The Role of Semiconductor Inputs in IT Hardware Price Decline: 
Computers vs. Communications

Ana Aizcorbe, Kenneth Flamm, Anjum KhurshidSsrn 2003 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates why semiconductor prices, a key driver of IT hardware price declines, fall much faster for computers than for communications equipment. By constructing industry-specific semiconductor input price indexes, the authors demonstrate that the differing price trends of semiconductor components used in each sector are the primary reason for the divergence in output price declines, explaining nearly all of the observed gap.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For decades, economists have observed rapid price declines in high-tech goods, particularly computers, largely attributed to quality improvements and falling input costs. Semiconductor prices, being a major input, have been a focal point. However, a puzzling observation emerged: while communications equipment is also a heavy user of semiconductors and a high-tech product, its quality-adjusted prices have declined much more slowly than those of computers. Early explanations often pointed to regulatory factors, but with market deregulation, this explanation became less plausible. The paper aims to resolve this puzzle by examining the semiconductor input side, specifically whether the types of chips used and their respective price trends differ between the computer and communications industries.

Methods

The core of the paper's methodology lies in constructing industry-specific semiconductor input price indexes. This involves:

  • Data Collection: Gathering data on nominal shipments of semiconductor devices by end-use from sources like the World Semiconductor Trade Statistics (WSTS) and industry associations.
  • Price Relative Calculation: Determining the price changes for various semiconductor device classes.
  • Index Construction: Employing chained-Fisher indexes to aggregate price changes, weighting them by their importance (expenditure shares) within each end-use industry. This is a standard but robust method for constructing price indexes that account for quality changes.
  • Contribution Analysis: Decomposing the overall price change of output (computers and communications equipment) into the contribution of semiconductor inputs and other factors. This uses a cost function framework and Shepherd's lemma to isolate the impact of input price changes.

A novel aspect is the creation of these disaggregated input price indexes for specific end-use industries (computers vs. communications), which were not readily available.

Datasets

The study relies on several datasets:

  • World Semiconductor Trade Statistics (WSTS) Survey: Provides data on nominal shipments of semiconductor devices by end-use and product class.
  • Semiconductor Industry Association (SIA) Data: Used for detailed descriptions of semiconductor devices and their capabilities.
  • Dataquest-Gartner Group: Semiconductor Product Trends data.
  • Electronic Industry Outlook (EIO): For equipment production value.
  • U.S. Census Annual Survey of Manufactures: Used to translate shipment shares into variable cost shares.
  • Previous academic studies: Data and price indexes from prior research on computer and communications equipment prices (e.g., Aizcorbe, Corrado, and Doms (2000) for computers; Grimm (1996) for digital switch prices).

The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather synthesizes and analyzes existing data to construct its specialized input price indexes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Semiconductor Price Divergence is Key: The most significant finding is that the price declines for semiconductor chips used in computers are substantially faster than those used in communications equipment. This directly addresses the puzzle.
  • Composition Matters: The types of semiconductor chips consumed by each industry are vastly different. Computers heavily rely on "leading-edge" MOS devices (MPUs, memory) that experience rapid price drops, while communications equipment uses a more diverse mix, including older, more mature technologies with slower price declines.
  • Input Prices Drive Output Prices: The differential price trends in semiconductor inputs are not just a minor factor; they are large enough to potentially explain all of the observed differences in the price declines of computers versus communications equipment.
  • Quality Adjustment is Crucial: The paper underscores the importance of quality-adjusted price indexes for understanding IT price dynamics. Without them, the true price performance improvements would be masked.

Key Results

  • Input Price Declines: Over the 1992-1999 period, semiconductor input prices for the computer industry fell at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of approximately 32%, while those for the communications equipment industry fell at a CAGR of about 15%.
  • Contribution to Output Price Change: In 1998, semiconductor price declines accounted for roughly 40-59% of the price decline in computers, 27-36% in consumer audio, and a smaller, but still significant, portion in communications equipment.
  • Explaining the Gap: The study concludes that differences in semiconductor input price changes, combined with differences in how intensely each industry uses semiconductors, can explain almost all of the observed difference in price decline rates between computers and communications equipment in 1998. Specifically, the higher semiconductor contribution in computers accounted for a substantial portion of the faster price decline compared to LAN equipment.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Quality: The authors acknowledge that data quality for semiconductor input expenditures across all sectors, and quality-adjusted price indexes for sectors beyond semiconductors, computers, and a fraction of communications equipment, remains marginal. This is a significant caveat.
  • Other Inputs: The analysis focuses heavily on semiconductors. While the framework accounts for "all other factors," the paper notes that differences in the importance and price trends of other inputs (like disk drives and displays for computers) and industry-specific innovation could also play a role.
  • Analog Device Measurement: The paper highlights challenges in accurately measuring price changes for analog devices, which are important for communications equipment, and discusses the construction of a hybrid index to address this.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that further research is needed to improve data quality for semiconductor input expenditures and quality-adjusted price indexes in less-covered sectors. A deeper dive into the role of other inputs and industry-specific innovation would also be valuable.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{aizcorbe2003role,
  author = {Ana Aizcorbe and Kenneth Flamm and Anjum Khurshid},
  title = {{The Role of Semiconductor Inputs in IT Hardware Price Decline: \&\#x0D;Computers vs. Communications}},
  year = {2003},
  doi = {10.2139/ssrn.333601},
  howpublished = {Ssrn},
}

Loading related content...

Figure