THE SDSS-III BARYON OSCILLATION SPECTROSCOPIC SURVEY: QUASAR TARGET SELECTION FOR DATA RELEASE NINE

Nicholas P. Ross, Adam D. Myers, E. Sheldon, Christophe Yèche, Michael A. Strauss, Jo Bovy, Jessica A. Kirkpatrick, Gordon T. Richards, Éric Aubourg, Michael R. Blanton, W. N. Brandt, W. Carithers, Rupert A. C. Croft, Robert da Silva, Kyle Dawson, Daniel J. Eisenstein, Joseph F. Hennawi, Shirley Ho, David W. Hogg, Khee‐Gan Lee, Britt Lundgren, R. G. McMahon, Jordi Miralda‐Escudé, N. Palanque‐Delabrouille, Isabelle Pâris, Patrick Petitjean, Matthew M. Pieri, J. Rich, Natalie A. Roe, David Schiminovich, David J. Schlegel, Donald P. Schneider, Anže Slosar, N. Suzuki, Jeremy L. Tinker, David H. Weinberg, Anya Weyant, Martin White, W. M. Wood‐VaseyThe Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series 2012 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey (BOSS), part of SDSS-III, aims to map the expansion history of the universe by observing the "Lyman-alpha forest" in the spectra of 150,000 high-redshift quasars. This paper details the complex statistical and machine-learning machinery—including Neural Networks and Extreme Deconvolution—used to identify these rare targets from millions of similar-looking stars in imaging data.

The Challenge: Finding Needles in a Cosmic Haystack

To measure Baryon Acoustic Oscillations (BAO) at high redshifts ($z > 2$), astronomers require a high surface density of quasars to act as "backlights." As their light travels toward Earth, it passes through intergalactic hydrogen clouds, creating a "forest" of absorption lines known as the Lyman-alpha forest. This forest provides a 3D map of the large-scale structure of the early universe.

The primary challenge is one of selection. Quasars are significantly rarer than stars. At a redshift of $z \approx 2.7$, the colors of quasars in standard optical filters ($ugriz$) overlap almost perfectly with common A-type stars and blue horizontal branch stars. To succeed, the BOSS team needed to develop a target selection algorithm that was both efficient (minimizing wasted spectroscopic fibers on stars) and complete (ensuring enough quasars for a dense map).

Advanced Selection Methods

The authors moved beyond traditional color-cut boxes, implementing sophisticated probabilistic and machine-learning approaches to maximize yield:

  • KDE (Kernel Density Estimation): A non-parametric method estimating the density of stars and quasars in multi-dimensional color space to assign probabilities to candidates.
  • Likelihood Methods: Utilizing $\chi^2$-like statistics to compare candidate fluxes against training sets of known objects.
  • Artificial Neural Networks (ANN): A multi-layer perceptron that classifies objects based on magnitudes and associated errors.
  • XDQSO (Extreme Deconvolution): Serving as the "CORE" algorithm, XDQSO models the underlying distribution of objects as a sum of Gaussians while explicitly accounting for heteroscedastic measurement errors. This is particularly effective for faint targets near the detection limit.
  • NN-Combinator: A "meta-classifier" that integrates outputs from various algorithms to produce a final prioritized target list.
Flowchart of the BOSS quasar target selection process, illustrating the complex logic used to filter SDSS photometry into CORE and BONUS target samples.

Key Insights: Breaking the $z=2.7$ Barrier

A critical finding of the paper is the difficulty of identifying quasars at $z \approx 2.7$. These scientifically valuable objects reside exactly on the "stellar locus" in color space. Furthermore, standard color cuts fail at faint magnitudes because photometric noise "smears" the distributions, making stars look like quasars and vice versa.

Color-color diagrams (g-r) vs (u-g) for bright (left) and faint (right) targets. The colored track represents the expected colors of quasars at different redshifts. Note how the quasar track (colored squares) crosses the dense stellar locus (black dots) at specific redshifts, and how noise increases the overlap for fainter objects.

To manage this, the survey split targets into two categories:

  1. CORE Sample: Selected via a single, fixed algorithm (XDQSO) to ensure a uniform sample for statistical studies of quasar evolution.
  2. BONUS Sample: Utilized every available technique, including multi-wavelength data from GALEX (UV), UKIDSS (Near-IR), and FIRST (Radio), to maximize the density of backlights for BAO measurements.

Results and Future Directions

In its first year alone, BOSS confirmed 11,263 new quasars at $z > 2.2$, nearly doubling the global sample known at the time. The algorithms achieved a surface density of approximately 15 high-$z$ quasars per square degree from a budget of 40 targets per square degree, meeting the technical requirements for the BAO experiment. XDQSO proved superior, selecting roughly one additional high-$z$ quasar per square degree compared to previous methods.

Despite these advances, limitations remain. Approximately 25-30% of targets are still stars, especially at the faint limit ($g \approx 22$), and a completeness "dip" persists around $z \approx 2.7$. Future work may incorporate variability data—measuring how an object's brightness changes over time—to further distinguish flickering quasars from steady-burning stars.

Summary updated

Abstract

33 pages, 26 figures, 12 tables and a whole bunch of quasars. Submitted to ApJ
BibTeX
@article{ross2012sdss,
  author = {Nicholas P. Ross and Adam D. Myers and E. Sheldon and Christophe Yèche and Michael A. Strauss and Jo Bovy and Jessica A. Kirkpatrick and Gordon T. Richards and Éric Aubourg and Michael R. Blanton and W. N. Brandt and W. Carithers and Rupert A. C. Croft and Robert da Silva and Kyle Dawson and Daniel J. Eisenstein and Joseph F. Hennawi and Shirley Ho and David W. Hogg and Khee‐Gan Lee and Britt Lundgren and R. G. McMahon and Jordi Miralda‐Escudé and N. Palanque‐Delabrouille and Isabelle Pâris and Patrick Petitjean and Matthew M. Pieri and J. Rich and Natalie A. Roe and David Schiminovich and David J. Schlegel and Donald P. Schneider and Anže Slosar and N. Suzuki and Jeremy L. Tinker and David H. Weinberg and Anya Weyant and Martin White and W. M. Wood‐Vasey},
  title = {{THE SDSS-III BARYON OSCILLATION SPECTROSCOPIC SURVEY: QUASAR TARGET SELECTION FOR DATA RELEASE NINE}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1088/0067-0049/199/1/3},
}
Figure