Abstract
We have studied the $J/\psi \phi$ mass distribution of the process $B^+ \to J/\psi \phi K^+$ from the threshold to about 4250 MeV, by considering the contribution of the $X(4140)$ with a narrow width, together with the $X(4160)$ state. Our results show that the cusp structure at the $D_s^* \bar{D}_s^*$ threshold is tied to the molecular nature of the $X(4160)$ state.
Introduction
The discovery of "XYZ states" has significantly expanded our understanding of quantum chromodynamics (QCD) beyond the traditional quark model. These exotic hadronic states do not conform to the standard $q\bar{q}$ meson or $qqq$ baryon configurations. Among these, the $X(4140)$ resonance, first observed in $B^+ \to J/\psi \phi K^+$ decays, has remained controversial. While early measurements characterized it as a narrow state, recent high-statistics data from the LHCb collaboration suggested a much larger width ($\approx 83$ MeV) and revealed a sharp "cusp" near the $D_s^* \bar{D}_s^*$ threshold. This study investigates whether these features can be explained by the interplay between a narrow $X(4140)$ and a dynamically generated $X(4160)$ molecular state.
Theoretical Framework
To model the $B^+ \to J/\psi \phi K^+$ reaction, we employ the Chiral Unitary Approach combined with Final State Interactions (FSI). The decay is treated as a two-step process. Initially, the $B$ meson decays into a $K$ meson and a pair of charmed-strange mesons ($D_s^* \bar{D}_s^*$) or $J/\psi \phi$. The underlying quark-level mechanisms for these primary productions are illustrated in Figure 1.
Following the primary production, the intermediate mesons undergo rescattering. We specifically consider the $D_s^* \bar{D}_s^*$ interaction, which dynamically generates the $X(4160)$ resonance. This rescattering is modeled using a loop function $G$ and a transition amplitude $t$. The hadronic mechanisms, including the formation of the $X(4160)$ and its subsequent decay into $J/\psi \phi$ or $D_s^* \bar{D}_s^*$, are shown in Figure 2.
The Nature of the Cusp and $X(4160)$
A key finding of this work is the interpretation of the "cusp" observed at the $D_s^* \bar{D}_s^*$ threshold (approximately 4224 MeV). We demonstrate that this cusp is not a separate resonance but a kinematic effect arising from the analyticity of the scattering amplitude. The derivative of the loop function $G$ is discontinuous at the threshold where the production of two $D_s^*$ mesons becomes energetically possible.
Crucially, the prominence of this cusp in the $J/\psi \phi$ mass spectrum is a direct consequence of the molecular nature of the $X(4160)$. If the $X(4160)$ is a $D_s^* \bar{D}_s^*$ bound state, its proximity to the threshold naturally enhances the threshold effect, creating the observed sharp structure.
Results and Comparison with LHCb Data
By including both a narrow $X(4140)$ (width $\approx 19$ MeV) and the broader $X(4160)$ state, our model achieves an excellent fit to the LHCb experimental data for the $J/\psi \phi$ invariant mass distribution up to 4250 MeV.
The analysis suggests that the "wide" $X(4140)$ reported by LHCb may be an effective description of a more complex region. In our model, the low-mass peak is dominated by the narrow $X(4140)$, while the higher-mass region and the threshold cusp are driven by the $X(4160)$. This dual-state approach reconciles the narrow width observed in earlier experiments with the broad structures seen in recent high-precision data.
Conclusion
Our study provides strong evidence that the $X(4160)$ is a molecular state composed of $D_s^* \bar{D}_s^*$ mesons. This interpretation naturally explains the cusp structure at the $D_s^* \bar{D}_s^*$ threshold in the $B^+ \to J/\psi \phi K^+$ reaction. Furthermore, we predict a distinct peak in the $D_s^* \bar{D}_s^*$ mass distribution just above its threshold, which serves as a testable prediction for future experimental verification.
Summary updated