TL;DR
This study investigates how moral injury impacts the coping styles of Chinese nursing interns, finding that while moral injury directly hinders positive coping, moral resilience and moral courage act as crucial buffers. These psychological resources not only mitigate the negative effects of moral injury but also facilitate more adaptive coping strategies, offering a pathway to improved mental well-being for these healthcare professionals.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Clinical internships are a critical, yet often stressful, period for nursing students. They are particularly vulnerable to "moral injury," a form of psychological distress arising from experiences that violate deeply held moral or ethical principles. This can stem from personal factors like inexperience or organizational issues like inadequate support. The paper highlights that moral injury can lead to severe mental health problems and negatively affect professional attitudes, potentially impacting patient care and the nursing workforce. While the link between moral injury and negative outcomes is established, the specific mechanisms by which nursing interns cope with this stress, and the role of protective psychological factors, remain underexplored, especially in the Chinese context. This study aims to fill this gap by examining how moral resilience and moral courage mediate the relationship between moral injury and positive coping styles.
Methods
The researchers employed a cross-sectional, multicenter study design, collecting data from 1,122 nursing interns across six nursing schools in Southwest China. They utilized a convenience sampling method and administered questionnaires online via social media platforms. The study used established scales to measure:
- Moral Injury: The Moral Injury Symptom Scale: Healthcare Professionals Version (MISS-HP).
- Positive Coping Style: The Simplified Coping Style Questionnaire (SCSQ).
- Moral Resilience: The Rushton Moral Resilience Scale (RMRS).
- Moral Courage: The Nurses' Moral Courage Scale (NMCS).
Statistical analysis involved Pearson correlation to examine relationships between variables and regression-based mediation analysis using the PROCESS 4.1 macro (specifically Model 6) to test the hypothesized serial mediation effects. Covariates such as demographics and professional factors were controlled for.
Datasets
The study utilized data collected from 1,122 nursing interns in China. No new datasets or benchmarks were introduced.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Moral Injury is a Direct Threat to Positive Coping: The study confirms that experiencing moral injury directly impairs a nursing intern's ability to engage in positive coping strategies. This is a foundational finding, establishing the direct negative pathway.
- Resilience and Courage as Essential Buffers: The most significant insight is the crucial role of moral resilience and moral courage. These aren't just passive traits; they actively mediate the relationship, buffering the negative impact of moral injury and promoting positive coping.
- Synergistic Effect of Resilience and Courage: The findings strongly suggest that moral resilience and moral courage work together, not just independently, but also in a serial fashion. Moral resilience appears to foster moral courage, which then further supports positive coping. This highlights a developmental or sequential relationship between these protective factors.
- Context Matters: The study's focus on Chinese nursing interns provides valuable insights into this specific cultural and educational context, suggesting that interventions should be tailored accordingly.
Key Results
- Negative Correlations: Moral injury was negatively associated with moral resilience (r = -0.463), moral courage (r = -0.226), and positive coping scores (r = -0.235), all at P < 0.001.
- Positive Correlations: Moral resilience was positively correlated with moral courage (r = 0.184) and positive coping (r = 0.196). Moral courage was also positively associated with positive coping (r = 0.515), all at P < 0.001.
- Mediation Effects:
- Moral injury directly influenced positive coping, accounting for 46.61% of the total effect.
- Indirect effects were observed:
- Through moral resilience: 18.64% of the total effect.
- Through moral courage: 23.73% of the total effect.
- Through the serial mediation of moral resilience and moral courage: 11.02% of the total effect.
- The combined mediating effect of moral resilience and moral courage accounted for 53.39% of the total effect.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Self-Report Bias: Data relied on self-reported measures, which can be influenced by social desirability, potentially leading to idealized responses rather than actual coping behaviors. Future research could incorporate objective measures like behavioral observations.
- Limited Mediators/Moderators: The study focused on moral resilience and courage. Other potential factors like social support, work environment, and personal beliefs were not explored and could offer a more comprehensive understanding.
- Geographical Scope: The sample was limited to nursing interns in Southwest China. Differences in educational systems and internship environments across China mean these findings may not be generalizable nationwide. Future studies should include a broader geographical representation.
The authors suggest that future research should explore these additional mediators and moderators to gain a more complete picture of how nursing interns cope with moral injury.
Summary updated