The strain seismograms of P- and S-waves of a local event recorded by four-gauge borehole strainmeter

Zehua Qiu, Chi Shun-liang, Zhenming Wang, N. Seth Carpenter, Lei Tang, Yanping Guo, Yang GuangEarthquake 2015 · DOI

Abstract

Traditionally used for long-term tectonic monitoring, YRY-4 four-gauge borehole strainmeters (FGBS) are shown to be capable of high-fidelity seismic recording at sampling rates of 100 Hz. This study analyzes strain seismograms from a local $M_L$ 3.5 earthquake, demonstrating that these instruments provide self-consistent data that distinguishes the unique deformation patterns of P- and S-waves. The results align well with conventional broadband seismograms, suggesting that strainmeters can offer complementary insights into wave propagation and source mechanisms.

Introduction

Seismology has long relied on translational motion measurements—velocity and acceleration—to understand the Earth's interior. However, borehole strainmeters offer a different perspective by measuring the internal deformation (strain) of the rock itself. While typically reserved for tracking slow tectonic shifts over years, increasing the sampling rate of these instruments transforms them into "strain seismographs." This paper evaluates the reliability and utility of high-frequency strain data recorded during a local seismic event.

Methods and Experimental Setup

The study utilized a YRY-4 four-gauge borehole strainmeter (FGBS) installed at the Guza station in Sichuan, China. On March 17, 2008, a local $M_L$ 3.5 earthquake occurred approximately 70 km from the station. The FGBS was operated at a sampling rate of 100 Hz to capture the transient strains of the arriving seismic waves.

Map of the study area showing the Guza station (GZ, blue triangle) and the earthquake epicenter (MI3.5, red circle). The inset shows the orientation of the four strain gauges (1-4).

Data Reliability and Self-Consistency

A critical advantage of the four-gauge design is the ability to verify data quality through a "self-consistency" check. In an ideal elastic medium, the sum of strain changes from orthogonal gauge pairs (e.g., $S1+S3$ and $S2+S4$) should be equal, representing the areal strain. The high correlation between these sums during the arrival of P- and S-waves confirms that the instrument is recording true ground deformation rather than localized noise.

Strain seismograms for the four individual gauges (S1-S4) and the sums of orthogonal pairs (S1+S3 and S2+S4). The P and S wave arrivals are clearly visible, and the near-identical sums demonstrate the instrument's high self-consistency.

Key Insights

  • P-Wave Directionality: Analysis of the strain tensor revealed that for P-waves, the direction of maximum normal strain change aligns with the azimuth of the earthquake's ray path. This confirms the longitudinal nature of P-waves, which "stretch" the ground along the line of travel.
  • S-Wave Complexity: S-wave strain patterns were found to be significantly more complex and did not align simply with the epicenter. This suggests that S-wave strain seismograms carry detailed information about the earthquake's source mechanism and the specific slip of the fault.
  • Comparison with Traditional Seismometry: When rotated into cardinal directions, the strain records showed strong waveform similarity to velocity records from a co-located CTS-1 broadband seismometer. Spectral analysis further confirmed this agreement, with both instruments identifying a dominant 7 Hz peak associated with the S-wave.

Conclusion

The YRY-4 borehole strainmeter proves to be a robust tool for high-frequency seismic observation. Its ability to provide self-consistent, multi-directional strain data offers a valuable supplement to traditional translational seismometry, particularly in understanding the geometric deformation of the crust during seismic events. Future research will focus on generalizing these findings across a broader range of earthquake magnitudes and distances.

Summary updated

Abstract

At a sampling rate of 100 samples per second, the YRY-4 four-gauge borehole strainmeters (FGBS) are capable of recording transient strains caused by seismic waves such as P and S waves or strain seismograms. At such a high sampling rate, data from the YRY-4 strainmeters demonstrate fairly satisfactory self-consistency. The strain tensor seismograms demonstrate the senses of motion of P waves, that is, the type of seismic wave travels in the direction of the maximum normal strain change. The observed strain patterns of S waves significantly differ from those of P waves and should contain information about the source mechanism. Spectrum analysis shows that the strain seismograms are consistent with conventional broadband seismograms from the same site.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{qiu2015strain,
  author = {Zehua Qiu and Chi Shun-liang and Zhenming Wang and N. Seth Carpenter and Lei Tang and Yanping Guo and Yang Guang},
  title = {{The strain seismograms of P- and S-waves of a local event recorded by four-gauge borehole strainmeter}},
  booktitle = {Earthquake},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1007/s11589-015-0120-5},
}
Figure