The roles of selectivity filters in determining aluminum transport by AtNIP1;2

Yuqi Wang, Enzong Xiao, Guorong Wu, Qing Bai, Feng Xu, Xiyue Ji, Chun’e Li, Jiping LiuPlant 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how specific structural regions within the aquaporin AtNIP1;2, known to transport aluminum, dictate its substrate specificity. By mutating key residues in the NPA and ar/R constriction regions, the researchers demonstrate their critical role in aluminum transport but find that mimicking the boric acid transporter AtNIP5;1's constrictions doesn't confer boric acid transport, suggesting other factors are at play.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Aquaporins (AQPs) are crucial membrane proteins that facilitate the transport of water and small molecules across cell membranes. While their general function is understood, the precise mechanisms by which specific AQPs achieve selectivity for different substrates remain an active area of research. Previous work identified AtNIP1;2, an aquaporin from Arabidopsis, as a transporter of aluminum (Al), likely in the form of aluminum-malate complexes, playing a vital role in plant Al tolerance. However, the specific structural elements within AtNIP1;2 responsible for this Al transport and its selectivity were unclear. This paper aims to elucidate the role of the "constriction regions" within the AtNIP1;2 pore – specifically the NPA motifs and the ar/R selectivity filter – in determining its transport activity and substrate specificity, particularly in distinguishing between aluminum and boron.

Methods

The researchers employed a site-directed mutagenesis approach to alter specific amino acid residues within the NPA motifs and the ar/R selectivity filter of AtNIP1;2. They generated single and multiple mutants, including those designed to mimic the corresponding regions in AtNIP5;1, a known boric acid transporter. These wild-type and mutant AtNIP1;2 proteins were then expressed in Saccharomyces cerevisiae (yeast) for functional analysis.

Two primary experimental techniques were used:

  • Yeast Al sensitivity assay (drop assay): Yeast strains expressing different AtNIP1;2 variants were grown on media supplemented with varying concentrations of aluminum-malate (Al-Mal). Growth inhibition served as an indicator of Al uptake and toxicity mediated by the expressed protein.
  • Yeast Al and Boron uptake assays: Short-term (2-hour) uptake experiments were conducted using yeast cells expressing the AtNIP1;2 variants. The internal concentrations of Al and Boron (B) were quantified using Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS) to directly measure transport activity.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on experimental manipulation of a single protein (AtNIP1;2) and its mutants, rather than utilizing large-scale datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Constriction regions are critical for Al transport: Mutations in the conserved NPA motifs (specifically the third residue) and the ar/R selectivity filter (particularly the first and fourth residues) significantly impaired or abolished AtNIP1;2's ability to transport aluminum. This strongly supports the hypothesis that these regions act as primary determinants of Al transport.
  • Mimicking AtNIP5;1's constrictions is insufficient for B transport: Despite engineering AtNIP1;2 to possess NPA and ar/R regions similar to the boric acid transporter AtNIP5;1, the resulting mutants could not transport boron. This is a crucial finding, indicating that while these regions are important for selectivity, they are not the sole determinants of substrate specificity.
  • AtNIP1;2 is likely not a boric acid transporter: The native AtNIP1;2 and its ar/R mutants showed no detectable boron uptake, reinforcing that its primary function, as investigated here, is aluminum transport.
  • Beyond constrictions: The inability to confer boric acid transport by mimicking AtNIP5;1's constrictions suggests that other structural features within the aquaporin pore or even post-translational modifications might be essential for determining the precise nature of a transporter's substrate specificity.

Key Results

  • Mutations N111L, N230L (NPA motifs), and R233G (ar/R region) in AtNIP1;2 abolished Al sensitivity in yeast cells, and corresponding Al uptake assays showed a significant reduction in Al transport compared to wild-type AtNIP1;2.
  • The wild-type AtNIP1;2 construct showed approximately a 3-fold higher Al uptake rate than the control (CK) line.
  • Mutations in the third residue of the NPA motifs (A113S) and the first residue of the ar/R tetrad (W91A) had the most significant negative impact on AtNIP1;2-mediated Al uptake.
  • AtNIP1;2 mutants engineered to mimic AtNIP5;1's NPA (NPS/NPV) and ar/R (AIGR) regions did not exhibit any detectable boric acid transport activity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The study primarily uses yeast as a heterologous expression system. While effective for demonstrating transport activity, it may not fully recapitulate the complex cellular environment and regulatory mechanisms present in Arabidopsis. The paper acknowledges that the precise impact of some mutations might be influenced by factors like post-translational modifications (e.g., phosphorylation, methylation, acetylation), which were not directly investigated.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that other structural features within the aquaporin pore, beyond the NPA and ar/R constrictions, are likely involved in determining substrate specificity. Future research could focus on exploring these other regions. Additionally, investigating the role of post-translational modifications in regulating AtNIP1;2's transport activity and selectivity would be a valuable next step. Further studies could also explore the interaction of AtNIP1;2 with other cellular components or its role in different plant tissues and under various environmental conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Aquaporins (AQPs) are channel proteins involved in transporting a variety of substrates. It has been proposed that the constriction regions in the central pores of the AQP channels play a crucial role in determining transport substrates and activities of AQPs. Our previous results suggest that AtNIP1;2, a member of the AQP superfamily in Arabidopsis, facilitates aluminum transport across the plasma membrane. However, the functions of the constriction regions in AtNIP1;2-mediated transport activities are unclear. This study reports that residue substitutions of the constriction regions affect AtNIP1;2-mediated aluminum uptake, demonstrating the critical roles of the constriction regions for transport activities. Furthermore, a constriction region that partially or wholly mimics AtNIP5;1, a demonstrated boric-acid transporter, could not render the boric-acid transport activity to AtNIP1;2. Therefore, besides the constriction regions, other structural features are also involved in determining the nature of AtNIP1;2's transport activities.<b>Abbreviations</b>: AIAR: alanine-isoleucine-alanine-arginine; AIGR: alanine-isoleucine-glycine- arginine; AQP: aquaporin; Al-Mal: aluminum-malate; ar/R: aromatic/arginine; AVAR: alanine-valine-alanine-arginine; CK: control; H: helical domain; ICP-MS: inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry; LA - LE: inter-helical loops A to E; NIP: nodulin 26-like intrinsic protein; NPA: asparagine-proline-alanine; NPG: asparagine-proline- glycine; NPS: asparagine-proline-Serine; NPV: asparagine-proline-valine; ORF: open reading frame; PIP: plasma membrane intrinsic proteins; SIP: small basic intrinsic proteins; TM: transmembrane helices; WIAR: tryptophan-isoleucine-alanine-arginine; WVAR: tryptophan-valine-alanine-arginine; WVGR: tryptophan-valine-glycine- arginine.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2021roles,
  author = {Yuqi Wang and Enzong Xiao and Guorong Wu and Qing Bai and Feng Xu and Xiyue Ji and Chun’e Li and Li Li and Jiping Liu},
  title = {{The roles of selectivity filters in determining aluminum transport by AtNIP1;2}},
  booktitle = {Plant},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1080/15592324.2021.1991686},
}
Figure