The spiking output of the mouse olfactory bulb encodes large-scale temporal features of natural odor environments

M. E. Suzanne Lewis, Lucas M. Suarez, Nicola Rigolli, Kevin M. Franks, Nicholas A. Steinmetz, David H. GirebioRxiv 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the mouse olfactory bulb (OB) doesn't track every subtle sniff of an odor plume. Instead, it focuses on the broader temporal "gestures" of the plume – like when it starts, when it ends, and the presence or absence of odor "whiffs" – to guide navigation. This suggests a "big picture" approach to odor sensing, rather than a high-fidelity, moment-to-moment tracking.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Animals, especially mice, are remarkably adept at finding odor sources by navigating through complex, turbulent odor plumes. These plumes aren't smooth streams of scent but rather dynamic clouds of odor molecules interspersed with pockets of clean air ("whiffs" and "blanks"). While we know the olfactory bulb (OB) plays a crucial role in processing this information, it's been unclear how it does this. Specifically, do individual OB neurons meticulously track every fluctuation in odor concentration, or does the OB represent the odor environment at a more abstract, temporal level? Previous research hinted at some level of plume tracking, but the exact features encoded and whether this was a cellular or population-level phenomenon remained elusive. This paper aims to bridge this gap by simultaneously recording OB activity and precise odor plume dynamics to understand what temporal features of natural odor environments are represented in the OB.

Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated setup to tackle this question. They used high-density multi-shank Neuropixels 2.0 probes to simultaneously record from large populations of mitral and tufted cells (MTCs) in awake, head-fixed mice. To capture the odor environment, they used a modified, passive ethanol sensor placed very close to the mouse's nose to record odor concentration dynamics in real-time. This allowed them to correlate neural activity with the precise odor signal. They analyzed the neural data using smoothed kernel density functions (KDFs) to visualize firing rates and ZETA analysis to identify significant cellular responses to plume events like onset and offset. To assess how well populations could discern odor presence, they employed Support Vector Machine (SVM) binary classifiers with a radial kernel, trained to distinguish between "whiffs" (odor present) and "blanks" (odor absent).

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed in terms of pre-existing datasets for training. The study generated its own dataset by releasing odor plumes and simultaneously recording neural activity and odor concentration from awake, head-fixed mice.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • OB as a "Big Picture" Sensor: The most striking insight is that individual OB cells don't meticulously track every fine-grained fluctuation in odor concentration. Instead, they seem to be tuned to the larger temporal events of the plume.
  • Temporal Landmarks are Key: Plume onset and offset, along with the presence or absence of odor (whiffs and blanks), are the primary temporal features encoded. This suggests the OB is providing a "temporal map" of the odor environment.
  • Population Power: While individual cells might not be high-fidelity trackers, the collective activity of even a small number of OB cells (~20) is sufficient to accurately distinguish between odor presence and absence throughout a plume. This highlights the power of population coding.
  • MC vs. EPL/SFL Cells: Mitral cells (MCs) appear to play a more significant role in maintaining sustained responses after odor offset compared to external plexiform layer/superficial layer (EPL/SFL) cells, suggesting a potential specialization in representing odor persistence.

Key Results

  • Cellular Level: Individual OB cells reliably signaled plume onset and, in high concentration plumes, plume offset. However, their tracking of fine-scale odor concentration fluctuations was weak.
  • Population Level: OB populations could accurately distinguish between whiffs and blanks throughout the entire duration of a plume. This decoding accuracy remained robust even across different time windows of the plume.
  • Decoding Accuracy: SVM classifiers achieved high accuracy (around 90%) in decoding odor presence/absence, significantly above chance.
  • Cell Contribution: Adding a single mitral cell to a population improved decoding accuracy more than adding a single EPL/SFL cell, suggesting a greater contribution from MCs to discerning whiffs and blanks.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations. The odor mixture used was a blend of five odors plus ethanol as a tracer, which might not perfectly represent all natural odor environments. The odor sensor's placement (~4mm from the nose) introduces some decorrelation of odor compared to the exact concentration at the nostril. Furthermore, the stochastic nature of plumes makes precise, repeatable stimulus presentation challenging, and their recordings were primarily from the ventral OB, where odor expression research is less extensive than in dorsal or lateral regions.

Future work could involve using more controlled odor dynamics to disentangle the effects of concentration and intermittency. Investigating how recent stimulus history influences OB responses is also crucial. The authors suggest exploring optogenetics to precisely stimulate olfactory sensory neurons and better understand OB responses. Finally, further research is needed to understand how these OB signals are processed by downstream targets, particularly the piriform cortex, in odor-guided navigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

In natural odor environments, odor travels in plumes. Odor concentration dynamics change in characteristic ways across the width and length of a plume. Thus, spatiotemporal dynamics of plumes have informative features for animals navigating to an odor source. Population activity in the olfactory bulb (OB) has been shown to follow odor concentration across plumes to a moderate degree (Lewis et al., 2021). However, it is unknown whether the ability to follow plume dynamics is driven by individual cells or whether it emerges at the population level. Previous research has explored the responses of individual OB cells to isolated features of plumes, but it is difficult to adequately sample the full feature space of plumes as it is still undetermined which features navigating mice employ during olfactory guided search. Here we released odor from an upwind odor source and simultaneously recorded both odor concentration dynamics and cellular response dynamics in awake, head-fixed mice. We found that longer timescale features of odor concentration dynamics were encoded at both the cellular and population level. At the cellular level, responses were elicited at the beginning of the plume for each trial, signaling plume onset. Plumes with high odor concentration elicited responses at the end of the plume, signaling plume offset. Although cellular level tracking of plume dynamics was observed to be weak, we found that at the population level, OB activity distinguished whiffs and blanks (accurately detected odor presence versus absence) throughout the duration of a plume. Even ~20 OB cells were enough to accurately discern odor presence throughout a plume. Our findings indicate that the full range of odor concentration dynamics and high frequency fluctuations are not encoded by OB spiking activity. Instead, relatively lower-frequency temporal features of plumes, such as plume onset, plume offset, whiffs, and blanks, are represented in the OB.
BibTeX
@misc{lewis2024spiking,
  author = {M. E. Suzanne Lewis and Lucas M. Suarez and Nicola Rigolli and Kevin M. Franks and Nicholas A. Steinmetz and David H. Gire},
  title = {{The spiking output of the mouse olfactory bulb encodes large-scale temporal features of natural odor environments}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1101/2024.03.01.582978},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure