The Rondo-Thinking in the Symphonic Poem “Festival of Rome”

Chenghong Wang2020 · DOI

Abstract

As one of the outstanding composers of the 20th century, Respighi is famous for his three symphonic poems "Fountain of Rome" ("Fontane di Roma"), "Pine of Rome" ("Pini di Roma") and "Festival of Rome" ("Feste Romane"). Through the study and analysis of the "Festival of Rome", this paper finds that Respighi has unique characteristics in the application of the rondo principle in the classical structural principles. He extended the classical structure principle of rondo to the level of rondo-thinking and applied it to the musical details of his works, such as sections, motivations, tonality, dynamics and tempo. This kind of creative thinking of extending and developing the principle of musical form is of enlightening significance to contemporary music creation.

Introduction: Beyond the Classical Rondo

In traditional music theory, a "Rondo" is a specific form (usually A-B-A-C-A) where a principal theme, or refrain, returns periodically, separated by contrasting episodes. However, as music evolved into the 20th century, these rigid structures often felt too restrictive for the fluid, atmospheric styles of Impressionism and Post-Romanticism.

Ottorino Respighi, in his symphonic poem Festival of Rome, addresses this tension by evolving the Rondo form into a broader "Rondo-thinking" process. Rather than adhering to a strict melodic template, Respighi abstracts the logic of the rondo—recurrence and contrast—and applies it as a fractal-like organizational tool across various musical dimensions. This allows the work to maintain internal logic and structural unity within a modern, impressionistic soundscape.

Defining Rondo-Thinking

"Rondo-thinking" is defined as an expanded cognition where the "refrain" is no longer limited to a melodic theme. Instead, a refrain can be a specific motive, a timbre, a tonal center, or even a dynamic level. The paper identifies six distinct levels of this application:

  1. Inter-paragraph: Large-scale structural repetitions.
  2. Music sections: Recurring closing factors at the end of phrases.
  3. Motivations: Short, recurring motives that anchor different musical ideas.
  4. Orchestration: Alternating between specific instrumental textures.
  5. Tonality and Harmony: Alternating between stable central keys and unstable harmonies.
  6. Tempo and Intensity: Using specific volume levels or speeds as recurring structural anchors.
Figure 3: Structural phrasing and orchestration details in the score, showing the interplay between different instrumental groups.

Structural Insights and Results

Non-Thematic Refrains and Intensity

In the "Arena" movement, Respighi uses a specific high-intensity volume (ff) as a structural refrain. The listener experiences the "return" of the volume as a point of stability, much like they would a returning melody in a Mozart rondo. Similarly, orchestration itself can function as a rondo; by alternating between the full orchestra's roar and solo instruments, Respighi creates a structural rhythm based on sound color.

Figure 6: Score excerpt showing the use of 'Orchestra ff' and shifts between Moderato and Molto allegro as structural anchors.

Motivic and Harmonic Anchoring

In "Arena," a specific "threat motive" (bA-F-G-bA) acts as a recurring anchor at the end of disparate phrases, providing a sense of dread and unity. In the "Epiphany" movement, the paper identifies a complex sequence (A-B-A1-B1-C-A2-E) that functions as a rondo but breaks classical rules by ending on an "inserted" part rather than the refrain. Furthermore, Respighi utilizes harmonic contrast in the final part of "Epiphany," using D major as a "static" refrain interspersed with unstable harmonies to create a rondo of tonal stability versus instability.

Conclusion

Respighi’s shift from rondo form (a noun) to rondo-thinking (a process) represents a significant evolution in 20th-century composition. While this study focuses on a single work, the implications are broad. This creative extension of musical form remains highly relevant for contemporary composers—including those in film scoring or electronic music—who seek to balance innovation with structural integrity. Future research could apply this lens to other modern genres where traditional forms are often abandoned in favor of atmospheric or motivic unity.

Summary updated

Abstract

As one of the outstanding composers of the 20th century, Respighi is famous for his three symphonic poems "Fountain of Rome" ("Fontane di Roma"), "Pine of Rome" ("Pini di Roma") and "Festival of Rome" ("Feste Romane"). Through the study and analysis of the "Festival of Rome", this paper finds that Respighi has unique characteristics in the application of the rondo principle in the classical structural principles. He extended the classical structure principle of rondo to the level of rondothinking and applied it to the musical details of his works, such as sections, motivations, tonality, dynamics and tempo. This kind of creative thinking of extending and developing the principle of musical form is of enlightening significance to contemporary music creation.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2020rondo,
  author = {Chenghong Wang},
  title = {{The Rondo-Thinking in the Symphonic Poem “Festival of Rome”}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.2991/assehr.k.200907.022},
}
Figure