Abstract
Nowadays, the coronavirus disease, aka COVID-19, has caused a great impact. In a very short time, the epidemic has swept the world. There are many restrictions on work, eating, shopping and even social distance. For these reasons, there is no contact for these activities. Delivery has become the best preferred method of logistics distribution. In addition to unmanned delivery vehicles (for example, autonomous vehicles, unmanned aircraft, autonomous mobile robots), contactless delivery also includes i-mailboxes, delivery platforms, smart food drawers, unmanned stores, etc. These methods avoid direct contact between people and reduce the risk of infection. In this study, the decision-making trial and evaluation laboratory analysis method (DEMATEL) combined with the analytic network process analysis method (ANP), named DEMATEL-based ANP (DANP), and the VIKOR (VlseKriterijumska optimizacija I Kompromisno Resenje) compromise ranking method are proposed to optimize the compromise solution method for contactless distribution plan rating. This research proposes five dimensions: security, delivery, convenience, competitive condition and temperature control, and 20 criteria under these dimensions, and select the most suitable solution through the above two methods. The results of this research show that the contactless distribution scheme selection method is competent to analyze the weight and performance evaluation of the relationship structure of consumers in the contactless distribution scheme selection structure through questionnaires, explore the most suitable distribution scheme, and provide consumers with reference for choosing a distribution solution alternative.
Introduction
The COVID-19 pandemic catalyzed a rapid shift toward the "contactless economy," making non-physical delivery a necessity. Logistics providers now face a fragmented landscape of options: autonomous drones, smart "i-mailboxes," unmanned stores, or traditional delivery platforms. These options involve conflicting criteria—for instance, an unmanned vehicle might offer high security but lower convenience compared to a specialized food delivery platform. This study aims to provide a mathematically rigorous way to rank these alternatives based on real-world consumer priorities in the "new normal."
Evaluation Framework and Methodology
The researchers identified five primary dimensions and 20 sub-criteria to evaluate contactless distribution schemes, as detailed in the table below.
The study employed a two-stage hybrid Multiple Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) approach:
- DANP (DEMATEL-based ANP): DEMATEL was used to map the interdependent relationships between dimensions. These relationships were then integrated into an ANP to calculate relative weights, accounting for the complex network of influences rather than assuming criteria are independent.
- VIKOR: A compromise ranking method that determines the best alternative by measuring proximity to an "ideal" solution while minimizing "individual regret" (the maximum gap in any single criterion).
Primary data was collected via 30 valid consumer questionnaires. A Consistency Index (C.I.) was used to ensure survey responses were logical and reliable.
Key Results and Discussion
The analysis revealed that Convenience (D3) is the primary driver for consumer selection, followed by Competitive Condition (D4). Interestingly, Security (D1) ranked third, suggesting that while health safety is the origin of the shift, ease of use and market presence are more decisive for long-term adoption.
At the individual criterion level, "Marketing Strategy" (C15) and "Product Penetration" (C16) emerged as the most critical factors. This suggests that for a contactless scheme to succeed, consumer awareness and market presence are more vital than the underlying hardware.
The VIKOR analysis produced a clear ranking of the five alternatives based on their $Q_j$ value (where a score closer to 0 is better):
- Delivery Platform ($Q_j = 0.019$): The clear winner, excelling in convenience and marketing reach.
- Instant Meal Cabinet ($Q_j = 0.301$): A strong second, balancing temperature control and pick-up flexibility.
- Unmanned Shop ($Q_j = 0.631$)
- Unmanned Vehicle ($Q_j = 0.925$)
- i-mailbox ($Q_j = 1.000$): Ranked last, suggesting traditional smart lockers lack the specialized features consumers now expect for food and perishables.
Conclusion
Delivery platforms (e.g., Uber Eats, Foodpanda) are currently the most effective contactless logistics solution. While high-tech alternatives like unmanned vehicles are promising, they lag in convenience and market penetration. Future work should focus on optimizing user interfaces for diverse demographics and implementing better verification methods to enhance consumer trust in the "last-mile" delivery process.
Summary updated