The study of antecedent clinical manifestations of hypertensive heart disease in cohort of hypertension

Qian Li, Na Li, Liang Xiao, Yanjie Liu, Li Chen, Huimin Lao, Sheng Wei, Jun Xiao, Xiaoqiang QiAging 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Hypertensive heart disease presents increasing morbidity and mortality worldwide, however, the data about its epidemics and its specific symptoms in hypertension patients is scarce. To assess the frequency and correlated symptoms of hypertensive heart disease, 800 hypertension patients were randomly recruited for this study per the guidelines of the American College of Cardiology. The diagnosis of heart disease and its typical symptoms (palpitation and angina) were analyzed for the frequency of hypertensive heart disease in hypertension cohort. Cross-tabulation analysis was used to study the correlation between psychiatric indexes, physical disorders, and cephalic symptoms with palpitation. It was found that around half of patients suffered hypertensive heart disease, which correlated to certain physical and mental symptoms. Significant correlations exist between palpitation and factors like amnesia, backache, and dizziness. These results provide clinical insights into the modifiable antecedent clinical conditions which are risk factors for hypertensive heart disease in elderly and will help improve early management of this disease.

Introduction

Hypertension is a global health crisis, but its most lethal complication—Hypertensive Heart Disease (HHD)—often develops insidiously. HHD encompasses a range of pathologies, from left ventricular hypertrophy (LVH) to heart failure and ischemic heart disease. Early-stage HHD is frequently asymptomatic or presents with vague symptoms that are easily dismissed by both patients and clinicians. While objective measures like blood pressure are standard, there is a critical need to understand how subjective patient symptoms correlate with disease progression. This study identifies "antecedent clinical manifestations"—early warning signs—that could facilitate earlier diagnosis and intervention.

Methods

This cross-sectional study involved 800 hypertension patients randomly recruited from Qingdao, China (61.25% female, 38.75% male, aged 40–80). Diagnosis followed American College of Cardiology (ACC) guidelines. A comprehensive questionnaire captured medical history, lifestyle, and symptoms categorized into psychiatric (e.g., amnesia, anxiety), physical (e.g., backache, numbness), and cephalic (e.g., dizziness, tinnitus) domains. Statistical analysis utilized cross-tabulation and Chi-square tests to identify significant correlations. Additionally, ten common blood routine biomarkers, including homocysteine and uric acid, were analyzed in relation to patient-reported palpitations.

Results and Key Insights

The study revealed a high prevalence of HHD within the hypertensive cohort, with over 60% of participants receiving a diagnosis.

Prevalence of Hypertensive Heart Disease in the study cohort.

The Palpitation Pivot

Palpitation emerged as a more sensitive representative clinical manifestation than traditional angina. While roughly half of the patients reported slight palpitations (46.38%) and slight angina (46.38%), palpitations were more broadly correlated with age and a wider variety of secondary symptoms. The data shows a clear increase in palpitation frequency and severity among those diagnosed with HHD compared to those who were not.

Distribution of palpitation severity across diagnosed and non-diagnosed patients.

Systemic Symptom Correlations

A striking finding was the correlation between cardiac palpitations and non-cardiac symptoms:

  • Psychiatric Indexes: "Annoy" (agitation) and amnesia showed significant positive correlations with HHD progression. Notably, 81.1% of those with medium palpitations reported amnesia.
  • Somatic Pain: Patients with palpitations were significantly more likely to suffer from backache, lumbar debility, or numbness of limbs (89.2% in the medium palpitation group).
  • Cephalic Symptoms: 94.6% of those with medium palpitations suffered from dizziness, with significant correlations also found for headache and tinnitus.

Biochemical Signatures

A clear metabolic profile was associated with palpitations, characterized by higher levels of homocysteine, total cholesterol, creatinine, and uric acid, alongside lower levels of HDL ("good") cholesterol.

Discussion and Future Directions

These findings suggest that cognitive, emotional, and somatic shifts may serve as early systemic indicators of cardiac strain. Identifying these antecedent symptoms offers a new roadmap for clinical screening in primary care settings.

However, the study's geographic focus on northern China may limit generalizability, and the reliance on self-reported data introduces potential subjective bias. Future longitudinal research is needed to determine if managing these antecedent symptoms can slow HHD progression and to explore the underlying physiological mechanisms, such as autonomic nervous system dysfunction, linking these disparate symptoms to cardiac health.

Summary updated

Abstract

Hypertensive heart disease presents increasing morbidity and mortality worldwide, however, the data about its epidemics and its specific symptoms in hypertension patients is scarce. To assess the frequency and correlated symptoms of hypertensive heart disease, 800 hypertension patients were randomly recruited for this study per the guidelines of the American College of Cardiology. The diagnosis of heart disease and its typical symptoms (palpitation and angina) were analyzed for the frequency of hypertensive heart disease in hypertension cohort. Cross-tabulation analysis was used to study the correlation between psychiatric indexes (annoy, amnesia, irritableness, depression, anxiety, and fear) and palpitation, the correlation between physical disorders (backache, lumbar debility, and numbness of limbs) and palpitation, and the correlation between symptoms (dizziness, daze, headache, and tinnitus) and palpitation presented in hypertensive patients. It was found that around half of patients suffered hypertensive heart disease, which correlated to certain physical and mental symptoms. Significant correlation exists between palpitation and annoy / amnesia. Significant correlation exists between palpitation and backache / lumbar debility / numbness of limbs; and significant correlation exists between palpitation and dizziness / daze / headache / tinnitus. These results provide clinical insights into the modifiable antecedent clinical conditions which are risk factors for hypertensive heart disease in elderly and will help improve early management of this disease.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2023study,
  author = {Qian Li and Na Li and Liang Xiao and Yanjie Liu and Li Chen and Huimin Lao and Sheng Wei and Jun Xiao and Xiaoqiang Qi},
  title = {{The study of antecedent clinical manifestations of hypertensive heart disease in cohort of hypertension}},
  booktitle = {Aging},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.18632/aging.204510},
}
Figure