Abstract
Positive displacement pumps, while essential for high-pressure industrial applications, generate significant pressure pulsations that can lead to mechanical fatigue and sensor inaccuracies. This study evaluates a novel, lightweight vibration absorber design against standard industrial dampers. Experimental results demonstrate that the optimized design reduces pressure fluctuations to less than 1% of the initial pressure while being nearly seven times lighter than conventional solutions. The findings validate a mathematical model for complex composite filters in high-pressure fluid systems.
Introduction
In industrial fluid systems, piston pumps are critical for delivering high-pressure flow. However, their operation is inherently non-steady, delivering fluid in discrete "pulses" rather than a continuous stream. These rhythmic pressure fluctuations are a major source of mechanical fatigue, which can lead to catastrophic system failures, such as the 1986 nitrogen tanker explosion cited by the authors. Furthermore, these pulses introduce significant noise into sensor data, making accurate flow and pressure measurement difficult. While vibration absorbers (dampers) are used to mitigate these effects, standard industrial versions are often bulky and inefficient. This paper investigates a more efficient, mathematically optimized damper design.
Experimental Methodology
The research was conducted using a specialized test rig at the Odessa National Polytechnic University. The setup was designed to measure the performance of various dampers under realistic operating conditions.
Hardware and Measurement
The researchers tested single-line and trilinear (three-piston) pumps using liquefied gas and carbon dioxide at operating pressures between 5 and 15 MPa. Three types of dampers were compared:
- Standard Industrial Damper: A reactive-type damper weighing 70 kg.
- New Design (H=0.5m): A lightweight prototype weighing 6 kg.
- New Design (H=1.0m): A lightweight prototype weighing 11.5 kg.
Measurements were captured using low-inertia pressure sensors (LKh-417) capable of recording vibrations up to 10 kHz. Sensors were placed at three critical points: immediately after the piston, before the damper, and after the damper. Additionally, a "failure mode" was simulated by forcing a valve seat to stay open, creating extreme irregularities to test the dampers' resilience.
Key Insights and Results
Upstream Surge and Harmonic Smoothing
A significant finding was that standard industrial dampers can actually increase pressure fluctuations in the line before the damper by 1.5 to 2 times. In contrast, the optimized designs effectively filtered high-frequency "impact noise," leaving only a smoothed fundamental harmonic. Even during simulated pump stage failures—where surges reached 300-400%—the H=1.0m damper maintained downstream fluctuations within a manageable 2.0-2.5% range.
Performance Metrics
- Smoothing Efficiency: The H=1.0m damper reduced pressure pulsations to 0.5–1.0% of the initial pressure, outperforming the standard damper's 1.3–2.5% range.
- Mass Efficiency: The new design achieved superior results with a 7x reduction in weight (11.5 kg vs. 70 kg).
- Pulsation Reduction: In single-piston pump tests, the H=1.0m damper decreased pulsations by an average factor of 13.6.
Conclusion
The experimental data strongly correlates with the authors' previously published mathematical models for "complex composite filters." The study proves that optimized fluid dynamics can replace sheer mass in damper design, providing a lightweight, highly effective solution for industrial high-pressure systems. Future work should address the long-term durability of these lighter steel (12Kh18N9T) designs under continuous high-pressure cycling and their performance with higher-viscosity fluids.
Summary updated