The taoist culture and the digital economy: Evidence from Chinese cities

Xiaohui Chen, Desheng WuHeliyon 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how traditional Taoist culture influences the growth of China's digital economy. It finds that Taoist principles, particularly those emphasizing "doing what should be done" and "quietness," positively promote digital economy development by fostering financial decentralization and financial technology innovation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China has prioritized the growth of its digital economy as a key national strategy. While much research has focused on technological and financial factors driving this growth, the influence of cultural elements has been less explored. This paper addresses this gap by examining the specific role of Taoist culture, a significant component of traditional Chinese philosophy, in fostering digital economy development. The authors question whether this ancient cultural heritage can, in fact, contribute to modern technological and economic advancement.

Methods

The researchers employed a theoretical analysis followed by an empirical investigation using a two-way city-year fixed effects model. They collected data from 229 Chinese cities spanning from 2011 to 2019. To measure Taoist culture intensity, they used the number of Taoist temples in each city. The digital economy development index was constructed using multiple indicators, including patent applications for digital technologies and keyword frequency analysis related to emerging tech. The study also incorporated mediating effect analysis to explore the channels through which Taoist culture influences the digital economy, specifically focusing on financial decentralization and financial technology. Robustness checks, including endogeneity treatment and alternative variable specifications, were performed to ensure the reliability of the findings.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 229 Chinese cities between 2011 and 2019. Key data sources included:

  • Digital Inclusive Finance Index: Developed by Peking University, used as a proxy for financial technology.
  • China City Statistical Yearbook: Provided various city-level economic and demographic data.
  • State Administration of Religious Affairs: Data on the locations of Daoist temples, used to quantify Taoist culture intensity.
  • Patsnap website: Data on patent applications related to digital technologies (ABCDI).
  • People's Daily Online: Keyword frequency analysis for digital economy-related terms.
  • China Emission Accounts and Datasets: Data on carbon emissions.
  • People's Bank of China, National Bureau of Statistics of China, Ministry of Civil Affairs of China, and WIND database: For additional economic and financial statistics.

No new benchmarks were introduced; the study relied on existing indices and publicly available data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ancient Wisdom for Modern Growth: The study reveals that traditional Taoist philosophy, often perceived as ancient and spiritual, has tangible economic implications in the modern digital age.
  • "Doing" through "Not Doing": The Taoist concept of "inaction" (wu wei) is reinterpreted not as passivity, but as acting in accordance with natural principles and delegating appropriately. This encourages managers to empower employees, fostering innovation crucial for digital economy development.
  • The Power of "Quietness": The Taoist emphasis on "quietness" is linked to enhanced focus and single-mindedness, which are vital for deep engagement in complex digital innovation.
  • Financial Channels as Mediators: Taoist culture doesn't directly boost the digital economy; it does so by first improving financial decentralization and fostering financial technology (fintech) adoption.

Key Results

  • Hypothesis 1 (H1): Taoist culture intensity (measured by the number of Taoist temples) has a statistically significant positive effect on digital economy development. This was consistently supported across various regression models and robustness checks.
  • Hypothesis 2 (H2): Taoist culture promotes digital economy development by improving cities' degree of financial decentralization. The study found that Taoist culture positively influences financial decentralization, which in turn boosts the digital economy.
  • Hypothesis 3 (H3): Taoist culture promotes digital economy development by improving cities' degree of financial technology. The research demonstrated that Taoist culture enhances financial technology adoption and innovation, thereby contributing to digital economy growth.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Measurement of Taoist Culture: While the number of Taoist temples is a reasonable proxy, it may not fully capture the nuanced influence of Taoist culture, which can be expressed in various ways beyond physical structures.
  • Endogeneity Concerns: The study acknowledges potential endogeneity issues and employs instrumental variable (IV) methods to address them, but the complexity of cultural and economic interactions means some unobserved factors might still influence the results.
  • Future Research Directions: The authors suggest exploring the direct impact of Taoist culture on digital technology innovation itself, rather than solely through financial channels. Additionally, investigating other potential pathways through which Taoist culture might influence the digital economy is recommended. The study also notes that while provincial governments' financial allocation is larger, city-level decentralization, influenced by Taoist culture, shows a positive impact on the digital economy, a point of divergence from some previous research and an area for further exploration.

Summary updated

Abstract

A key component of China's national plan is now the growth of the digital economy. This development relies on the continuous and in-depth practice of the vast majority of Chinese people who are deeply influenced by Chinese culture, of which Taoist culture is an important component that is closely related to the Chinese people and deeply influences overall worldviews. How does Taoist culture affect digital economy growth? Applying a theoretical analysis, in order to investigate this subject, this study used a two-way city-year fixed effects model with Chinese city data. The results demonstrate that Taoist culture can promote digital economy growth. The reason for this is that the "action" of Taoist culture refers to doing what should be done rather than inactivity. Additionally, the "quietness" of Taoist culture facilitates public individuals' single mindedness. The findings imply that Taoist culture has financial decentralization and financial technology effects. Theoretically, improvement in the degree of financial decentralization and technology can promote cities' digital economy development.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2023taoist,
  author = {Xiaohui Chen and Desheng Wu},
  title = {{The taoist culture and the digital economy: Evidence from Chinese cities}},
  booktitle = {Heliyon},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e22846},
}
Figure