The role of the Hes1 crosstalk hub in Notch-Wnt interactions of the intestinal crypt

Sophie K. Kay, Heather A. Harrington, Sarah Shepherd, Keith Brennan, Trevor Dale, James M. Osborne, David J. Gavaghan, Helen M. ByrnePLOS Computational Biology 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper develops a mathematical model of the Notch and Wnt signaling pathways in intestinal crypts, revealing how their crosstalk, mediated by the Hes1 promoter, dictates cell fate decisions. The model highlights that Wnt signaling can stabilize Notch signaling, preventing oscillations and promoting a single cell fate, while Notch signaling alone allows for flexibility and potential oscillations, crucial for maintaining cell fate options.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The intestinal epithelium is a dynamic tissue where cells continuously renew and differentiate to maintain homeostasis. This process is tightly regulated by signaling pathways, particularly Notch and Wnt, which control cell proliferation and fate specification. While both pathways are known to be critical, the precise mechanisms by which they interact and coordinate cell fate decisions, especially in the context of the intestinal crypt, remain complex. Specifically, understanding how the Hes1 gene, a key downstream target of both pathways, acts as a central hub for their crosstalk and influences the transition from a flexible state to a determined cell fate is a significant challenge. This paper aims to address this by creating a detailed mathematical model to explore this intricate interplay.

Methods

The authors employ a multi-pronged approach:

  • Mathematical Modeling: They construct a detailed ordinary differential equation (ODE) model representing the biochemical reactions of the Notch and Wnt pathways and their crosstalk. This model includes 12 dependent variables and numerous parameters, capturing key molecular players and interactions.
  • Chemical Reaction Network Theory (CRNT): To analyze the complex network without relying on specific parameter values, CRNT is used. This powerful theoretical framework helps determine properties like monostability (a single stable state) or multistability (multiple stable states) based on the network's structure.
  • In Silico Simulations: The model is simulated using computational tools (Matlab) to explore the dynamics of cell pairs under various conditions, including healthy and "mutant" scenarios (e.g., APC mutations, hyperstimulated Wnt signaling).
  • Parameter Fitting: Model parameters are estimated and fitted using experimental data from literature and cell lines to ensure biological realism.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on existing experimental data from literature for parameter fitting and model validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hes1 as a Central Crosstalk Hub: The Hes1 promoter is identified as a critical point where Notch and Wnt pathways converge, significantly influencing cell fate decisions.
  • Wnt Stabilizes Notch: Direct Wnt-mediated action on the Hes1 promoter, via β-catenin, stabilizes the Notch pathway, dampening oscillations and pushing the system towards a single, determined cell fate. This is crucial for cell fate selection.
  • Notch Promotes Flexibility: When Hes1 transcription is primarily controlled by Notch signaling, the system exhibits oscillations. This "flexibility" allows cells to maintain multiple fate options until a specific cue triggers commitment.
  • Spatial Gradients Matter: The model suggests that the spatial variation of Wnt levels along the intestinal crypt axis (high at the base, low at the orifice) plays a key role in coordinating cell fate selection and the emergence of cellular heterogeneity.
  • Mutant Cells Can Invert Neighboring Fates: A Wnt-hyperstimulated mutant cell can potentially influence neighboring healthy cells to adopt a secondary, less differentiated fate, which has implications for understanding cancer development.

Key Results

  • CRNT analysis revealed that the Notch subnetwork is discordant (multistable) when Hes1 transcription is solely Notch-mediated, but becomes concordant (monostable) when Wnt-mediated regulation via β-catenin is included.
  • Time-dependent simulations of cell pairs demonstrated that increasing the proportion of Notch-mediated control of Hes1 (represented by θ2) leads to more pronounced Hes1 oscillations, especially in low Wnt conditions.
  • In healthy cell pairs, varying the Notch-Wnt control of Hes1 (θ2) showed that Wnt-dominant control leads to rapid settling into a steady state with reduced Hes1, while Notch-dominant control allows for oscillations.
  • Simulations of APC mutant cells showed that impaired destruction complex function leads to increased β-catenin and Hes1, potentially driving prolonged mitotic activity.
  • Wnt-hyperstimulated mutant cells were shown to invert the cell fate of neighboring healthy cells, leading to a healthy cell with high Hes1 and a mutant cell with low Hes1.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Homogeneous System Assumption for CRNT: CRNT analysis was performed on homogeneous systems due to computational complexity, limiting its direct application to heterogeneous cell populations.
  • Simplified Wnt Model: The Wnt submodel is intentionally simplified to focus on Hes1 crosstalk, omitting some detailed processes like Dishevelled representation.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest extending studies to larger cell populations and more realistic crypt settings, exploring the cancer stem cell hypothesis in more detail, and refining the model to include Hes1 mRNA and dimerisation, as well as a more explicit representation of Dishevelled. They also note the potential to incorporate different Axin forms.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{kay2017role,
  author = {Sophie K. Kay and Heather A. Harrington and Sarah Shepherd and Keith Brennan and Trevor Dale and James M. Osborne and David J. Gavaghan and Helen M. Byrne},
  title = {{The role of the Hes1 crosstalk hub in Notch-Wnt interactions of the intestinal crypt}},
  journal = {PLOS Computational Biology},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pcbi.1005400},
}
Figure