Abstract
Our study underscores the vital role that healthcare professionals play in educating, advocating for, and promoting breastfeeding behaviors. This further highlights the pressing need for sustained efforts to support breastfeeding initiatives and address disparities in maternal and child health, particularly in the context of the challenges presented by the COVID-19 pandemic.
Introduction: The Impact of Pandemic Disruptions
Breastfeeding is a cornerstone of maternal and infant health, yet it is highly sensitive to the quality of clinical and social support. During the COVID-19 pandemic, healthcare systems underwent radical shifts: visitor restrictions barred doulas from delivery rooms, bedside time for nurses was slashed, and many lactation support groups moved to less-accessible virtual formats.
This study sought to quantify the specific "value-add" of nurses, midwives, and doulas (NMDs) on breastfeeding initiation and duration, and to understand how the pandemic altered the provision of this education across different demographic groups. While previous studies noted a general decline in breastfeeding support during 2020, this research uses a massive, multi-year dataset to tease out the nuances of who provided education and how it affected the long-term success of breastfeeding.
Methods and Datasets
The researchers employed a cross-sectional design using secondary data analysis from the Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System (PRAMS). Managed by the CDC, PRAMS is considered the "gold standard" for maternal health data in the U.S., covering approximately 83% of all U.S. births.
The study analyzed data from 46 U.S. states and New York City across Phase 7 (2012–2015) and Phase 8 (2016–2020), totaling 193,068 respondents. To analyze the data, the authors used:
- Multivariable Logistic Regression: To calculate adjusted odds ratios (aORs) for breastfeeding initiation.
- Cox Proportional Hazard Models: To analyze the "hazard" (risk) of stopping breastfeeding over time.
- Sensitivity Analysis: Including data imputation for participants with missing demographic information.
Key Insights: The "NMD Effect" and the Pandemic Paradox
The most striking finding is the "NMD Effect": receiving guidance from a nurse, midwife, or doula is a massive predictor of success. Mothers who received this support were 1.99 times more likely to breastfeed or pump than those without it.
However, the pandemic created a significant barrier. There was a statistically significant drop in the likelihood of receiving breastfeeding education during 2020 (aOR = 0.92), confirming that hospital efficiency measures and visitor restrictions directly impacted preventative care delivery.
Interestingly, a "Stay-at-Home Paradox" emerged. While mothers were less likely to start breastfeeding during the pandemic, those who did were actually less likely to stop (HR = 0.94). This suggests that stay-at-home orders and remote work may have removed the common barrier of returning to a workplace that lacks pumping support.
Key Results and Demographic Disparities
The data reveals clear benefits of professional support: 89.7% of mothers who received NMD education initiated breastfeeding, compared to only 81.1% of those who did not.
The study also highlights persistent systemic inequities:
- Race/Ethnicity: Black birthing individuals reported the lowest breastfeeding rates and the highest hazard of stopping (HR = 1.13) compared to White counterparts. Conversely, Non-Hispanic Asian participants reported the highest rates (over 93%) both before and during the pandemic.
- Socioeconomic Status: Higher education and income were strongly protective. College-educated participants had a 50% lower hazard of stopping compared to those without a high school diploma.
Limitations and Future Directions
While the PRAMS dataset is robust, the study relies on maternal recall 2–6 months postpartum, which may introduce bias. Additionally, the grouping of nurses, midwives, and doulas into a single category prevents a granular analysis of their unique contributions—particularly doulas, who provide continuous non-clinical support.
Future research should disentangle these roles and investigate the efficacy of virtual versus in-person lactation support to better prepare healthcare systems for future disruptions. Furthermore, as PRAMS only surveys live births, the lactation support needs of those experiencing fetal loss remain an important area for future study.
Summary updated