The target selection and quantitative evaluation for deep geothermal resource zoning of typical geothermal fields in central Hebei of North China plain

Hong Xiang, Yahui Yao, Shaohua Gai, Jian Song, Wei Song, Jiulong Liu, Zhaolong FengFrontiers in Earth Science 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a multi-criteria evaluation framework combining the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) and GIS spatial analysis to pinpoint high-priority deep geothermal targets in central Hebei. The study identifies the Mesoproterozoic reservoir as a major asset, with 56% of its area classified as an "excellent" prospect, particularly around the Xingji and Gaoyang uplifts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As China pushes toward its "Double Carbon" goals (peaking emissions by 2030 and achieving neutrality by 2060), geothermal energy has moved from a niche interest to a strategic necessity. The North China Plain sits atop massive deep geothermal reserves, but finding the "sweet spots" for development is notoriously difficult.

Historically, exploration has relied on qualitative assessments or broad tectonic classifications that lack the resolution needed for efficient industrial-scale mining. There is a significant gap between knowing a region is "geothermally active" and knowing exactly where to sink a multi-million-dollar well. This paper addresses the need for a standardized, quantitative zoning method that balances geological reality with economic and environmental demand.

Methods

The authors propose a three-tiered evaluation system that moves beyond simple temperature maps. Their approach integrates:

  1. Indicator System Construction: They selected nine secondary indicators grouped into three primary categories:
  2. Resource Condition: Abundance, temperature, porosity, and reservoir thickness.
  3. Development Potential: Effluent capacity (how easily water flows), buried depth, and heat mining coefficients.
  4. Heating Demand: Carbon reduction potential and urbanization rates (where the heat is actually needed).
  5. Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP): To avoid arbitrary scoring, the team used AHP to assign weights to these indicators based on expert judgment. For example, "Resource Condition" was weighted most heavily (approx. 48%), while "Heating Demand" accounted for about 18%.
  6. GIS and Kriging Interpolation: The study area was divided into a grid. By applying the weighted scores to each grid cell and using Kriging (a geostatistical interpolation method), they generated continuous "prospectivity maps" that delineate excellent, general, and poor target areas.

Datasets

The study synthesizes a wide array of regional data:

  • Geological & Geophysical Data: Borehole data and geophysical logging from typical geothermal fields in central Hebei (including the Jizhong depression and Cangxian uplift).
  • Formation-Specific Data: Detailed parameters for the Cambrian-Ordovician carbonate reservoirs and the Middle-Upper Proterozoic (Mesoproterozoic) reservoirs.
  • Demographic Data: 2019 census data was used to calculate urbanization rates, serving as a proxy for heating demand.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Demand" Factor: One of the most practical insights is the inclusion of urbanization and carbon reduction as evaluation metrics. A high-temperature reservoir in the middle of nowhere is less valuable than a moderate-temperature one near a dense urban center like Xiong’an New Area.
  • Structural Goldmines: The study reinforces that "uplifts" (swells) are the primary targets. In these areas, the bedrock is shallower and the geothermal gradient is higher, making extraction both cheaper and more productive.
  • Reservoir Superiority: While the Cambrian-Ordovician reservoirs cover a larger area, the Mesoproterozoic reservoirs (specifically the Jixian Wumishan and Gaoyuzhuang formations) show superior "excellent" prospectivity due to better karst fracture development and higher temperatures.

Key Results

  • Weight Distribution: The most critical individual indicators were found to be Reservoir Temperature (weight 0.187) and Reservoir Buried Depth (weight 0.144), highlighting that heat and accessibility remain the primary drivers of project viability.
  • Mesoproterozoic Success: 56% of the Mesoproterozoic reservoir area was classified as an "excellent" prospect. These are primarily concentrated in the Xingji uplift and Gaoyang low uplift.
  • Regional Hotspots: The evaluation specifically flagged Xiong’an New Area, Cangzhou, and eastern Hengshui as top-tier targets for immediate exploration and development.
  • Quantified Zoning: The authors successfully moved from vague tectonic descriptions to a 1-9 scoring scale, providing a clear "heat map" (Figures 10 and 11 in the paper) for stakeholders.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while this regional model is a powerful tool for zoning, it is not a substitute for site-specific exploration. The accuracy of Kriging interpolation is inherently limited by the density of existing boreholes; areas with sparse data may have higher uncertainty.

Furthermore, the paper suggests that this methodology could be expanded in the future to include other deep-earth applications, such as carbon sequestration (CCS) or the development of dry hot rock (EGS) resources, which require even deeper drilling and different stimulation techniques.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the rapid economic development in North China, the demand for geothermal energy is increasing. It is urgent to find favorable deep geothermal resource targets in North China. Although geothermal resources in the North China Plain are widely distributed, in order to develop deep geothermal resources in North China safely, stably and efficiently, it is essential to carry out the target selection and evaluation of geothermal resource zoning. This article takes the typical geothermal fields in the central Hebei region as the research object, and through the comprehensive collation of regional geothermal geological data, constructs an optimization evaluation indicator system for geothermal resource target areas from three aspects: resource conditions, mining potential, and heating demand. On this basis, it establishes a linear relationship between the attribute values and scores of each indicator, and uses the analytic hierarchy process to assign weights to each indicator and calculate the comprehensive weight. Then, the comprehensive evaluation value is obtained by weighted calculation of the scores and comprehensive weights of each block in the grid segmentation of the evaluation area. Finally, through the spatial analysis function of GIS, the comprehensive evaluation values of all blocks in the evaluation area were analyzed using kriging difference analysis, and a comprehensive evaluation map, the geothermal resource prospective target area map, was finally obtained. Using quantitative zoning evaluation methods, the target areas for exploration and development of deep geothermal resources in central Hebei Province have been delineated within a large region. The evaluation results indicate that the Cambrian-Ordovician reservoir target area is relatively large, and there are many favorable target areas with good reservoir conditions in the Middle-Upper Proterozoic. The excellent prospective target area of the Mesoproterozoic geothermal reservoir accounts for 56%, mainly located in the Xingji uplift and Gaoyang low uplift. Xiong’an New Area, Cangzhou, and the eastern part of Hengshui are excellent prospective target areas for the evaluation of the Mesoproterozoic geothermal reservoir in a single area. This evaluation method can provide a reference for the optimization of resource exploration and development target areas in key regions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xiang2023target,
  author = {Hong Xiang and Yahui Yao and Shaohua Gai and Jian Song and Wei Song and Jiulong Liu and Zhaolong Feng},
  title = {{The target selection and quantitative evaluation for deep geothermal resource zoning of typical geothermal fields in central Hebei of North China plain}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Earth Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/feart.2023.1264652},
}
Figure