The super-super exchange mechanism in iron-based antiperovskite chalco-halides

Kai Liu, Zhong-Yi LuarXiv 2016 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

By using first-principles electronic structure calculations, we have systematically studied the magnetism in three recently synthesized iron-based antiperovskite chalco-halides: $Ba_3(FeS_4)Cl$, $Ba_3(FeS_4)Br$, and $Ba_3(FeSe_4)Br$. These compounds consist of edge-sharing $BaQ_6$ ($Q$=Cl or Br) octahedra intercalated with isolated $FeX_4$ ($X$=S or Se) tetrahedra. We find that even though the shortest distances between the nearest-neighboring Fe atoms in these three compounds already exceed 6 Å—much larger than the bond length of a chemical bonding—they all remarkably show antiferromagnetic (AFM) coupling along the $b$-axis with very weak spin-spin correlation along the $a$-axis. Our study shows that the mechanism underlying this novel AFM coupling is a new type of exchange interaction between the nearest-neighboring Fe-based super-moments mediated by Ba cations, which we call the super-super exchange interaction. In this mechanism, each magnetic Fe atom partially polarizes its four nearest-neighboring $X$ atoms to form a super-moment through $p$-$d$ orbital hybridization, and the $X$ atoms in neighboring $FeX_4$ tetrahedra along the $b$-axis antiferromagnetically couple with each other through the intermediate Ba cations. Different from conventional superexchange, here it is cations rather than anions that mediate two neighboring super-moments.

Introduction

In condensed matter physics, understanding how magnetic moments (spins) interact is fundamental to designing new materials for electronics and data storage. Usually, these interactions require magnetic atoms to be very close so their electron clouds overlap (direct exchange) or to be linked by a single non-magnetic atom like oxygen (superexchange). However, a recently synthesized group of materials called iron-based antiperovskite chalco-halides presented a puzzle. In these crystals, the iron (Fe) atoms are separated by more than 6 Å—a distance far too great for standard chemical bonding or direct magnetic overlap. Despite this "social distancing" at the atomic level, experiments showed that these materials still undergo an antiferromagnetic (AFM) phase transition at low temperatures. This study explains the "hidden" bridge that allows these distant spins to communicate.

Methodology

The researchers employed first-principles electronic structure calculations based on Density Functional Theory (DFT) using the VASP (Vienna Ab initio Simulation Package) with the Projector Augmented Wave (PAW) method. The Generalized Gradient Approximation (GGA) handled electron exchange and correlation. To determine the ground state, they modeled six different magnetic configurations (various types of antiferromagnetic and ferromagnetic orders). Initial atomic coordinates and lattice parameters were taken from recent experimental work to ensure structural accuracy.

The Super-Super Exchange Mechanism

The core finding of this research is the discovery of the "super-moment." The Fe atoms do not act in isolation; through $p$-$d$ orbital hybridization, an Fe atom partially polarizes its four neighboring sulfur (S) or selenium (Se) atoms. This entire $FeX_4$ tetrahedron acts as a single magnetic "super-moment."

Spin density map showing the formation of magnetic 'super-moments' in $Ba_3(FeSe_4)Br$.

In standard superexchange, an anion (like $O^{2-}$) bridges two magnetic cations. Here, the roles are reversed: the $X$ atoms of two neighboring super-moments couple through an intermediate barium (Ba) cation. This cation-mediated coupling between super-moments is why the authors coined the term "super-super exchange."

Key Results and the Selenium Paradox

The calculations confirmed that the "AFM1" state (antiferromagnetic along the $b$-axis) is the most stable ground state, matching experimental neutron diffraction data. Iron atoms were found to be in a high-spin state with a magnetic moment of approximately 3.4 $\mu_B$, while the S/Se atoms carry a small induced moment of ~0.15 $\mu_B$.

Counter-intuitively, the compound with the largest distance between iron atoms ($Ba_3(FeSe_4)Br$) was predicted to have the strongest magnetic coupling. This "Selenium Paradox" occurs because selenium atoms have larger atomic radii and more extended 4p orbitals than sulfur. This leads to stronger hybridization with iron and a more effective bridge through the barium atoms, overcoming the increased physical distance.

Geometric path and charge difference density illustrating the Ba-mediated exchange between super-moments.

Based on the calculated exchange strength ($J_b$), the authors predict that $Ba_3(FeSe_4)Br$ will have a phase transition temperature ($T_N$) of roughly 110 K, which is higher than its sulfur-based counterparts ($Ba_3(FeS_4)Br$ at 84 K and $Ba_3(FeS_4)Cl$ at 95 K).

Conclusion

This study identifies a novel magnetic mechanism that allows for long-range spin alignment in materials with low magnetic atom densities. While standard GGA calculations may underestimate band gaps, the identified magnetic mechanism remains robust. The prediction that the selenium-based compound has the highest $T_N$ despite the longest Fe-Fe distance is a bold theoretical claim that invites further experimental verification via neutron scattering. This mechanism could provide a new pathway for transferring spin information over long distances, potentially impacting the development of future spintronic devices.

Summary updated

Abstract

By using the first-principles electronic structure calculations, we have systematically studied the magnetism in three recently synthesized iron-based antiperovskite chalco-halides: Ba$_3$(FeS$_4$)Cl, Ba$_3$(FeS$_4$)Br, and Ba$_3$(FeSe$_4$)Br. These compounds consist of edge-sharing Ba$Q_6$ ($Q$=Cl or Br) octahedra intercalated with isolated Fe$X_4$ ($X$=S or Se) tetrahedra. We find that even though the shortest distances between the nearest-neighboring Fe atoms in these three compounds already exceed 6 Å, much larger than the bond length of a chemical bonding, they all remarkably show antiferromagnetic (AFM) coupling along $b$ axis with very weak spin-spin correlation along $a$ axis. Our study shows that the mechanism underlying this novel AFM coupling is such a new type of exchange interaction between the nearest-neighboring Fe-based super-moments mediated by Ba cations, which we call the super-super exchange interaction, in which each magnetic Fe atom partially polarizes its four nearest-neighboring $X$ atoms to form a super-moment through $p$-$d$ orbital hybridization and the $X$ atoms in neighboring Fe$X_4$ tetrahedra along $b$ axis antiferromagnetically couple with each others through the intermediate Ba cations. Different from the conventional superexchange, here it is cations rather than anions that mediate two neighboring super-moments. According to the calculated strength of the AFM coupling, we predict that among these compounds the highest AFM phase transition temperature $T_N$ may reach 110 K in Ba$_3$(FeSe$_4$)Br, in comparison with the observed $T_N$s of 84 K in Ba$_3$(FeS$_4$)Br and 95 K in Ba$_3$(FeS$_4$)Cl.
BibTeX
@misc{liu2016super,
  author = {Kai Liu and Zhong-Yi Lu},
  title = {{The super-super exchange mechanism in iron-based antiperovskite chalco-halides}},
  year = {2016},
  eprint = {1604.02044},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1604.02044},
}
Figure