The role of learner engagement with corrective feedback in EFL/ESL classrooms

Hao Liu, Mengya FengFrontiers in Psychology 2023 · DOI

This review article, published in Frontiers in Psychology, explores the "missing link" in language acquisition: how students actually interact with the corrections they receive. While decades of research have focused on which teacher strategies (like "recasts" or "explicit correction") work best, this paper argues that the secret sauce isn't the feedback itself, but the learner’s engagement with it. By synthesizing recent theoretical and empirical work, the authors demonstrate that for corrective feedback (CF) to actually stick, students must be cognitively, affectively, and behaviorally "tuned in."

TL;DR

Corrective feedback in the classroom is useless if the student is a passive recipient; the paper argues that learner engagement is the essential mediator for language acquisition. It highlights that engagement is a multidimensional, dynamic process, and suggests that teachers must move beyond simply providing "good" feedback to actively training students on how to use it.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the world of Second Language Acquisition (SLA), Corrective Feedback (CF)—the information a learner receives about the success or failure of a language task—is a cornerstone of teaching. However, researchers have long noticed a frustrating inconsistency: the same feedback strategy can lead to a breakthrough for one student and be completely ignored by another.

The authors address the gap between input (the teacher's correction) and intake (the student's actual learning). They argue that the field has historically over-emphasized the type of feedback while neglecting the learner's internal state. The problem is that CF is often treated as a one-way transmission rather than a "long-term dialogic process."

Methods

As a Mini Review, this paper does not present new experimental data. Instead, it employs a qualitative synthesis of existing literature. The authors:

  1. Conceptualize Engagement: They adopt a multidimensional framework, breaking engagement down into three facets: Cognitive (mental effort and noticing), Affective (emotional responses), and Behavioral (the actual actions taken, like revising a text).
  2. Theoretical Integration: They lean heavily on Rod Ellis’s (2010) componential framework, which posits that learners act as "active agents" who filter feedback through their own beliefs and goals.
  3. Empirical Review: They analyze recent case studies and questionnaires (e.g., Han & Hyland, 2015; Zheng & Yu, 2018) to see how these theoretical dimensions play out in real EFL (English as a Foreign Language) classrooms.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. As a review article, it synthesizes findings from various external studies rather than utilizing a primary dataset. It references specific instruments used in other research, such as the Responsive Pedagogy Questionnaire.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Active Agent" Filter: Learners aren't sponges; they are filters. They choose—consciously or unconsciously—what feedback to heed based on their proficiency, beliefs, and even their current mood.
  • The Proficiency Paradox: Research by Zheng and Yu (2018) suggests that lower-proficiency students often experience an "imbalance" in engagement. They might want to improve (behavioral engagement) but lack the mental "bandwidth" to process complex corrections (cognitive engagement), leading to surface-level processing.
  • Emotions are Gatekeepers: Affective engagement (feelings of contentment vs. dissatisfaction) mediates how a student perceives feedback. If a student feels discouraged by a correction, their cognitive engagement may shut down entirely.
  • Feedback as "Work" for the Student: The authors echo Dylan Wiliam’s famous sentiment: "Feedback should be more work for the recipient than the donor." If the teacher does all the heavy lifting of correcting, the student’s behavioral engagement remains low.

Key Results

The review concludes that learner engagement is indispensable for CF effectiveness. Key qualitative findings include:

  • Self-Efficacy Matters: Students with higher perceived self-efficacy are significantly more likely to engage deeply with teacher feedback.
  • Contextual Mediation: Engagement is not a fixed trait; it is a "dynamic construct" that fluctuates based on the classroom atmosphere, the teacher-student relationship, and even the specific task at hand.
  • Strategy Training is Essential: The authors find that students often don't know how to engage with feedback. Simply providing corrections isn't enough; teachers must provide "specific strategy training" to help students learn how to process and act on that information.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that research into the role of engagement in CF is still in its "infancy." * Lack of Granularity: There is still a lack of detailed theoretical descriptions regarding the exact mechanisms of how engagement leads to long-term L2 development. * Scale: Many of the empirical studies cited are small-scale or qualitative, making broad generalizations difficult. * Future Direction: The authors call for more research using a "dynamic perspective" to track how engagement changes over time. They also urge a shift in pedagogy: teachers should focus on fostering "agenetic engagement"—empowering students to take an active, self-directed role in the feedback loop.

Summary updated

Abstract

As corrective feedback (CF) is conducive to students' second language (L2) development, a considerable number of studies have investigated the effects of different types of CF strategies on EFL/ESL learning achievement. However, the role of learner engagement has been largely neglected in the field of CF research. The present study aims to describe the role of learner engagement with CF in EFL/ESL classrooms by reviewing theoretical and empirical evidence. The findings reveal that learner engagement is indispensable for CF to be effective, and providing strategies for working with CF is essential to guide EFL/ESL learners in their learning process. The implications for teacher CF practice and learner engagement training are also discussed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2023role,
  author = {Hao Liu and Mengya Feng},
  title = {{The role of learner engagement with corrective feedback in EFL/ESL classrooms}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1118467},
}
Figure