The structural basis of hyperpromiscuity in a core combinatorial network of type II toxin–antitoxin and related phage defense systems

Karin Ernits, Chayan Kumar Saha, Tetiana Brodiazhenko, Bhanupratap Singh Chouhan, Aditi Shenoy, Jessica A. Buttress, Julián J. Duque-Pedraza, Veda Bojar, Jose A. Nakamoto, Tatsuaki Kurata, Artyom A. Egorov, Lena Shyrokova, Marcus Johansson, Toomas Mets, Aytan Rustamova, Jelisaveta Džigurski, Tanel Tenson, Abel Garcia‐Pino, Henrik Strahl, Arne Elofsson, Vasili Hauryliuk, Gemma C. AtkinsonProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces NetFlax, a computational tool for analyzing toxin-antitoxin (TA) systems, revealing a core network of these genetic modules and their evolutionary relationships. By combining structural predictions with experimental validation, the study elucidates how the hyperpromiscuous Panacea antitoxin domain neutralizes diverse toxins, highlighting its role in microbial defense, particularly against phages.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Toxin-antitoxin (TA) systems are ubiquitous genetic elements in prokaryotes, crucial for processes like plasmid stability and cellular defense. Type II TA systems, consisting of a toxin and its neutralizing antitoxin, are particularly diverse and modular, allowing for extensive "partner swapping" during evolution. A key question has been how certain antitoxins, like the Panacea domain, can neutralize such a wide array of unrelated toxins. Understanding the structural basis of this "hyperpromiscuity" and the broader evolutionary landscape of TA systems, especially their role in antiphage defense, has been a significant challenge.

Methods

The core of this research lies in the development and application of NetFlax, a novel bioinformatic tool designed to identify and map TA-like gene pairs. NetFlax employs an iterative gene neighborhood analysis approach, allowing it to discover interconnected clusters of TA systems. To understand the structural basis of these interactions, the researchers utilized AlphaFold2 to predict the 3D structures of over 3,400 TA complexes. This was complemented by mutagenesis studies and functional assays, including metabolic labeling (using 35S methionine, 3H uridine, and 3H thymidine) to assess inhibition of protein synthesis, transcription, and replication, respectively. Fluorescence microscopy was also employed to visualize cellular effects like membrane depolarization.

Datasets

The study utilized a large dataset of 24,474 representative predicted proteomes from bacteria and archaea, along with 10,449 available virus genomes, sourced from the NCBI RefSeq FTP server. This comprehensive dataset formed the basis for the NetFlax analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • A Core Network of TA Systems: NetFlax successfully mapped a complex, interconnected network of TA systems, revealing that many appear to be evolutionarily related, particularly to phage defense mechanisms.
  • Structural Basis of Hyperpromiscuity: The study provides structural insights into how the Panacea domain achieves its broad neutralization capabilities. It demonstrates that Panacea can directly neutralize toxins or act as a scaffold for other neutralizing domains (like PAD1, Phd-C, and ZFD), suggesting a flexible mechanism.
  • Panacea as a Sensor: The researchers hypothesize that Panacea might function as a sensor, responding to TA-activating cues rather than directly mediating neutralization in all cases.
  • TA Systems as Phage Defense: The research strongly reinforces the role of TA systems, especially those with AAA ATPase and ImmA protease domains, as integral components of the antiphage defense arsenal.
  • Recurrent Structural Folds: Despite sequence diversity, many TA systems share common structural folds (e.g., ATPase, MazF/PemK, PIN, RelE/ParE, Phd/YefM), indicating convergent evolution or shared ancestry.

Key Results

  • 3,597 TA Systems Identified: NetFlax identified 3,597 TA systems, organized into 278 distinct homologous clusters and 275 unique TA node combinations.
  • 3,419 Complex Structures Predicted: AlphaFold2 successfully predicted structures for 3,419 TA complexes, with a significant portion (around 50-60%) showing good model confidence.
  • Experimental Validation of 16 TA Systems: Sixteen NetFlax-identified TA systems were experimentally validated for toxicity neutralization.
  • Mechanisms of Toxicity: Metabolic labeling assays helped predict the mechanisms of toxicity for validated systems, including membrane disruption, inhibition of cell division, and protein synthesis.
  • Antiphage Activity Confirmed: The antiphage activity of a RosmerTA system from Gordonia phage Kita was validated, demonstrating its role in microbial defense.
  • Membrane Depolarization: Fluorescence microscopy confirmed the predicted membrane-depolarizing activity of a specific TA system.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that NetFlax has limitations:

  • Limited to Representative Proteomes: The analysis is based on a representative set of proteomes, potentially missing some diversity and novel systems.
  • Focus on Two-Gene Systems: NetFlax currently only addresses conserved two-gene proteinaceous systems, excluding multigene systems.
  • Potential for False Positives: Spurious domain associations could lead to false positive predictions.

Future work could involve:

  • Fine-grained analysis of specific lineages: Deeper investigation into identified TA lineages.
  • Exploring multigene systems: Expanding the NetFlax approach to include more complex TA architectures.
  • Investigating the precise role of Panacea: Further research into its hypothesized sensor function.
  • Understanding moonlighting roles: Delving deeper into how antitoxin domains can perform multiple functions beyond neutralization.

Summary updated

Abstract

Toxin-antitoxin (TA) systems are a large group of small genetic modules found in prokaryotes and their mobile genetic elements. Type II TAs are encoded as bicistronic (two-gene) operons that encode two proteins: a toxin and a neutralizing antitoxin. Using our tool NetFlax (standing for Network-FlaGs for toxins and antitoxins), we have performed a large-scale bioinformatic analysis of proteinaceous TAs, revealing interconnected clusters constituting a core network of TA-like gene pairs. To understand the structural basis of toxin neutralization by antitoxins, we have predicted the structures of 3,419 complexes with AlphaFold2. Together with mutagenesis and functional assays, our structural predictions provide insights into the neutralizing mechanism of the hyperpromiscuous Panacea antitoxin domain. In antitoxins composed of standalone Panacea, the domain mediates direct toxin neutralization, while in multidomain antitoxins the neutralization is mediated by other domains, such as PAD1, Phd-C, and ZFD. We hypothesize that Panacea acts as a sensor that regulates TA activation. We have experimentally validated 16 NetFlax TA systems and used domain annotations and metabolic labeling assays to predict their potential mechanisms of toxicity (such as membrane disruption, and inhibition of cell division or protein synthesis) as well as biological functions (such as antiphage defense). We have validated the antiphage activity of a RosmerTA system encoded by <i>Gordonia</i> phage Kita, and used fluorescence microscopy to confirm its predicted membrane-depolarizing activity. The interactive version of the NetFlax TA network that includes structural predictions can be accessed at http://netflax.webflags.se/.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ernits2023structural,
  author = {Karin Ernits and Chayan Kumar Saha and Tetiana Brodiazhenko and Bhanupratap Singh Chouhan and Aditi Shenoy and Jessica A. Buttress and Julián J. Duque-Pedraza and Veda Bojar and Jose A. Nakamoto and Tatsuaki Kurata and Artyom A. Egorov and Lena Shyrokova and Marcus Johansson and Toomas Mets and Aytan Rustamova and Jelisaveta Džigurski and Tanel Tenson and Abel Garcia‐Pino and Henrik Strahl and Arne Elofsson and Vasili Hauryliuk and Gemma C. Atkinson},
  title = {{The structural basis of hyperpromiscuity in a core combinatorial network of type II toxin–antitoxin and related phage defense systems}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.2305393120},
}
Figure