The role of radial head morphology in proximal radioulnar joint congruency during forearm rotation

Hailong Zhang, Guang Yang, Yi LuJournal of Experimental Orthopaedics 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the radial head's elliptical shape plays a crucial role in the proximal radioulnar joint's (PRUJ) stability during forearm rotation. The PRUJ exhibits its highest congruency and stability at maximal pronation and supination, with a significant decrease in congruency at the neutral position, suggesting implications for radial head prosthesis design and placement.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The proximal radioulnar joint (PRUJ) is essential for forearm rotation, and its congruency (how well the joint surfaces fit together) directly impacts elbow function. While the importance of PRUJ congruency is recognized, the precise morphological features of the radial head and their specific role in maintaining this congruency across different forearm rotation positions have not been fully elucidated. Previous assumptions of a circular radial head have been challenged, with emerging evidence suggesting an elliptical shape. Understanding this morphology is critical for accurately reconstructing the radial head, particularly when using prostheses, to avoid instability and ensure proper joint function. This paper aims to quantitatively characterize the radial head's morphology and its impact on PRUJ congruency during pronation and supination.

Methods

The researchers utilized a sophisticated 3D modeling approach based on computed tomography (CT) scans. Thirty patients underwent CT scans of their elbows, from which 3D models of the proximal radius and ulna were reconstructed. A key methodological innovation was the establishment of a local coordinate system to accurately orient and analyze the radial head's geometry. This involved defining a central axis of forearm rotation and then projecting the radial head's contours onto a standard cross-section.

The study then focused on calculating the radius of curvature of specific points on the radial head that come into contact with the radial notch (RN) of the ulna at different forearm positions: maximal pronation, neutral, and maximal supination. These points were identified and labeled as the pronation point (PP), neutral point (NP), and supination point (SP), respectively. A best-fit ellipse was generated for the radial head, and a best-fit circle was used to describe the morphology of the RN. Statistical analysis, including one-way ANOVA and Tukey's post-hoc tests, was employed to compare the radii of curvature and assess the significance of the findings.

Datasets

The study used CT scan data from 30 patients with distal humerus fractures. These scans served as the basis for creating the 3D models. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing CT imaging data was utilized for analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Elliptical Radial Head is Key: The radial head is not perfectly circular but rather elliptical, and this shape is fundamental to how it interacts with the ulna during rotation.
  • Rotation Dictates Congruency: The degree of "fit" or congruency within the PRUJ changes significantly with forearm rotation.
  • Maximal Rotation = Maximal Stability: The PRUJ is most congruent and stable at the extremes of forearm rotation (maximal pronation and supination).
  • Neutral Position is a Weak Link: The neutral forearm position is associated with the least congruency in the PRUJ, potentially making it more vulnerable.
  • Morphology Guides Prosthetics: The specific orientation and shape of the radial head's ellipse are critical for accurate placement of radial head prostheses to ensure optimal joint function and stability.

Key Results

  • The radial head was successfully modeled as an ellipse with semi-major and semi-minor axes of 23.84 ± 1.73 mm and 20.69 ± 1.43 mm, respectively.
  • The radii of curvature for the contact points of the radial head with the radial notch were:
  • Pronation Point (PP): 14.72 ± 1.51 mm
    • Neutral Point (NP): 9.74 ± 1.49 mm
    • Supination Point (SP): 14.58 ± 1.70 mm
  • The radius of curvature at the neutral position (NP) was significantly smaller than at maximal pronation (PP) and supination (SP) (p < 0.001).
  • The congruency of the PRUJ was found to be best at maximal pronation and supination, with the neutral position showing the least congruency.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Average "Safe Zone": The study used an average value for the "safe zone" of the radial head's contact with the RN. Individual variations in this zone could influence the accuracy of matching points. Future work could involve determining case-specific safe zones.
  • Cartilage Not Considered: The analysis was based on bone architecture from CT scans, and the role of articular cartilage in PRUJ congruency was not evaluated. Further studies incorporating cartilage would be beneficial.
  • Ligaments and Tendons Ignored: The influence of ligaments and tendons on forearm rotation and PRUJ stability was not investigated. Future research could explore these soft tissue contributions.

Despite these limitations, the study's findings on the elliptical morphology of the radial head and its impact on PRUJ congruency provide valuable insights for clinical practice, particularly in the design and surgical implantation of radial head prostheses.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Purpose Congruency of the proximal radioulnar joint (PRUJ) is important in the rotation of the forearm while any compromise would significantly impair the elbow function. The purpose of this study is to determine the morphological features of the radial head and investigate its role in the congruency of the PRUJ during forearm rotation. The hypothesis is that the PRUJ is more congruent in the maximal pronation and supination positions than in the neutral position. Methods Thirty sets of computed tomography images of the elbow were acquired, and a three‐dimensional model of the proximal radius and ulna was generated. The radius of curvature of the radial head and the radial head at the maximal pronation, neutral positions and maximal supination were calculated and compared with a one‐way analysis of variance. Results The point on the radial head contacting the middle point of radial head at the maximal pronation and supination was located at the ends of the semi‐major axis of the ellipse, while it was located at one end of the semi‐minor axis at neutral position. The radii of curvature of the pronation, neutral and supination points of the radial head were 14.72 ± 1.51, 9.74 ± 1.49 and 14.58 ± 1.70 mm, respectively. The value of the neutral point was significantly smaller than that of the pronation and supination points. Conclusions This study quantitatively evaluated the morphology of the radial head and suggested that the best congruency of the PRUJ was achieved at maximal pronation and supination, while the neutral position was associated with the least congruency. Level of Evidence Basic Science Study.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2024role,
  author = {Hailong Zhang and Guang Yang and Yi Lu},
  title = {{The role of radial head morphology in proximal radioulnar joint congruency during forearm rotation}},
  journal = {Journal of Experimental Orthopaedics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1002/jeo2.70059},
}
Figure