The Temperament Police: The Truth, the Ground Truth, and Nothing but the Truth

Simon Dixon, Dan Tidhar, Emmanouil BenetosISMIR 2011 · OpenReview

Abstract

Historical performance practice for the harpsichord utilizes various unequal tuning systems, or temperaments, where specific intervals are tuned with varying degrees of purity. While album liner notes often specify the temperament used, objective verification has historically been difficult. This paper presents an automated system for estimating musical temperament from polyphonic harpsichord recordings with sub-cent precision. By analyzing a dataset of 526 tracks, we demonstrate that the "ground truth" labels provided by performers and record labels frequently diverge from the physical reality of the audio, revealing a significant gap between musicological theory and performance practice.

Introduction

In Western music, temperament refers to the specific tuning of the twelve notes within an octave. While modern music is dominated by Equal Temperament, historical harpsichord performance relies on systems like Werckmeister III or Meantone temperaments. Measuring these systems from audio is scientifically challenging, requiring frequency precision far beyond standard pitch-detection algorithms. Furthermore, there is a musicological need to verify if the temperaments claimed in CD metadata match the actual tuning used in the recording.

Methodology

The authors developed a multi-stage pipeline to audit harpsichord recordings. The process begins with Harpsichord-Specific Transcription using Non-negative Matrix Factorization (NMF) with beta-divergence. This identifies which notes are played using spectral templates from the RWC musical instrument database, smoothed by a Hidden Markov Model (HMM).

Transcription results showing MIDI pitch over time for two different segments.

Following transcription, the system performs High-Precision F0 Estimation. This involves a Short-Time Fourier Transform (STFT) with quadratic interpolation and a bias-correction formula to achieve sub-bin frequency resolution. Crucially, the system models the inharmonicity constant ($B$) of harpsichord strings, ensuring that fundamental frequency calculations account for the inherent stiffness of the strings. Finally, the system generates a 12-dimensional vector of pitch deviations, which is compared against a library of theoretical profiles using a weighted divergence metric.

Comparison of theoretical profiles for Sixth Comma Meantone and Fifth Comma temperaments.

Results and Key Insights

The system's accuracy was validated using a synthetic dataset generated via the Pianoteq physical modeling synthesizer, where it achieved 100% accuracy in identifying the correct temperament from 180 possibilities. However, real-world results from the primary dataset of 526 tracks were more complex.

The Discrepancy of "Ground Truth"

The most striking finding is that "ground truth" in music information retrieval is often a social construct. While some recordings matched their metadata perfectly, many others showed significant divergence. For instance, "Werckmeister III" was often used as a generic label for any unequal tuning, being detected in only two of the five CDs that claimed to use it.

The Pragmatic Tuner

The data suggests that tuners treat theoretical temperaments as flexible starting points rather than rigid laws. A common observation was the substitution of "Quarter Comma Meantone" (QCMT) with "Fifth Comma Meantone" (FCMT). The latter is a "milder" system that is often easier to manage across different musical keys and instrument-specific constraints.

Conclusion

This research highlights that for temperament estimation, a "high precision, low recall" strategy is most effective; one does not need to transcribe every note, but rather a sufficient sample with extreme frequency accuracy. The findings suggest that content-based analysis is essential for building an accurate map of how performance practices have actually evolved, independent of the prescriptions of music theorists—the "Temperament Police."

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{dixon2011temperament,
  author = {Simon Dixon and Dan Tidhar and Emmanouil Benetos},
  title = {{The Temperament Police: The Truth, the Ground Truth, and Nothing but the Truth}},
  booktitle = {ISMIR},
  year = {2011},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=fMZX3x9m3V},
}
Figure