The Semantics of Intention Maintenance for Rational Agents

IJCAI 1995

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of formally modeling how rational agents maintain their intentions over time, especially as their beliefs and desires change. The authors introduce a novel "only intention" modality to precisely capture the commitment inherent in intentions, leading to a more robust semantic and axiomatic framework for intention maintenance in BDI (Belief-Desire-Intention) agent architectures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Agent-oriented systems, which are increasingly used in complex applications like air traffic control and network management, often rely on the concept of agents having beliefs, desires, and intentions (BDI). While the static relationships between these mental attitudes (e.g., an agent only intends what it believes is possible and desires) have been well-studied, the dynamics of how intentions are maintained over time have been problematic to formalize.

Previous attempts to axiomatize intention maintenance often led to undesirable consequences. For instance, if an agent intends to do A or B, and A becomes impossible, the intention might incorrectly persist for B. Similarly, if an agent intends to have milk and cereal, and obtaining milk becomes impossible, the intention to have cereal might be incorrectly maintained. These issues stem from how standard logical systems handle closure properties of intentions, particularly under conjunction and disjunction. The paper aims to provide a formal framework that accurately reflects our intuitive understanding of intention maintenance, where intentions represent a commitment that persists unless certain conditions are met.

Methods

The authors build upon a previously developed possible-worlds semantic model for BDI agents. This model represents an agent's state as a set of possible worlds, where each world is a branching tree structure. Beliefs, desires, and intentions are modeled by sets of "accessible worlds."

The core innovation is the introduction of an "only intention" modality, denoted as OINTEND(φ). This modality is stronger than the standard INTEND(φ). While INTEND(φ) means φ is true in all intention-accessible worlds, OINTEND(φ) additionally requires that the set of intention-accessible worlds exactly corresponds to the worlds where φ is true. This precise specification of intention-accessible worlds is crucial for capturing the commitment aspect.

They then develop a BDI logic (BDICTL*) incorporating this new modality and define semantic constraints for intention revision. These constraints ensure that intentions are maintained only if they remain believed to be possible and desired. The paper also introduces belief and desire revision functions that map old accessible worlds to new ones, reflecting changes in the agent's environment or knowledge.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Only Intention" Modality is Key: The paper argues that standard modal operators are insufficient for capturing the nuances of intention maintenance. The OINTEND operator provides the necessary expressiveness to precisely define the scope of an agent's commitment, preventing unintended consequences arising from closure properties.
  • Commitment is Semantic: The authors emphasize that intention maintenance is fundamentally about commitment. Their semantic approach, by precisely defining the set of intention-accessible worlds, directly models this commitment, rather than relying on ad-hoc axiomatizations.
  • Dynamic Revision is Crucial: The paper highlights that intentions don't exist in a vacuum. They must be revised in light of changing beliefs and desires. The proposed framework provides a mechanism for this dynamic revision, ensuring that intentions remain consistent with the agent's evolving mental state.
  • Problems with Closure: The paper clearly illustrates how naive assumptions about closure under conjunction and disjunction lead to paradoxes in intention maintenance. The OINTEND operator offers a principled way to avoid these issues.

Key Results

The paper presents several theorems that demonstrate the utility of the OINTEND operator and the proposed semantic framework. Specifically, they show how OINTEND prevents the problematic inferences identified in the introductory examples. For instance, OINTEND(φ ∨ ψ) does not imply OINTEND(φ) or OINTEND(ψ), and OINTEND(φ ∧ ψ) does not imply OINTEND(φ) and OINTEND(ψ). This allows for a more accurate formalization of intention maintenance. The paper also outlines axioms for intention maintenance that are consistent with belief and desire revision.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future directions:

  • Completeness: They have not proven the completeness of their axiomatization with respect to the proposed semantics.
  • Restrictive Constraints: The current model uses restrictive constraints on correspondence functions relating beliefs, desires, and intentions. Relaxing these constraints would allow for more general models.
  • Decision-Theoretic Framework: The paper suggests that their work needs to be integrated into a decision-theoretic framework to fully capture rational agency.
  • Plans: The paper touches upon the notion of plans but does not delve deeply into their role in intention revision, leaving this as an area for future exploration.
  • Partial Mappings: The current work assumes total 1-1 mappings for revision functions, which is a simplification. Investigating the implications of partial mappings is also suggested.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{1995semantics,
  title = {{The Semantics of Intention Maintenance for Rational Agents}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {1995},
}
Figure