TL;DR
This study validates the INTERGROWTH-21st Fetal Growth Standards by following a cohort of healthy children up to two years of age. The findings demonstrate that these children maintained satisfactory growth and development, supporting the standards' appropriateness for constructing international growth charts and aiding in global health monitoring.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
For decades, monitoring fetal and child growth has relied on a patchwork of local growth charts, often based on diverse populations and hospital-specific data. This creates inconsistencies and challenges in comparing growth across different regions and socioeconomic backgrounds. The World Health Organization (WHO) recommends international standards, but until the INTERGROWTH-21st Project, a comprehensive set of international standards for fetal growth, newborn size, and preterm infant growth was lacking. This study addresses the critical question of whether the healthy cohort used to create these INTERGROWTH-21st standards continued to exhibit optimal growth and development postnatally, specifically up to the key milestone of two years of age. This validation is crucial for confirming the standards' utility and ensuring they accurately reflect healthy growth in diverse populations worldwide.
Methods
The study employed a prospective, longitudinal design, following infants from the INTERGROWTH-21st Project's Infant Follow-up Study. Key methods included:
- Standardized Anthropometric Measurements: Weight, length, and head circumference were meticulously measured by trained teams at birth and at 1 and 2 years of age, adhering to strict WHO protocols and using calibrated equipment.
- Motor Development Assessment: Four key WHO motor development milestones (sitting without support, hands-and-knees crawling, standing alone, and walking alone) were assessed using standardized forms and parental reporting, with a focus on minimizing recall bias.
- Morbidity and Health Data Collection: Information on health, severe morbidities, feeding practices, and nutritional intake was collected using standardized forms.
- Statistical Analysis: Age- and sex-specific z-scores and percentiles were calculated using WHO Child Growth Standards. Variance components analysis was used to quantify the contribution of between-site and within-site variability to overall growth. For preterm infants, corrected age was used.
Datasets
The primary dataset for this study is the INTERGROWTH-21st Project cohort, which includes:
- Fetal Growth Longitudinal Study: Provided data for the international fetal growth standards.
- Newborn Size at Birth Study: Provided data for newborn size standards.
- Preterm Postnatal Growth Study: Provided data for preterm postnatal growth standards.
This study specifically focuses on the Infant Follow-up Study, which evaluated a subset of these infants up to 2 years of age. The study also utilized the World Health Organization (WHO) Child Growth Standards and WHO motor development milestone distributions for comparison.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Confirmation of Prescriptive Standards: The study strongly supports the idea that a carefully selected, healthy cohort can indeed represent a "prescriptive population" for constructing international growth standards, as opposed to purely descriptive ones.
- "Growth Channelization" in Action: The findings suggest that children tend to grow along the same percentile once they reach a certain age, a phenomenon known as "growth channelization." This implies that early growth patterns are highly influential.
- Transgenerational "Washout" Effect: The observed increase in predicted adult height in children from low-middle income countries compared to their parents suggests a potential "washout" effect where improved environmental and nutritional conditions in one generation can lead to significant growth improvements.
- Weight vs. Length for Population Comparisons: The study highlights that length is a more sensitive indicator for evaluating growth potential across populations than weight, as it is less affected by acute influences like short-term nutritional changes.
Key Results
- High Follow-up Rate: 3042 out of 3711 eligible infants (82%) were evaluated at 2 years of age, with similar rates for the preterm subgroup (86%).
- Growth Aligns with WHO Standards: At 2 years of age, the INTERGROWTH-21st cohort's growth (weight, length, head circumference) plotted almost perfectly onto the WHO Child Growth Standards, falling within the 3rd and 97th percentiles.
- Length: 49th percentile (mean z-score 0.01 ± 1.1)
- Head Circumference: 50th percentile (mean z-score 0.01 ± 1.1)
- Weight: 58th percentile (mean z-score 0.21 ± 1.1)
- Motor Development Milestones Achieved: Over 99% of children achieved the four assessed motor development milestones by 2 years of age, with over 97% falling within the WHO range for normal term infants.
- Low Inter-Site Variability: Variance components analysis revealed that only 5.5% of the total variability in length between birth and 2 years of age was explained by differences among study sites, while 42.9% was due to individual variation within sites. This underscores the consistency of growth across diverse geographic locations when health and nutrition are adequate.
- Predicted Adult Height Increase: Children from low-middle income countries in the cohort are predicted to be approximately 8.9 cm taller than their parents, suggesting a significant intergenerational growth improvement.
Limitations and Future Work
- Morbidity Data: Information on morbidity was primarily based on parental report and focused on substantive clinical episodes, rather than direct observation.
- Study Duration: The study outcomes do not extend beyond 2 years of age, although this age was chosen as a key predictor of subsequent growth.
- Seattle Site Exclusion: The Seattle, WA, study site could not participate in the follow-up due to logistical issues, representing a small portion of the overall cohort.
- Future Work: The authors suggest further research into the complex interactions of nutrition, environment, migration, and social-cultural issues on fetal growth patterns. They also highlight the ongoing investigation into the mechanisms of transgenerational phenotype "washout" at the molecular level in the INTERBIO-21st Study. The study also points to the need for further exploration of the timing, velocity, and individual tracking of growth from conception to 2 years of age, particularly in relation to feeding and morbidity in high-risk populations.
Summary updated