The Role of Multiple Marks in Epigenetic Silencing and the Emergence of a Stable Bivalent Chromatin State

Swagatam Mukhopadhyay, Anirvan M. SenguptaPLOS Computational Biology 2013 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a minimal mathematical model of epigenetic silencing in yeast, revealing that multiple histone marks (specifically H4K16 acetylation and H3K79 methylation) are crucial for robust silencing. The model predicts a novel "bivalent" chromatin state, characterized by both active and silencing marks, which emerges under specific perturbations and leads to patchy silencing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Epigenetic silencing, the process by which genes are stably turned off without altering the underlying DNA sequence, is fundamental to cellular function and development. In budding yeast, the Silent Information Regulator (SIR) complex plays a key role in establishing these silenced regions, particularly at telomeres and mating-type loci. While it's known that various histone modifications (like acetylation and methylation) are involved, the precise interplay of these marks and how they contribute to the bistability (having distinct active and silenced states) and robustness of epigenetic silencing remains incompletely understood. Specifically, the paper aims to elucidate the role of multiple histone marks in this complex system and to explain how different perturbations can lead to varied outcomes, including the emergence of novel chromatin states.

Methods

The authors employ a minimal mathematical modeling approach. Instead of building a comprehensive network model with numerous parameters, they focus on a simplified system that captures the essential molecular interactions known to be involved in yeast silencing. This includes key players like the SIR complex, H4K16 acetylation (mediated by Sas2), and H3K79 methylation (mediated by Dot1). The model uses a lattice-based approach to simulate nucleosomes along a chromosome, allowing for local interactions and the study of spreading phenomena. They analyze the phase space of the model, which represents all possible stable states of the system under different parameter combinations, to identify distinct epigenetic fates. A key aspect of their model is the incorporation of a "titration effect" for Sir proteins, reflecting their limited supply, which leads to self-adjustment of binding rates and influences the system's behavior under perturbations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical modeling and simulations, not experimental datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergy of Multiple Marks: The model strongly suggests that the combination of H4K16 acetylation and H3K79 methylation is essential for the robustness of epigenetic silencing, not just the presence of silencing.
  • Emergence of a Bivalent State: A significant finding is the prediction of a "bivalent" chromatin state, where a single nucleosome or region exhibits both active (acetylation/methylation) and silencing (SIR complex binding) marks simultaneously. This state is not simply an intermediate but a distinct stable outcome.
  • Patchy Silencing: The bivalent state is linked to "patchy silencing," where silenced and active regions are interspersed in a less organized manner than in the typical silenced state.
  • Titration Effect's Counter-Intuitive Outcomes: The limited supply of Sir proteins (titration effect) can lead to unexpected responses to perturbations, influencing the spread and stability of silencing.
  • Dot1's Pivotal Role: The model provides a framework to reconcile seemingly contradictory experimental observations regarding the role of Dot1, suggesting its critical involvement in establishing heritable silenced domains, even if other marks can maintain some level of silencing.
  • Sir Occupancy as a Better Reporter: The authors argue that measuring Sir occupancy, rather than transcriptional activity, is a more sensitive indicator of the effects of perturbations like Dot1 and Sir2 inhibition.

Key Results

  • The model predicts four distinct stable epigenetic fates: silenced, active, intermediate, and bivalent.
  • Inhibition of Sir2 activity (a key deacetylase) pushes the system towards the bivalent state, leading to less defined silencing boundaries and patchy silencing.
  • Dot1 inhibition leads to a shift from a silenced-active bistable region to a silenced-intermediate bistable region, compromising the establishment of well-defined silenced domains.
  • Overexpression of Dot1 pushes the system towards the bivalent state, resulting in long-lived, patchy silencing domains that may be heritable.
  • Sas2 inhibition, unlike Dot1 inhibition, is predicted to eliminate the stability of silenced domains, highlighting distinct roles for acetylation and methylation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Minimal Model Simplification: The authors acknowledge that their model is minimal and that additional interactions or components could exist. However, they argue that the core conclusions are robust as long as the included interactions are retained.
  • Parameter Values: The precise biophysical parameters for the model are unknown, meaning that quantitative predictions of correlation lengths or transition points are relative trends rather than absolute values.
  • Experimental Validation: The authors suggest that future experimental work should focus on direct measurement of Sir occupancy at single-cell resolution under various perturbations (Dot1, Sas2, Sir2 enzymatic activity) to test their predictions, particularly regarding the bivalent state and Sir titration effects. They are also investigating multiple perturbations experimentally.
  • Broader Applicability: The methodology is proposed to be applicable to other epigenetic silencing systems, such as Polycomb silencing in higher eukaryotes.

Summary updated

Abstract

We introduce and analyze a minimal model of epigenetic silencing in budding yeast, built upon known biomolecular interactions in the system. Doing so, we identify the epigenetic marks essential for the bistability of epigenetic states. The model explicitly incorporates two key chromatin marks, namely H4K16 acetylation and H3K79 methylation, and explores whether the presence of multiple marks lead to a qualitatively different systems behavior. We find that having both modifications is important for the robustness of epigenetic silencing. Besides the silenced and transcriptionally active fate of chromatin, our model leads to a novel state with bivalent (i.e., both active and silencing) marks under certain perturbations (knock-out mutations, inhibition or enhancement of enzymatic activity). The bivalent state appears under several perturbations and is shown to result in patchy silencing. We also show that the titration effect, owing to a limited supply of silencing proteins, can result in counter-intuitive responses. The design principles of the silencing system is systematically investigated and disparate experimental observations are assessed within a single theoretical framework. Specifically, we discuss the behavior of Sir protein recruitment, spreading and stability of silenced regions in commonly-studied mutants (e.g., sas2, dot1) illuminating the controversial role of Dot1 in the systems biology of yeast silencing.
BibTeX
@article{mukhopadhyay2013role,
  author = {Swagatam Mukhopadhyay and Anirvan M. Sengupta},
  title = {{The Role of Multiple Marks in Epigenetic Silencing and the Emergence of a Stable Bivalent Chromatin State}},
  journal = {PLOS Computational Biology},
  year = {2013},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=iewOCas5JX},
}
Figure