The Role of “Hierarchical and Classified Prevention and Control Measures (HCPC)” Strategy for SARS-CoV-2 Delta Variant in Guangzhou: A Modeling Study

Yu Ma, Hui Wang, Yong Huang, Chun Chen, Shihao Liang, Mengmeng Ma, Xinjun He, Kangning Cai, Zengtao Jiao, Liyi Chen, Bowei Zhu, Ke Li, Chaojun Xie, Lei Luo, Zhoubin ZhangJournal of Epidemiology and Global Health 2023 · DOI

Abstract

It may be concluded that timely and more precise interventions including mass testing and graded community management are effective measures for Delta variant containment in China.

Introduction

The emergence of the SARS-CoV-2 Delta variant in 2021 presented a significant challenge to global public health due to its heightened transmissibility and shorter incubation period. In mid-2021, Guangzhou, China, experienced the country's first major local Delta cluster. Rather than implementing a traditional, citywide lockdown, authorities introduced the "Hierarchical and Classified Prevention and Control (HCPC)" strategy. This approach utilized tiered interventions, such as mass testing and movement restrictions, tailored to specific community risk levels. This study quantifies the effectiveness of this precision strategy, evaluating its impact on containment, the importance of timing, and its economic efficiency compared to broader lockdown measures.

Methodology: The SEPIR Model

To evaluate the outbreak, researchers developed a modified SEPIR model, an extension of the standard SEIR framework. The critical addition is the Pre-symptomatic (P) state, which accounts for individuals who are infectious before developing symptoms—a hallmark of the Delta variant.

The SEPIR model structure and disease progression timeline.

The model utilizes Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) simulations to estimate transmission rates ($\beta$) across four policy phases. Key parameters, such as an incubation period of 4.4 days and a pre-symptomatic infectious period of 2.3 days, were derived from field research reports of the 153 confirmed cases provided by the Guangzhou CDC and existing literature.

Key Results and Policy Impact

The HCPC strategy proved highly effective in curbing the outbreak. The effective reproduction number ($R_t$) plummeted from 3.78 at the onset to 0.50 by the final phase, successfully halting community transmission.

Observed, fitted, and predicted onset cases in Guangzhou with key HCPC intervention dates.

The Critical Importance of Timing

Simulation results highlight a non-linear relationship between the timing of interventions and the scale of the outbreak. A delay of just 3 days in implementing the HCPC measures would have led to an increase in total cases ranging from 166% to 813%. Without any non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs), the model predicts the virus would have infected approximately 7.39 million people by mid-July.

Precision vs. Economic Cost

A major advantage of the HCPC strategy is its economic efficiency. While a full citywide lockdown might have reduced the case count slightly further (from 153 to 119), it would have incurred significantly higher costs. The HCPC approach saved Guangzhou an estimated 27 to 30 billion Chinese yuan compared to a month-long citywide lockdown. The strategy resulted in an estimated 0.5%–2.0% GDP loss, whereas a full lockdown was projected to cause a 2.3% loss per month.

Discussion and Limitations

The study demonstrates that the HCPC strategy is robust, showing even greater effectiveness against earlier variants like Alpha and Beta. However, the authors note several limitations. The model assumes infinite resources, such as quarantine beds and testing kits, which might not hold true in a massive outbreak scenario. Additionally, as HCPC is a bundled set of measures, the model cannot isolate the specific contribution of individual interventions like mask-wearing.

In conclusion, the Guangzhou experience suggests that "early and precise" is more effective than "late and strong." Timely, tiered community management combined with mass testing provides a viable path for containing highly transmissible variants while minimizing socio-economic disruption.

Summary updated

Abstract

It may be concluded that timely and more precise interventions including mass testing and graded community management are effective measures for Delta variant containment in China.
BibTeX
@article{ma2023role,
  author = {Yu Ma and Hui Wang and Yong Huang and Chun Chen and Shihao Liang and Mengmeng Ma and Xinjun He and Kangning Cai and Zengtao Jiao and Liyi Chen and Bowei Zhu and Ke Li and Chaojun Xie and Lei Luo and Zhoubin Zhang},
  title = {{The Role of “Hierarchical and Classified Prevention and Control Measures (HCPC)” Strategy for SARS-CoV-2 Delta Variant in Guangzhou: A Modeling Study}},
  journal = {Journal of Epidemiology and Global Health},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1007/s44197-023-00108-1},
}
Figure