The Tameness of Quantum Field Theory, Part I -- Amplitudes

Michael R. Douglas, Thomas W. Grimm, Lorenz SchlechterarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new mathematical concept called "tameness" to characterize physical theories, suggesting that all well-behaved quantum field theories should exhibit this property. The authors prove that perturbative quantum field amplitudes are "tame" and provide evidence that non-perturbative results and effective theories compatible with quantum gravity are also tame, offering a new lens for understanding the structure of fundamental physics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Physicists often deal with functions and structures that exhibit complex, sometimes "wild," behavior, especially when dealing with singularities, infinities, or non-analytic limits in quantum field theory (QFT). While concepts like analyticity capture some of this behavior, they are too restrictive. The authors aim to define a broader mathematical framework – "tameness" – that can precisely capture the "finite amount of structure" expected in physical theories, thereby providing a powerful tool for classifying theories and understanding their consistency, particularly in the context of quantum gravity.

Methods

The core of the paper lies in defining and applying the concept of "tameness" using tools from mathematical logic, specifically o-minimal structures. These structures provide a framework for defining sets and functions with strong finiteness properties. The authors then demonstrate:

  • Perturbative Amplitudes: They prove that Feynman amplitudes at any finite loop order are "tame" functions of external momenta and couplings. This involves showing that these amplitudes can be expressed as period integrals, which are known to be definable within specific o-minimal structures like Ran,exp.
  • Non-Perturbative Results: They examine various exactly solvable QFTs (like the 0d Sine-Gordon model and 1d QFTs) and show that their partition functions are also tame, often by relating them to period integrals or related mathematical objects.
  • Renormalization Group Flow: They discuss how tameness relates to the behavior of renormalization group flows, suggesting that tameness is preserved when integrating out heavy fields.
  • Effective Field Theories (EFTs): They connect tameness to the "Tameness Conjecture," which posits that EFTs compatible with quantum gravity must be tame, implying constraints on their UV completions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Tameness" as a Unifying Principle: The paper proposes "tameness," rooted in o-minimal structures, as a generalized finiteness principle for physical theories, going beyond simple analyticity.
  • Perturbative Amplitudes are Tame: A significant result is the proof that all finite-loop Feynman amplitudes are tame, providing a rigorous mathematical foundation for their well-behaved nature.
  • Periods as the Key: The connection between Feynman integrals and period integrals is crucial. The definability of period integrals in o-minimal structures directly implies the tameness of amplitudes.
  • Non-Perturbative Tameness and UV Completion: The paper suggests that tameness is not just a feature of perturbative calculations but also extends to non-perturbative phenomena, especially when theories have a consistent UV completion (e.g., with quantum gravity).
  • Global Symmetries and Tameness: The presence of infinite-order global symmetries can violate tameness, hinting at why such symmetries might need to be broken or gauged in theories compatible with quantum gravity.

Key Results

  • Theorem: For any renormalizable QFT with finitely many particles and interactions, all ℓ-loop amplitudes are definable in the o-minimal structure Ran,exp as functions of masses, external momenta, and coupling constants.
  • Evidence for Non-Perturbative Tameness: Examples of exactly solvable QFTs demonstrate that their full partition functions are tame.
  • Support for the Tameness Conjecture: The findings provide further evidence for the conjecture that effective theories compatible with quantum gravity are tame.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Non-Renormalizable Theories: While the paper focuses on renormalizable theories, the treatment of non-renormalizable effective theories and the role of infinite counterterms is discussed as a challenge, with the hope that tameness might still hold under certain conditions related to UV completion.
  • Generalizing O-Minimal Structures: The paper notes that Ran,exp might not be sufficient for all physical theories, suggesting the need for new, larger o-minimal structures (e.g., RQFTO, REFTd) to capture phenomena like exponential periods or more complex QFTs.
  • Renormalization Group Flow: The tameness of the full RG flow and its solutions is a complex question that requires further investigation.
  • Conformal Field Theories (CFTs): The paper outlines future work in Part II that will explore tameness conjectures for EFTs and CFTs more comprehensively.
  • Decidability: The authors speculate on a link between tameness and logical decidability, suggesting this as a promising avenue for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

We propose a generalized finiteness principle for physical theories, in terms of the concept of tameness in mathematical logic. A tame function or space can only have a finite amount of structure, in a precise sense which we explain. Tameness generalizes the notion of an analytic function to include certain non-analytic limits, and we show that this includes many limits which are known to arise in physics. For renormalizable quantum field theories, we give a general proof that amplitudes at each order in the loop expansion are tame functions of the external momenta and the couplings. We then consider a variety of exact non-perturbative results and show that they are tame but only given constraints on the UV definition of the theory. This provides further evidence for the recent conjecture of the second author that all effective theories that can be coupled to quantum gravity are tame. We also discuss whether renormalization group flow is tame, and comment on the applicability of our results to effective theories.
BibTeX
@misc{douglas2022tameness,
  author = {Michael R. Douglas and Thomas W. Grimm and Lorenz Schlechter},
  title = {{The Tameness of Quantum Field Theory, Part I -- Amplitudes}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2210.10057},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2210.10057},
}

Loading related content...

Figure