The temperature-dependence of host–guest binding thermodynamics: experimental and simulation studies

Laura Grimm, Jeffry Setiadi, Boryslav A. Tkachenko, Peter R. Schreiner, Michael K. Gilson, Frank BiedermannChemical 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study combines experimental (ITC) and computational (MD simulations) approaches to investigate how temperature affects the thermodynamics of host-guest binding in water. They found that negative heat capacity changes are a universal feature, indicating that binding becomes more enthalpically favorable at higher temperatures due to altered water solvation. This work sheds light on the crucial role of water in molecular recognition, with implications for drug design and understanding complex biological systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding molecular interactions in water is fundamental to fields like biochemistry and pharmacology, as it underpins the design of drugs and therapeutic agents. Water, however, is a complex solvent, and disentangling its contribution to binding thermodynamics from direct solute-solute interactions is a significant challenge. While the hydrophobic effect is often cited as a driving force for binding, its precise role and the underlying mechanisms, particularly how they change with temperature, remain debated. Simple, rigid host-guest systems offer a tractable model to isolate and study these effects. However, obtaining a complete thermodynamic profile (ΔG, ΔH, ΔS, and ΔCp) experimentally can be difficult, and existing computational methods sometimes struggle to accurately capture solvation effects, especially in confined environments like host cavities. This paper aims to address these challenges by providing a comprehensive, temperature-dependent thermodynamic analysis of well-defined host-guest systems, leveraging both experimental and computational techniques to elucidate the role of water.

Methods

The researchers employed a dual approach:

  • Isothermal Titration Calorimetry (ITC): This is a standard experimental technique used to directly measure the heat released or absorbed during a binding event. By performing ITC experiments across a temperature range (278 K to 328 K in 10 K steps), they were able to determine the temperature dependence of binding thermodynamics (ΔG, ΔH, and ΔS) for 16 different host-guest complexes.
  • Molecular Dynamics (MD) Simulations: These simulations were used to computationally model the host-guest systems. By simulating the molecules and their surrounding water molecules over time, they could calculate binding thermodynamics.
  • Grid Inhomogeneous Solvation Theory (GIST): This computational method was applied to analyze the spatial distribution of solvent (water) and its energetic contributions to the binding process, particularly focusing on heat capacity changes.

The novelty lies in the combined, temperature-dependent analysis of these well-defined systems, allowing for a direct comparison between experimental and computational results and a deeper understanding of solvation effects.

Datasets

The study utilized experimental data from isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) performed on 16 host-guest systems. These systems involved macrocyclic hosts cucurbit[n]urils (CB7 and CB8) and β-cyclodextrin (β-CD) complexed with various electrically neutral, mostly rigid guest molecules, including hydroxylated ferrocene and diamondoid derivatives, as well as more flexible guests like nandrolone, L-phenylalanine, and 1-hexanol. The computational analysis focused on six of these systems involving CB7, CB8, and β-CD with two diamondoid guests (1-AdOH and 4,9-DA(OH)2).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Negative Heat Capacity is a Universal Indicator: The consistent observation of negative changes in heat capacity (ΔCp,b) across all studied host-guest systems, and even in literature data, is a significant finding. This suggests that binding becomes more enthalpically favorable at higher temperatures, a trend that appears to be a general feature of host-guest complexation in water, unlike the more variable entropic and enthalpic contributions.
  • Water's Role Evolves with Temperature: The study strongly implicates water solvation as the primary driver for the observed temperature dependence. As temperature increases, water's solvent properties change, leading to a diminished enthalpic penalty for desolvation (removing water from the host and guest upon binding). This makes binding more favorable from an enthalpy perspective at higher temperatures.
  • Enthalpy-Entropy Compensation is Pervasive: As expected, the researchers observed significant enthalpy-entropy compensation, where changes in enthalpy are largely offset by changes in entropy. This is a common phenomenon in molecular recognition.
  • Hydrogen Bonds are Important, but Not the Whole Story: While hydrogen bond formation plays a role, the study found that the number of hydrogen bonds doesn't perfectly correlate with binding free energy. The overall balance of hydrogen bonds (host-guest, host-water, guest-water, and water-water) provides a better correlation, highlighting the complex interplay of interactions.
  • Force Field Accuracy Matters: The comparison between experimental and computational results revealed discrepancies, suggesting that while the computational models capture general trends, improvements in force fields are still needed for precise quantitative predictions, particularly in accurately representing the balance of solute-solvent and solute-solute interactions.

