The Rotor-Vibrator Plus Multi-Particle-Hole Description of 154Gd

Yingxin Wu, Aoxue Li, Feng Pan, Lianrong Dai, Jerry P. DraayerSymmetry 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel theoretical model that combines the established rotor-vibrator and particle-plus-rotor models to describe the complex behavior of well-deformed atomic nuclei, specifically focusing on 154Gd. By incorporating multi-particle-hole excitations, the model offers a more comprehensive explanation for the observed low-lying excited states, particularly the enigmatic 0+ states, providing a better fit to experimental data than previous approaches.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Atomic nuclei, especially those in the rare earth and actinide regions, exhibit intricate energy spectra. While models like the collective rotor-vibrator model (RVM) and the interacting boson model (IBM) have been successful in describing many nuclear properties, they often struggle to fully account for the numerous low-lying 0+ excited states observed in well-deformed nuclei like 154Gd. These states have been a long-standing puzzle, with their exact nature remaining debated. Existing models often predict these states at energies that don't align with experimental observations or fail to capture their collective behavior. This paper aims to bridge this gap by proposing a more sophisticated model that can better explain these complex states.

Methods

The core of this work lies in a new theoretical framework that extends the conventional rotor-vibrator model (RVM) and particle-plus-rotor model (PRM). The proposed "Rotor-Vibrator Plus Multi-Particle-Hole Description" (RV+MPH) incorporates multi-particle-hole (MPH) excitations from a collective even-even core. This means that in addition to the collective motion of the nucleus (described by the RVM), the model also considers the excitation of multiple particles and holes within the nucleus.

The Hamiltonian used in this model includes terms for the RVM core, proton and neutron single-particle and single-hole energies, and interactions between these excited pairs. A key aspect is the preservation of the intrinsic D2 symmetry, which is characteristic of well-deformed nuclei. The model specifically considers 2p2h (two-particle, two-hole) excitations as a significant contribution to the observed 0+ states, complementing the beta and gamma vibrations already described by the RVM. The authors then apply this model to 154Gd, fitting its low-lying positive parity level energies, excitation energies of 0+ states, and various experimental data like B(E2) values and branching ratios.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is experimental nuclear spectroscopy data for 154Gd. Specifically, the authors utilize:

  • Low-lying positive parity level energies: Data from experiments, particularly from the NuDat 2.8 database and recent theses, for levels below 1.990 MeV.
  • 0+ excitation energies: A series of experimentally identified 0+ states up to a certain energy level.
  • B(E2) values: Experimental data for electric quadrupole transition probabilities.
  • E2 branching ratios: Ratios of different E2 transition probabilities.
  • E2/M1 and E0/E2 mixing ratios: Experimental data for the mixing of different types of electromagnetic transitions.

The paper also references theoretical calculations from other models, such as the original RVM and the Interacting Boson Model (IBM), for comparison.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • MPH excitations as a key to 0+ states: The most significant insight is that multi-particle-hole excitations, particularly 2p2h configurations, play a crucial role in understanding the nature and energies of low-lying 0+ states in well-deformed nuclei. This offers a complementary explanation to the standard beta and gamma vibrations.
  • Improved description of 154Gd spectra: The RV+MPH model provides a better fit to the experimental level energies of 154Gd compared to the original RVM, especially for higher excited 0+ bands.
  • Shape coexistence and configuration mixing: The study reinforces the idea that shape coexistence and configuration mixing are important phenomena in these nuclei, potentially involving pairing isomers and different nuclear deformations.
  • Limitations of simpler models: The paper highlights the limitations of simpler models like the RVM in accurately predicting the energies of higher excited 0+ states, underscoring the need for more sophisticated approaches.

Key Results

The study successfully applies the RV+MPH model to 154Gd, achieving the following:

  • Good fit to level energies: The model provides a significantly improved fit to the low-lying positive parity level energies below 1.990 MeV compared to the original RVM. Two fitting schemes (S1 and S2) were explored, with S1 showing slightly better agreement for level energies.
  • Accurate B(E2) values: The calculated B(E2) values for transitions within the lowest three bands (ground-state, beta, and gamma) are in good agreement with experimental data and comparable to those from the RVM.
  • Improved E2/M1 ratios: The E2/M1 mixing ratios calculated by the RV+MPH model (both S1 and S2) are found to be acceptable and better than those obtained from the IBM.
  • Discrepancies in specific ratios: While generally good, some B(E2) ratios, particularly those involving the 05 band, show noticeable deviations. Similarly, the B(M1, 2+ → 2+) values are found to be about two times smaller than experimental values, suggesting a trade-off for achieving a better fit to E2/M1 ratios.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest avenues for future research:

  • Parameter dependence: The model's accuracy is influenced by the number of parameters involved, and a mixing of configurations from different schemes might further improve results.
  • Neglected interactions: The current model neglects certain interactions, such as K-band mixing, rotation-particle, and rotation-hole coupling terms. Including these could lead to more accurate predictions for B(E2) values and E2/M1 ratios.
  • Shape coexistence and pairing: Further investigation into shape coexistence, particularly involving different deformed bases and pairing interactions among nucleons, is recommended.
  • Extension to other nuclei: The model's applicability to other well-deformed nuclei and chains of isotopes could be explored to study shape phase evolution.
  • Experimental data: The authors emphasize the need for more precise experimental measurements of E2 and M1 transition rates and mixing ratios, as well as data from two-nucleon transfer reactions, to further validate and refine theoretical models.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{wu2022rotor,
  author = {Yingxin Wu and Aoxue Li and Feng Pan and Lianrong Dai and Jerry P. Draayer},
  title = {{The Rotor-Vibrator Plus Multi-Particle-Hole Description of 154Gd}},
  journal = {Symmetry},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/sym14122620},
}
Figure