The role of positron polarization for the inital $250$ GeV stage of the International Linear Collider

H. Fujii, Robert Karl, G. Wilson, Y. Gao, Jenny List, Hitoshi Murayama, Hyung Do Kim, Shinya Kanemura, Maxim Perelstein, Sabine Riemann, T. Tanabe, Michael E. Peskin, Christophe Grojean, Jaehoon Yu, F. Simon, James E. Brau, Junping Tian, Jürgen Reuter, Moritz Habermehl, Tim Barklow, Mihoko M. Nojiri, M. Berggren, James D. Wells, R. Pöschl, Gudrid Moortgat‐PickarXiv 2018 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The International Linear Collider (ILC) is now proposed with a staged machine design, with the first stage at $\sqrt{s}=$~250 GeV and an integrated luminosity goal of 2~ab$^{-1}$. One of the questions for the machine design is the importance of positron polarization. In this report, we review the impact of positron polarization on the physics goals of the $250$ GeV stage of the ILC and demonstrate that positron polarization has distinct advantages.

Introduction

The International Linear Collider (ILC) represents the next frontier in precision particle physics, designed to scrutinize the Higgs boson and explore the landscape of physics beyond the Standard Model (BSM). To manage the technical and financial scale of the project, the ILC has transitioned to a staged implementation, beginning at a center-of-mass energy of 250 GeV. While the polarization of the electron beam ($P_{e^-}$) is a standard feature, the inclusion of positron polarization ($P_{e^+}$) introduces additional technical complexity. This paper evaluates whether a 30% positron polarization is a necessary requirement for the 250 GeV stage, concluding that it is essential for maximizing discovery potential and ensuring the robustness of experimental results.

Methodology

The analysis presented here is based on a meta-analysis of Monte Carlo studies tailored for the ILC 250 GeV "H-20" running scenario. The researchers utilized several theoretical and statistical frameworks:

  • Effective Field Theory (EFT): This framework was employed to model potential deviations in Higgs and triple gauge boson couplings in a model-independent manner.
  • Global Fit Analysis: The studies accounted for "nuisance parameters," such as uncertainties in luminosity and beam polarization, to determine their impact on the final precision of physics observables.
  • Scenario Comparison: The core of the study compares a scenario with $P_{e^+} = 30\%$ against a scenario with $P_{e^+} = 0$, assuming a total integrated luminosity of 2 ab$^{-1}$.

Systematic Control and Redundancy

The primary advantage of positron polarization lies in the redundancy it provides. By polarizing both beams, the ILC can access four distinct helicity combinations: ($e^-_L e^+_R, e^-_R e^+_L, e^-_L e^+_L, e^-_R e^+_R$). In contrast, an unpolarized positron beam only allows for two combinations.

This redundancy is the only method available to independently constrain systematic uncertainties in-situ. Without the ability to flip the spin of both beams, uncertainties regarding the actual degree of polarization and luminosity can propagate into the physics results. The authors cite the SLD experiment at the Stanford Linear Collider as a historical precedent; it demonstrated that even a "nominally unpolarized" beam can possess small, unknown biases. Having a polarized source and dedicated polarimeters allows researchers to treat polarization as a controlled, measurable variable rather than an unknown source of error.

Impact on Higgs Physics

The Higgs-strahlung process ($e^+e^- \to ZH$) is the primary production channel at 250 GeV. Positron polarization significantly enhances the statistical power and precision of Higgs measurements:

  • Event Yield: Including 30% positron polarization increases the total Higgs boson yield by approximately 20%, moving from roughly 420,000 to 500,000 events over the lifetime of the 250 GeV stage.
  • Coupling Precision: Precision in measuring Higgs couplings, such as $g(hbb)$ and $g(h\tau\tau)$, improves by about 6%. This improvement stems from better signal-to-background ratios and the ability to suppress specific Standard Model backgrounds by selecting favorable chirality states.

Sensitivity to New Physics

Positron polarization acts as a "filter" for new physics. Since the weak interaction is inherently chiral, the ability to manipulate the spin of both matter and antimatter allows for the isolation of BSM signals:

  • Dark Matter Searches: In searches for Weakly Interacting Massive Particles (WIMPs) using the "mono-photon" signature, positron polarization provides a sensitivity boost equivalent to a 25% increase in total running time.
  • Contact Interactions: For Bhabha scattering and other four-fermion processes, the reach for probing new energy scales (contact interactions) increases by a factor of 1.3.
  • CP Violation: Certain complex parameters related to CP violation—the fundamental difference between matter and antimatter—require both beams to be polarized to be measured effectively.

Conclusion

While the ILC could operate with only electron polarization, the exclusion of positron polarization would significantly limit the machine's scientific reach. The 30% polarization of positrons provides a critical layer of systematic control, increases the statistical yield of the Higgs sector, and enhances the sensitivity to BSM phenomena. In the pursuit of precision physics, the redundancy provided by polarized positrons is not merely an upgrade but a fundamental requirement for a robust discovery program.

Summary updated

Abstract

The International Linear Collider is now proposed with a staged machine design, with the first stage at $\sqrt{s}=$~250 GeV and an integrated luminosity goal of 2~ab$^{-1}$. One of the questions for the machine design is the importance of positron polarization. In this report, we review the impact of positron polarization on the physics goals of the $250$ GeV stage of the ILC and demonstrate that positron polarization has distinct advantages.
BibTeX
@misc{fujii2018role,
  author = {H. Fujii and Robert Karl and G. Wilson and Y. Gao and Jenny List and Hitoshi Murayama and Hyung Do Kim and Shinya Kanemura and Maxim Perelstein and Sabine Riemann and T. Tanabe and Michael E. Peskin and Christophe Grojean and Jaehoon Yu and F. Simon and James E. Brau and Junping Tian and Jürgen Reuter and Moritz Habermehl and Tim Barklow and Mihoko M. Nojiri and M. Berggren and James D. Wells and R. Pöschl and Gudrid Moortgat‐Pick},
  title = {{The role of positron polarization for the inital $250$ GeV stage of the International Linear Collider}},
  year = {2018},
  eprint = {1801.02840},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1801.02840},
}
Figure