Key Results

  • Temperature-Dependent Enthalpy: For all 16 host-guest systems, the binding enthalpy (ΔHexp) became more favorable (more negative) by approximately 0.75 kcal mol⁻¹ for every 10 K increase in temperature.
  • Nearly Constant Free Energy: Despite the significant temperature dependence of enthalpy, the binding free energy (ΔGexp) remained remarkably constant across the temperature range studied. This was due to compensatory changes in binding entropy (-TASexp).
  • Consistently Negative Heat Capacity: The measured heat capacity changes (ΔCp,b) were consistently negative, ranging from -55 to -144 cal mol⁻¹ K⁻¹.
  • Computational Accuracy: MD simulations reproduced experimental trends well, with R² values close to 0.9 for ΔG, 0.8 for ΔH, and 0.7 for -TAS. The computed heat capacities also showed good agreement with experimental values.
  • Hydrogen Bond Correlations: The correlation between binding free energy and the total number of hydrogen bonds (computed) was R² = 0.63, and for experimental data, R² = 0.48. Excluding an outlier (CB7-1-AdOH) improved these correlations significantly.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Force Field Limitations: The authors acknowledge that the computed thermodynamic quantities systematically overestimated experimental data, suggesting potential issues with the force field's ability to accurately balance solute-solvent and solute-solute interactions. This highlights the need for further development and validation of simulation force fields using host-guest binding data.
  • Flexibility and Complexity: While the study focused on rigid systems to simplify analysis, the authors note that discerning these patterns in more flexible molecules, like proteins, will be more challenging due to the substantial and potentially unpredictable contributions of conformational changes.
  • Future Directions: The study suggests that the insights gained from these simple systems can inform the understanding of more complex molecular associations. Future work could involve applying similar combined experimental and computational approaches to more complex systems, including proteins and ligands, to further unravel the role of water in biological recognition. The development of more accurate force fields for molecular simulations remains a crucial area for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

The thermodynamic parameters of host-guest binding can be used to describe, understand, and predict molecular recognition events in aqueous systems. However, interpreting binding thermodynamics remains challenging, even for these relatively simple molecules, as they are determined by both direct and solvent-mediated host-guest interactions. In this contribution, we focus on the contributions of water to binding by studying binding thermodynamics, both experimentally and computationally, for a series of nearly rigid, electrically neutral host-guest systems and report the temperature-dependent thermodynamic binding contributions Δ<i>G</i><sub>b</sub>(<i>T</i>), Δ<i>H</i><sub>b</sub>(<i>T</i>), Δ<i>S</i><sub>b</sub>(<i>T</i>), and Δ<i>C</i><sub>p,b</sub>. Combining isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) measurements with molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, we provide insight into the binding forces at play for the macrocyclic hosts cucurbit[<i>n</i>]uril (CB<i>n</i>, <i>n</i> = 7-8) and β-cyclodextrin (β-CD) with a range of guest molecules. We find consistently negative changes in heat capacity on binding (Δ<i>C</i><sub>p,b</sub>) for all systems studied herein - as well as for literature host-guest systems - indicating increased enthalpic driving forces for binding at higher temperatures. We ascribe these trends to solvation effects, as the solvent properties of water deteriorate as temperature rises. Unlike the entropic and enthalpic contributions to binding, with their differing signs and magnitudes for the classical and non-classical hydrophobic effect, heat capacity changes appear to be a unifying and more general feature of host-guest complex formation in water. This work has implications for understanding protein-ligand interactions and other complex systems in aqueous environments.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{grimm2023temperature,
  author = {Laura Grimm and Jeffry Setiadi and Boryslav A. Tkachenko and Peter R. Schreiner and Michael K. Gilson and Frank Biedermann},
  title = {{The temperature-dependence of host–guest binding thermodynamics: experimental and simulation studies}},
  booktitle = {Chemical},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1039/d3sc01975f},
}
Figure