The Stability of Phyto-Zooplanktonic Networks Varied with Zooplanktonic Sizes in Chinese Coastal Ecosystem

Zheng Zhang, Hongjun Li, Wenli Shen, Kai Feng, Shuzhen Li, Songsong Gu, Yuqi Zhou, Xi Peng, Xiongfeng Du, Qing He, Linlin Wang, Zhaojing Zhang, Danrui Wang, Zhujun Wang, Ye DengmSystems 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that smaller zooplankton contribute to more stable and complex interactions with phytoplankton in coastal ecosystems. This finding highlights the critical, yet often overlooked, role of zooplankton body size in shaping marine food web stability and how it influences the ecosystem's response to environmental changes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The intricate relationships between phytoplankton (primary producers) and zooplankton (primary consumers) form the foundation of marine food webs, influencing energy flow and ecosystem stability. While body size is known to affect individual metabolic rates and ecological functions, its specific impact on the stability of these crucial phyto-zooplanktonic networks (PZNs) has remained unclear, especially at large scales. Understanding these interactions is vital for managing coastal ecosystems, particularly in the face of environmental changes. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by investigating how zooplankton body size influences the structure and stability of PZNs along the extensive Chinese coastline.

Methods

The researchers constructed bipartite networks to represent the co-occurrence patterns between phytoplankton and zooplankton. They specifically analyzed these networks based on two distinct size fractions of zooplankton: smaller (~160 µm) and larger (~500 µm), collected using different plankton nets. Standard network analysis techniques were employed to assess topological properties like network size, number of links, and complexity. To evaluate network stability, they calculated robustness (resistance to node removal) and vulnerability. Environmental factors (temperature, salinity, pH, metal concentrations, and nutrients) were also analyzed to understand their influence on the networks. Statistical methods like Mantel tests, CCA, VPA, and SEM were used to link environmental factors, plankton composition, and network structure.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 251 seawater samples collected along over 13,000 kilometers of the Chinese coastline, spanning latitudes from 20°N to 40°N. These samples contained approximately 307 phytoplankton species and 200 zooplankton species, which were categorized into smaller and larger size fractions. This comprehensive dataset allowed for a large-scale analysis of phyto-zooplankton interactions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Size Matters More Than We Thought: The study strongly suggests that zooplankton body size plays a more significant role in maintaining PZN stability than phytoplankton size. This implies that focusing solely on phytoplankton dynamics might be insufficient for understanding overall ecosystem health.
  • Smaller is More Stable: Contrary to a potential assumption that larger organisms might lead to more robust systems, this research found that PZNs are more complex and stable when associated with smaller zooplankton. This challenges conventional thinking and emphasizes the importance of smaller grazers.
  • Differential Interactions: Different sizes of zooplankton tend to interact with specific phytoplankton groups. Larger zooplankton were more associated with dinoflagellates, while smaller zooplankton showed a preference for diatoms. This suggests a size-based partitioning of resources and interactions within the planktonic community.
  • Body Size as an Environmental Filter: Zooplankton body size acts as a crucial mediator between environmental factors and network structure. Environmental changes influence the zooplankton community composition, which in turn shapes the overall PZN. This highlights a complex interplay where body size dictates how the ecosystem responds to external pressures.

Key Results

  • Phyto-zooplankton networks (PZNs) constructed with smaller zooplankton (PSZNs) exhibited higher complexity and stability compared to those with larger zooplankton (PBZNs). This was evidenced by larger network sizes, more links, and higher linkage density in PSZNs.
  • PSZNs showed significantly higher robustness to node loss (both phytoplankton and zooplankton removal) than PBZNs. This indicates that networks with smaller zooplankton are more resilient to disturbances.
  • The study found that zooplankton played a more central role in determining network stability than phytoplankton, as removing zooplankton nodes had a greater impact on network robustness.
  • Environmental factors, particularly metal concentrations, significantly influenced zooplankton composition, and this influence was stronger for smaller zooplankton. This suggests that smaller zooplankton are more sensitive to certain environmental changes.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that co-occurrence-based statistical approaches, while widely used, might not always represent real biotic interactions. They also note that only a minor portion of the networked community variations (26.75%) could be explained by the measured coastal variables and distance factors, suggesting that other unmeasured environmental variables or processes might be at play.

Future work could involve verifying these findings in diverse ecosystems to confirm the generality of the observed relationships. Further experimental designs that explicitly consider the role of zooplankton body size in cross-trophic interactions are also recommended. The study also suggests that specific biological treatment strategies for algal blooms should consider the size of the planktonic predators employed, hinting at potential applications in ecological management.

Summary updated

Abstract

The linkages between phytoplankton and zooplankton are crucial for the stability of complex food webs and the flow of energy within the marine ecosystem. Despite body size exhibiting multiple effects on the planktonic community assembly and the dispersal scale, its role in determining the stability of phyto-zooplanktonic co-occurrence patterns remains unclear. Here, we focused on more than 13,000 kilometers of the Chinese coast to study the diatom-dominated plankton ecosystem and to report the significant negative effects of zooplanktonic body sizes on the topological properties of phyto-zooplanktonic networks (PZNs) by using more than 500 species from 251 samples taken along the coastline. PZNs tended to be more complex and stable when phytoplankton associated with smaller zooplankton. Particularly, the subnetworks of dominant phytoplankton displayed differences with different zooplanktonic body sizes. The zooplankton with larger and smaller body sizes tended to interact with dinoflagellates and diatoms, respectively. Additionally, abiotic factors (i.e., water temperature, pH, salinity, and metal concentrations) displayed significant effects on PZNs via the shifting of zooplanktonic composition, and the zooplanktonic body sizes altered the network modules' associations with different environmental factors. Our study elucidated the general relationship between zooplanktonic body sizes and the stability of PZNs, which provides new insights into marine food webs. <b>IMPORTANCE</b> Body size is a key life trait of aquatic plankton that affects organisms' metabolic rates and ecological functions; however, its specific effects on interactions between phytoplankton and zooplankton are poorly understood. We collected planktonic species and their body size data along more than 13,000 kilometers of coastline to explore the role of zooplanktonic body size in maintaining the stability of phyto-zooplanktonic networks (PZNs). We found that zooplankton play a more important role in maintaining PZN stability than do phytoplankton as well as that the PZN would be more complex and stable with smaller zooplankton. Furthermore, this work revealed that body size significantly determined the relationships between environmental factors and network structure. Overall, these findings lay a general relationship between zooplanktonic body sizes and the stability of PZNs, which helps us further explore the micro food web of coastal ecosystems.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2022stability,
  author = {Zheng Zhang and Hongjun Li and Wenli Shen and Kai Feng and Shuzhen Li and Songsong Gu and Yuqi Zhou and Xi Peng and Xiongfeng Du and Qing He and Linlin Wang and Zhaojing Zhang and Danrui Wang and Zhujun Wang and Ye Deng},
  title = {{The Stability of Phyto-Zooplanktonic Networks Varied with Zooplanktonic Sizes in Chinese Coastal Ecosystem}},
  booktitle = {mSystems},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1128/msystems.00821-22},
}
Figure