The shift from life in water to life on land advantaged planning in visually-guided behavior

Ugurcan Mugan, Malcolm A. MacIverbioRxiv 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how the transition from aquatic to terrestrial life, with its increased visual complexity, favored the evolution of planning abilities over simpler habit-based behaviors. Using computational simulations, they show that planning offers a significant advantage in visually-guided predator-prey scenarios, but only in complex terrestrial environments, suggesting a link between environmental complexity and the development of advanced cognitive strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles a fundamental question in evolutionary biology and neuroscience: why do terrestrial animals, in general, exhibit more complex cognitive abilities than aquatic ones, particularly the capacity for planning? While it's widely accepted that land-dwellers plan better, the evolutionary drivers behind this difference are not fully understood. The authors hypothesize that the dramatic increase in visual range and environmental complexity encountered when vertebrates moved from water to land provided a selective pressure for the evolution of planning. They aim to test this by comparing the effectiveness of habit-based versus plan-based decision-making in simulated aquatic and terrestrial predator-prey scenarios.

Methods

The core of the study involves computational simulations of predator-prey interactions. They developed two distinct decision-making systems for the "prey" agent:

  • Habit-based action selection: This system relies on learned associations between actions and outcomes based on past experience, akin to "muscle memory" or learned reflexes.
  • Plan-based action selection: This system involves simulating future states and evaluating potential outcomes before committing to an action, essentially "thinking ahead."

These agents were placed in simulated 2D environments representing both aquatic (simple, open) and terrestrial (complex, with obstacles) settings. Key variables manipulated included the prey's visual range and the environmental complexity (clutter). The simulations assessed survival rates under different conditions and with varying levels of planning depth (number of simulated future states).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulated environments and agent behaviors rather than real-world datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Environmental complexity is key: The advantage of planning over habit-based behavior is not universal; it emerges specifically in environments with high spatial complexity.
  • Visual range matters, but only with complexity: While increased visual range is beneficial, its utility for planning is amplified by the presence of environmental complexity that allows for more nuanced predictions and strategies.
  • Terrestrial environments as a crucible for planning: The transition to land, with its rich visual detail and obstacles, created a scenario where planning offered a significant survival advantage, driving its evolutionary selection.
  • Eigencentrality as a predictor of planning utility: The study introduces "eigencentrality" (a measure of network connectivity) as a proxy for environmental complexity and strategic importance. Transitions into high-eigencentrality regions (indicating more open and interconnected spaces) correlate with a shift towards planning.
  • Hybrid strategies are efficient: In complex environments, a hybrid approach that switches from habit to planning in high-eigencentrality areas can be as effective as continuous planning, suggesting an energy-efficient evolutionary pathway.

Key Results

  • In simple aquatic environments, planning offered no significant survival advantage over habit-based action selection.
  • In complex terrestrial environments, planning significantly increased prey survival rates, with the benefit increasing with both visual range and the depth of simulated futures.
  • The study found that planning becomes significantly more advantageous in environments with mid-range clutter and high spatial complexity (measured by network eigencentrality).
  • In these complex environments, prey using planning exhibited more variable and flexible behaviors, including the strategic use of occlusions for hiding and diversion.
  • A hybrid strategy, switching to planning in high-eigencentrality regions, performed nearly as well as continuous planning in complex environments, with only a small decline in survival rate.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational burden: The authors acknowledge the high computational cost of simulating planning, which limited their ability to simulate planning in both predator and prey simultaneously.
  • Simplified models: The simulations use simplified 2D environments and agent behaviors. Future work could explore more realistic 3D environments and a wider range of animal behaviors.
  • Generalizability of eigencentrality: While eigencentrality proved useful in this study, its broader applicability to non-spatial contexts for understanding decision-making shifts warrants further investigation.
  • Evolutionary pathways: The paper speculates on the evolutionary trajectory of planning, suggesting it may have initially evolved for less dynamic situations (e.g., olfaction-based exploration) before being adapted for dynamic visual scenarios. Future research could explore these earlier forms of planning.
  • Mechanisms of switching: The study suggests a potential mechanism for switching between habit and planning based on eigencentrality, but further research is needed to elucidate the neural underpinnings of this transition.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Other than formerly land-based mammals such as whales and dolphins that have returned to an aquatic existence, it is uncontroversial that land animals have developed more elaborated cognitive abilities than aquatic animals. Yet there is no apparent a-priori reason for this to be the case. A key cognitive faculty is the ability to plan. Here we provide evidence that in a dynamic visually-guided behavior of crucial evolutionary importance, prey evading a predator, planning provides a significant advantage over habit-based action selection, but only on land. This advantage is dependent on the massive increase in visual range and spatial complexity that greeted the first vertebrates to view the world above the waterline 380 million years ago. Our results have implications for understanding the evolutionary basis of the limited ability of animals, including humans, to think ahead to meet slowly looming and distant threats, toward a neuroscience of sustainability.
BibTeX
@misc{mugan2019shift,
  author = {Ugurcan Mugan and Malcolm A. MacIver},
  title = {{The shift from life in water to life on land advantaged planning in visually-guided behavior}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1101/585760},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure