The Synthesis and Anion Recognition Property of Symmetrical Chemosensors Involving Thiourea Groups: Theory and Experiments

Xue-Fang Shang, Zhenhua Yang, Jiajia Fu, Peipei Zhao, Xiu-Fang Xu2015 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed new symmetrical chemosensors based on thiourea derivatives that can selectively detect acetate ions in solution. These sensors utilize changes in color and fluorescence to signal the presence of acetate, even in the presence of other common anions, making them promising for environmental and pharmaceutical monitoring.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Anions play crucial roles in biological, chemical, and environmental systems. In particular, carboxylate ions, such as acetate, are important metabolic products. The ability to accurately detect and quantify these anions is vital for various applications, including environmental monitoring and diagnostics. While many chemosensors exist, there's a continuous need for more selective, sensitive, and easily detectable sensors, especially for biologically relevant anions like acetate. This paper addresses this need by designing and synthesizing novel symmetrical chemosensors that leverage the strong hydrogen-bonding capabilities of thiourea groups and the optical properties of anthracene moieties for selective acetate recognition.

Methods

The study employed a multi-faceted approach combining synthesis, experimental characterization, and theoretical investigation.

  • Synthesis: Four symmetrical compounds (1-4) were synthesized through the condensation of either 3-nitrobenzaldehyde or 9-anthracenecarbaldehyde with diaminothiourea or diaminourea. This synthetic strategy allowed for the systematic variation of the chromophore (nitrobenzene vs. anthracene) and the hydrogen-bonding unit (thiourea vs. urea).
  • Spectrophotometric and Fluorometric Titrations: UV-Vis absorption and fluorescence spectroscopy were used to monitor the interaction between the synthesized compounds and various anions (acetate, fluoride, phosphate, chloride, bromide, and iodide). Titration experiments involved stepwise addition of anions to solutions of the chemosensors in DMSO to observe spectral changes.
  • Binding Constant Calculation: The binding constants ($K_s$) for host-guest complexation were determined using a non-linear least squares calculation method based on the UV-Vis spectral data.
  • Interference Experiments: These experiments were conducted to assess the selectivity of the chemosensors by adding mixtures of anions to determine if the presence of other anions affected the binding of the target anion.
  • Theoretical Investigation: Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations, specifically using the B3LYP/3-21G level of theory with the Gaussian03 program, were performed to optimize the geometries of the chemosensors and to analyze their electronic structures, including frontier molecular orbitals (HOMO and LUMO). This theoretical work aimed to explain the observed spectral changes and the mechanism of anion binding.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated by the authors through spectroscopic measurements and theoretical calculations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Thiourea as a Strong Anion Binder: The study reinforces the well-established fact that thiourea derivatives are excellent hydrogen-bond donors, making them highly effective for anion recognition.
  • Anthracene as a Sensitive Fluorophore: The incorporation of the anthracene moiety in compound 3 significantly enhances its fluorescence properties, leading to more pronounced spectral responses upon anion binding.
  • Selective Acetate Recognition: Compound 3, featuring both thiourea and anthracene, demonstrated remarkable selectivity for acetate ions over other common anions like fluoride, phosphate, chloride, bromide, and iodide. This selectivity is attributed to a combination of factors, including multiple hydrogen bonds, conformational complementarity, and the inherent basicity of the anion.
  • Mechanism of Binding: The host-guest interaction is primarily driven by multiple hydrogen bonds between the NH groups of the thiourea moiety and the acetate anion. Theoretical calculations confirmed the existence of intramolecular hydrogen bonds within the chemosensors, which further strengthen anion binding.
  • Colorimetric and Fluorometric Sensing: The binding of acetate to compound 3 induces distinct color changes (yellow to orange) and significant changes in fluorescence intensity, providing a dual-mode sensing capability.
  • Theoretical Explanation for Spectral Shifts: DFT calculations helped elucidate the origin of the observed red-shift in UV-Vis spectra upon complexation, linking it to electron transitions between frontier molecular orbitals.

Key Results

  • Compound 3 is the most effective chemosensor: It showed sensitive and selective binding for acetate ion.
  • Binding Order: The binding affinity for the tested anions followed the order: AcO⁻ > F⁻ > H₂PO₄⁻ >> Cl⁻, Br⁻, I⁻.
  • High Binding Constants: Compound 3 exhibited significantly higher binding constants ($K_s$) for acetate (3.93 ± 0.06 × 10⁴ M⁻¹) compared to compound 1 (1.33 ± 0.08 × 10⁴ M⁻¹).
  • No Interference: Interference experiments confirmed that the presence of other anions did not significantly affect the binding of acetate to compound 3, highlighting its practical utility.
  • Color Change: Upon addition of acetate, the solution of compound 3 changed color from yellow to orange.
  • Fluorescence Quenching: The fluorescence intensity of compound 3 was significantly quenched upon binding with acetate.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Solvent Dependence: The experiments were conducted in DMSO. The performance of these sensors in different solvent systems, particularly in aqueous environments relevant to environmental and biological samples, would be an important area for future investigation.
  • Real Sample Analysis: While the authors suggest the potential for use in environmental and pharmaceutical samples, direct application and validation in these complex matrices are not presented. Future work could focus on adapting these sensors for real-world sample analysis.
  • Further Optimization: While compound 3 shows promising selectivity, further structural modifications could potentially lead to even higher selectivity or sensitivity for acetate, or for other important anions.
  • Exploration of Other Anions: The study focused on a specific set of anions. Expanding the scope to include other biologically or environmentally relevant anions could broaden the applicability of this sensor platform.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{shang2015synthesis,
  author = {Xue-Fang Shang and Zhenhua Yang and Jiajia Fu and Peipei Zhao and Xiu-Fang Xu},
  title = {{The Synthesis and Anion Recognition Property of Symmetrical Chemosensors Involving Thiourea Groups: Theory and Experiments}},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.3390/s151128166},
}
Figure