The Role of the Primary Visual Cortex in Perceptual Suppression of Salient Visual Stimuli

Georgios A. Keliris, Nikos K. Logothetis, Andreas S. ToliasJournal of Neuroscience 2010 · DOI

Abstract

The role of primary visual cortex (area V1) in subjective perception has intrigued students of vision for decades. Specifically, the extent to which the activity of different types of cells (monocular versus binocular) and electrophysiological signals (i.e., local field potentials versus spiking activity) reflect perception is still debated. To address these questions we recorded from area V1 of the macaque using tetrodes during the paradigm of binocular flash suppression, where incongruent images presented dichoptically compete for perceptual dominance. We found that the activity of a minority (20%) of neurons reflect the perceived visual stimulus and these cells exhibited perceptual modulations substantially weaker compared with their sensory modulation induced by congruent stimuli. Importantly, perceptual modulations were found equally often for monocular and binocular cells, demonstrating that perceptual competition in V1 involves mechanisms across both types of neurons. The power of the local field potential (LFP) also showed moderate perceptual modulations with similar percentages of sites showing significant effects across frequency bands (18-22%). The possibility remains that perception may be strongly reflected in more elaborate aspects of activity in V1 circuits (e.g., specific neuronal subtypes) or perceptual states might have a modulatory role on more intricate aspects of V1 firing patterns (e.g., synchronization), not necessarily altering the firing rates of single cells or the LFP power dramatically.

Introduction: The Debate Over V1 and Perception

In the study of vision, a long-standing debate persists: where does "seeing" actually happen? When two different images are presented to each eye (binocular rivalry), the brain suppresses one, and we perceive only one at a time. While human fMRI studies have suggested that the primary visual cortex (V1) robustly reflects this perceived image, earlier electrophysiological studies in monkeys suggested that V1 primarily signals the physical stimulus on the retina, with perceptual suppression only appearing strongly in higher-order areas like V4 or the inferior temporal (IT) cortex. This study aims to resolve this discrepancy by characterizing how different types of V1 signals and cell types respond during perceptual shifts.

Methodology: Binocular Flash Suppression and Tetrode Recording

Researchers trained rhesus macaques to perform a Binocular Flash Suppression (BFS) task. In BFS, a stimulus is shown to one eye, and then a second, different stimulus is "flashed" to the other eye. This flash invariably causes the second stimulus to dominate the monkey's perception, even though the first stimulus remains physically present.

Experimental paradigm showing the timeline of binocular flash suppression (A) and the eight stimulus conditions used to compare perceptual and physical changes (B).

Key technical aspects included:

  • Tetrode Recordings: These allowed for the isolation of individual neurons and simultaneous recording of Local Field Potentials (LFPs)—the aggregate electrical signal from local populations.
  • Physical Alternation Control: To establish a baseline, the researchers compared "perceptual" suppression (stimulus present but not seen) to "physical" alternation (stimulus actually removed).
  • Ocularity Mapping: Neurons were categorized as monocular or binocular to determine if suppression occurs specifically at the point where signals from both eyes first merge.

Key Findings: The "20% Minority" and Weak Modulation

The study revealed that only about one-fifth (20%) of visually responsive V1 neurons changed their firing rates in a way that matched the monkey's perception. The vast majority of V1 continued to signal the physical retinal input, regardless of whether the animal "saw" it.

Representative neural responses (rasters and spike rates) in V1 comparing activity during perceptual suppression and physical alternation.

Even in the neurons that reflected perception, the effect was significantly "muted." The change in firing rate during perceptual suppression was only about 27% as strong as the change seen when the stimulus was physically removed. This is reflected in the absolute "d-prime" (a measure of discriminability), which was 0.41 for perceptual shifts compared to 1.48 for physical sensory shifts.

Crucially, perceptual modulation was found equally in both monocular and binocular cells. This suggests that suppression is not a simple "gate" at the first stage of binocular convergence but involves a more complex, distributed circuit. Furthermore, the LFP showed similar moderate modulation (18–22% of sites) across various frequency bands, including the gamma range (30–90 Hz).

Discussion: A Distributed Circuit for Perception

The results support the idea that V1 is a participant in—but not the primary driver of—perceptual suppression. The relatively weak modulation suggests that V1 likely receives "top-down" feedback from higher visual areas (like V4 or MT) where the "decision" of what to perceive has already been established.

While firing rates and LFP power show only moderate changes, the authors acknowledge that perception might be encoded in more intricate ways, such as neuronal synchronization or temporal coding. Future research focusing on simultaneous recordings from V1 and higher areas could further track the real-time flow of these suppressive signals.

Summary updated

Abstract

The role of primary visual cortex (area V1) in subjective perception has intrigued students of vision for decades. Specifically, the extent to which the activity of different types of cells (monocular versus binocular) and electrophysiological signals (i.e., local field potentials versus spiking activity) reflect perception is still debated. To address these questions we recorded from area V1 of the macaque using tetrodes during the paradigm of binocular flash suppression, where incongruent images presented dichoptically compete for perceptual dominance. We found that the activity of a minority (20%) of neurons reflect the perceived visual stimulus and these cells exhibited perceptual modulations substantially weaker compared with their sensory modulation induced by congruent stimuli. Importantly, perceptual modulations were found equally often for monocular and binocular cells, demonstrating that perceptual competition in V1 involves mechanisms across both types of neurons. The power of the local field potential (LFP) also showed moderate perceptual modulations with similar percentages of sites showing significant effects across frequency bands (18-22%). The possibility remains that perception may be strongly reflected in more elaborate aspects of activity in V1 circuits (e.g., specific neuronal subtypes) or perceptual states might have a modulatory role on more intricate aspects of V1 firing patterns (e.g., synchronization), not necessarily altering the firing rates of single cells or the LFP power dramatically.
BibTeX
@article{keliris2010role,
  author = {Georgios A. Keliris and Nikos K. Logothetis and Andreas S. Tolias},
  title = {{The Role of the Primary Visual Cortex in Perceptual Suppression of Salient Visual Stimuli}},
  journal = {Journal of Neuroscience},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1523/jneurosci.0677-10.2010},
}
Figure