The Role of Logistics in Practical Levelized Cost of Energy Reduction Implementation and Government Sponsored Cost Reduction Studies: Day and Night in Offshore Wind Operations and Maintenance Logistics

Thomas T. Poulsen, Charlotte Bay Hasager, Christian S. JensenEnergies 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper highlights that logistics constitute a significant portion (at least 17%) of operational expenditure (OpEx) in offshore wind farms, with OpEx itself showing a massive variance (factor of 9.5) across studies. It argues that government-sponsored cost reduction studies are often too theoretical for practical implementation due to cultural divides between shore-based planners and offshore workers, and proposes a business case for extending operations to 24/7 to achieve tangible savings.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The authors tackle the challenge of implementing cost reduction strategies in the offshore wind industry, particularly focusing on operational expenditure (OpEx). While government-sponsored studies aim to lower the Levelized Cost of Energy (LCoE) for offshore wind, the paper argues these studies are often too abstract and disconnected from the realities faced by industry practitioners. A key problem is the significant variability in OpEx estimations across different studies, making it difficult to compare and implement findings. Furthermore, there's a perceived cultural disconnect between the individuals who develop these cost-reduction strategies (often shore-based office personnel) and those who must execute them in the harsh offshore environment. The paper seeks to bridge this gap by analyzing practical implementation challenges and proposing concrete solutions.

Methods

The research employs a mixed-methods approach, combining a comprehensive analysis of existing literature with a practical case study.

  • Literature Analysis: The authors analyzed eleven government-sponsored LCoE cost-reduction studies and reports. This involved comparing their methodologies, assumptions, and definitions, particularly concerning OpEx and its components.
  • Case Study: A 20-month industry-wide initiative in Denmark, facilitated by Offshoreenergy.dk (OE), served as the core of the practical research. This initiative involved industry practitioners working to develop implementable cost-out initiatives. The paper focuses on a specific business case developed within this initiative: extending operations from daytime to 24/7.
  • Business Case Development: The research team actively participated in the OE initiative, contributing to the development of business cases for cost reduction. This involved interviews, focus groups, and action research to identify, prioritize, and detail potential savings.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The research relies on analysis of existing studies and data generated through practitioner collaboration.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Logistics is a Major Cost Driver: Logistics are not a minor detail; they represent a substantial portion of offshore wind operational costs, making them a critical area for cost reduction efforts.
  • OpEx Variance is a Huge Hurdle: The massive variation in OpEx estimates across studies (factor of 9.5) highlights a fundamental lack of standardization and makes it difficult to establish reliable benchmarks or predict costs accurately.
  • The "Theory vs. Practice" Divide: A significant cultural and experiential gap exists between shore-based planners who create theoretical cost-reduction models and the offshore personnel who must implement them in challenging conditions. This disconnect hinders practical application.
  • 24/7 Operations as a Tangible Solution: Extending working hours to include night shifts (24/7 operations) presents a practical, implementable strategy for achieving cost savings, potentially reducing LCoE by around 1%.
  • Government Studies are Policy Tools, Not Implementation Guides: While valuable for setting strategic direction and driving policy, government-sponsored LCoE studies often lack the granular detail and practical focus needed for direct implementation by industry.

Key Results

  • Logistics Share of OpEx: Logistics account for at least 17% of annual operational expenditure (OpEx) for offshore wind farms. This share can range up to 32% depending on how costs are measured.
  • OpEx Variance: Annual operational expenditure (OpEx) can vary by a factor of 9.5 across different studies.
  • OpEx Share of LCoE: The share of OpEx in the total Levelized Cost of Energy (LCoE) can range from 13% to 57% over the project lifecycle, largely due to the variance within OpEx itself.
  • 24/7 Business Case Savings: Extending working hours to 24/7 operations can yield savings of approximately EUR 1.8 million per year for a 400 MW near-shore offshore wind farm, translating to a reduction of just over 1% in LCoE.
  • Cultural Barriers: The research identified distinct stakeholder groups with differing objectives, highlighting the challenge of bridging the gap between policy-level planning and on-site implementation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study acknowledges that the LCoE definitions and assumptions used in the analyzed studies are inconsistent, making direct comparisons challenging.
  • The research on logistics costs is based on a "logistics base case" derived from one detailed study, which may not fully capture all nuances.
  • The 24/7 business case was modeled for a near-shore, land-based O&M setup, and savings might differ for far-offshore or sea-based setups.
  • The study did not consider logistics for floating wind turbines.
  • Future Work:
    • Further research is needed to devise solutions for applying the assumptions of cost studies down to a line-item cost level.
  • More in-depth study is required on the impact of key structural dimensions on offshore O&M logistics strategy.
  • Further research should investigate the cultural gap between shore-based and maritime personnel and its impact on cost savings realization.
  • The methodology and processes for logistics cost reduction and logistics innovation need further research, as they are distinct paths to cost reduction.
  • The authors suggest the development of standardized methodologies for cost modeling, potentially aligning with systems like the Strategic Energy Technologies Information System.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper reveals that logistics make up at least 17% of annual operational expenditure costs for offshore wind farms. Annual operational expenditure is found to vary by a factor of 9.5, making its share of levelized cost of energy for offshore wind range from 13% to 57%. These are key findings of a 20-month research project targeting cost reduction initiatives for offshore wind systems. The findings reveal that cost-out measures are difficult to implement due to cultural differences. Implementation efforts are rendered by personnel located offshore in a harsh sea environment which is in stark contrast to the shore-based office personnel who develop studies directing cost reduction efforts. This paper details the company motivation to join industry-wide cost reduction initiatives. A business case for offshore wind operations and maintenance logistics yielding 1% savings in levelized cost of energy is included on how to expand working hours from daytime to also work at night.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{poulsen2017role,
  author = {Thomas T. Poulsen and Charlotte Bay Hasager and Christian S. Jensen},
  title = {{The Role of Logistics in Practical Levelized Cost of Energy Reduction Implementation and Government Sponsored Cost Reduction Studies: Day and Night in Offshore Wind Operations and Maintenance Logistics}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/en10040464},
}
Figure