Abstract: Êèїâñüêèé ³íñòèòóò б³зíåñó ³ òåхíîëîг³éБєлов О. В
Introduction
Ukraine’s economic recovery and long-term growth are inextricably linked to its innovative and scientific potential. However, the country has long struggled with a "brain drain" and a shrinking research and development (R&D) sector. This paper, published in 2020, investigates the primary driver of this decline: the relative compensation of scientific and technical personnel. By analyzing regional salary trends over a 14-year period (2004–2017), the study highlights a systemic devaluation of scientific labor compared to average regional wages.
Methodology: The Speed-Acceleration Approach
To move beyond simple absolute salary figures, the authors employ a "speed-acceleration" method. This approach analyzes the dynamics of the salary level indicator ($Роп_{ij}$), defined as the ratio of the average scientific salary to the average regional salary.
Two primary metrics are calculated:
- Speed ($v$): The absolute increase of the salary ratio, indicating whether relative pay is growing or shrinking.
- Acceleration ($a$): The absolute increase of the speed, indicating whether the trend is intensifying or stabilizing.
Based on these metrics, the economic state of a region is classified into one of four groups, ranging from ideal growth to a state of crisis.
Data Analysis and Trends
The study utilizes data from the official statistical yearbooks "Science and Innovation in Ukraine" from 2004 to 2017. The most striking finding is the crossing of the "100% threshold." In 2004, scientists in nearly every region (24 out of 25) earned significantly more than the average regional wage. By 2017, the situation had reversed: in only five regions did scientific salaries remain above the regional average.
Nationally, the ratio plummeted from 136% in 2004 to just 89% in 2017. This indicates that a career in science has transitioned from a premium profession to one that pays less than the national average wage, severely undermining the sector's attractiveness to new talent.
Key Insights
- The "Group 4" Trap: The analysis reveals that most regions spent the majority of the study period in Group 4 (accelerating decline). This suggests that the devaluation of scientific work was not a temporary fluctuation but a self-reinforcing downward trend.
- Fragmented Recovery: While some regions, including Kyiv, showed periodic "pulses" of improvement (moving into Group 1 or 2), these were short-lived and failed to alter the long-term negative trajectory.
- Regional Disparities: Industrial hubs like Dnipropetrovsk and Zaporizhzhia showed more resilience than agrarian regions, yet they too succumbed to the broader national trend of declining relative pay by the end of the period.
Conclusion
The persistent negative "speed" and "acceleration" of scientific salaries in Ukraine signal a deep-seated crisis. The authors conclude that without urgent state-level intervention to reverse these trends, the country risks a total loss of its competitive scientific workforce. Future research is recommended to apply this methodology to other indicators, such as total R&D funding and the modernization of laboratory infrastructure, to provide a more holistic view of the sector's health.
Summary updated