efficacy of deep vertical rotary tillage at different depths in managing water and salt dynamics in such challenging environments.

Methods

The researchers conducted a controlled soil column experiment to compare three tillage treatments:

  • XG-20: Traditional rotary tillage to a depth of 20 cm.
  • FL-20: Deep vertical rotary tillage to a depth of 20 cm.
  • FL-40: Deep vertical rotary tillage to a depth of 40 cm.

Soil columns were prepared with a base layer of quartz sand and then filled with sieved saline soil to a height of 110 cm. The tillage treatments were simulated using a small rotary cultivator for XG-20 and a hand electric drill with an auger for FL-20 and FL-40, ensuring the machine speed mimicked field conditions.

The experiment involved two irrigation events over a 37-day period, simulating natural rainfall patterns. Soil water content and electrical conductivity (EC, an indicator of salt concentration) were measured at various depths (10, 20, 40, 60, and 80 cm) at different time points (4, 19, and 37 days after the first irrigation). Evaporation was also monitored. The study analyzed the temporal-spatial dynamics of soil water and salt, infiltration rates, and desalinization rates. Statistical analysis, including one-way ANOVA, was used to determine the significance of the observed differences.

Datasets

The study utilized soil samples collected from the Dong Tai Ecological Research Station of Coastal Wetland in Jiangsu Province, China. The physical and chemical properties of this soil were characterized, including pH, EC, salinity content, sand, silt, and clay content, classifying it as silt loam. Meteorological data from 2000-2012 were used as a reference for simulating precipitation and irrigation amounts.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Deep Vertical Rotary Tillage is a Game Changer: The core insight is that deep vertical rotary tillage, especially at greater depths (40 cm), fundamentally alters soil structure in a way that significantly benefits water and salt management in saline soils.
  • Breaking the Capillary Barrier: By smashing deep soil without disturbing the topsoil layer, this method appears to disrupt capillary action, which is crucial for preventing the upward movement of salt towards the root zone, especially in the presence of shallow groundwater.
  • Depth Matters: The study strongly suggests that the effectiveness of deep vertical rotary tillage is directly proportional to its depth. FL-40 consistently outperformed FL-20 and XG-20 across most measured parameters.
  • Improved Water Infiltration and Retention: The loosened soil structure created by FL-40 allows for much higher water infiltration rates and increased water retention in deeper soil layers, which is vital for crop survival during dry periods.
  • Enhanced Salt Leaching: The improved water movement facilitates the downward movement of salts, leading to a significant reduction in salinity within the root zone.

Key Results

  • Infiltration Rate: The average infiltration rate in the 0-40 cm soil layer for FL-40 was 1.25 cm h⁻¹ higher than XG-20 and 0.46 cm h⁻¹ higher than FL-20.
  • Soil Water Content: Soil water content followed the order FL-40 > FL-20 > XG-20, with FL-40 showing significantly increased water content in the 40-60 cm layers.
  • Desalinization Rate: The FL-40 treatment showed a significantly higher desalinization rate, with average increases of 16.32% and 13.99% compared to XG-20 and FL-20, respectively, in the 0-60 cm soil layer.
  • Electrical Conductivity (EC): EC values decreased more significantly with FL-40, indicating a greater reduction in salt concentration.
  • Salt Accumulation: While salt accumulation was observed in the 60 cm layer across all treatments, it was lowest in the FL-40 treatment, suggesting better long-term salt management.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that this study was conducted as a preliminary soil column experiment under controlled laboratory conditions, without vegetation and with simplified environmental factors. They note that natural conditions, including atmospheric influences and groundwater dynamics, can differ significantly. Therefore, they emphasize the need for field validation of these findings. Future work should include field experiments to verify the results and further investigate the combined effects of deep vertical rotary tillage with other management practices, such as dark pipe drainage, to address saline alkali barriers more comprehensively. The study also suggests exploring the long-term impacts of this tillage method on soil properties and crop yields.

Summary updated

Abstract

Different from the traditional deep tillage, deep vertical rotary tillage can smash deep soil without disturbing the soil layer, which improves soil water infiltration and promotes salt leaching. This has gradually been applied in the research into saline alkali improvements. However, there is limited knowledge about the effect of deep vertical rotary tillage on the temporal–spatial distributions of soil water and salt under the shallow underground water level. Therefore, a preliminary soil column experiment was carried out to explore the results of water and salt movement under three different tillage methods: traditional rotary tillage depth of 20 cm (XG−20), deep vertical rotary tillage depth of 20 cm (FL−20) and deep vertical rotary tillage depth of 40 cm (FL−40). The temporal–spatial variation in soil water and salt was analyzed. The results showed that the average infiltration rate of FL−40 increased by 1.25 and 0.46 cm h−1 in 0−40 cm soil layer compared with that of XG−20 and FL−20. At the same time, soil water content was also increased, and the order of soil water content was FL−40 > FL−20 > XG−20. With the increase in tillage depth, the desalinization rate and the soil electric conductivity (EC) of FL−40 were increased and decreased, respectively. The FL−40 treatment’s average desalinization rates increased by 16.32% and 13.99% compared with XG−20 and FL−20 treatments’ in 0−60 cm soil layer. In conclusion, FL−40 had a better effect on regulating water and salt. The deep vertical rotary tillage provided an effective method for the control and optimization of water and salt in coastal saline soil.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2022temporalspatial,
  author = {Wenxiu Li and Jingsong Yang and Chong Tang and Xiaoyuan Liu and Wenping Xie and Rongjiang Yao and Xiangping Wang},
  title = {{The Temporal–Spatial Dynamic Distributions of Soil Water and Salt under Deep Vertical Rotary Tillage on Coastal Saline Soil}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/w14213370},
}
Figure