The role of craftsmanship in the conservation of Venice. State of the art and perspective

Francesco Trovò, Enrico VettoreProceedings HERITAGE 2022 - International Conference on Vernacular Heritage: Culture, People and Sustainability 2022 · DOI

Abstract

The case of Venice shows how the overall image and the perception of vernacularity in historical built aggregates strongly depend on the ability not only to preserve existing structures but also to "replicate" consolidated building techniques to ensure continuity. This approach often necessitates substitution and refurbishment, which can conflict with traditional conservation principles favoring recognizability of additions. The most pressing issue is the progressive disappearance of local craftsmanship, a crisis particularly dramatic in Venice where specific knowledge is required for historical building interventions. This paper examines measures to counteract this phenomenon, including training courses for artisans, public subsidies, and the evolving role of authorities.

Introduction

Venice is frequently characterized as a museum city, yet it remains a fragile physical environment requiring constant, specialized maintenance. Its survival depends not merely on stone and mortar, but on the "intangible heritage" of the artisans who possess the unique skills to work them. Currently, Venice faces a demographic and technical crisis: as local artisans disappear, the specific building techniques required to maintain the city’s unique vernacular character are being lost. Conservation policy must shift from protecting "building shapes" to actively subsidizing the generational transfer of craftsmanship.

The Crisis of Venetian Craftsmanship

Since 1976, Venice has lost half of its resident population and half of its registered artisans. This decline creates a technical vacuum; when historic buildings require repair, the work is increasingly outsourced to firms using modern, standardized materials—such as concrete or industrial plaster—that are incompatible with the Venetian architectural DNA.

Artisans and students examining traditional building materials and tools during a training session.

Data from Confartigianato Venezia indicates that the average age of craftsmen has risen from 46 to 52 in just two decades, with only 2% of the workforce currently under the age of 30. This generational gap is identified as the single greatest threat to the city's physical conservation. Furthermore, the explosion of mass tourism has pushed artisan workshops out of the city, making the logistics of maintenance—which requires boat transport and local laboratories—prohibitively expensive.

Regulatory and Economic Barriers

A significant insight of this research is the "certification trap" created by modern heritage laws. The Italian "Code of Cultural Heritage" and the 2017 Public Contracts Regulations often require formal academic degrees for public works. This effectively disqualifies master masons or carpenters who possess decades of practical "know-how" but lack formal certifications. Consequently, larger, certified corporations often win contracts over more skilled traditional artisans.

Additionally, current urban planning often focuses on preserving the typology (the shape and height of buildings) while neglecting the authenticity of materials. This leads to a form of "theme park" conservation where the city maintains its silhouette but loses its material integrity up close.

The Path Forward: Workshop Schools and Policy Reform

To address these challenges, the authors propose several strategic interventions:

  • The "Fabbriceria" Model: Applying the continuous, specialized maintenance model used for major monuments (like St. Mark’s Basilica) to the city's diffuse building fabric.
  • Bottega Scuola (Workshop Schools): Championing regional laws that allow traditional workshops to act as accredited schools. These programs use public funding to bridge the gap between master and apprentice through hands-on training.
A practical demonstration of traditional metalworking techniques in a Venetian workshop.
  • Operational Prescriptions: Advocating for building permits that mandate traditional techniques (such as marmorino or cocciopesto plaster) even for non-monumental private buildings to ensure the city's material soul is preserved.

Conclusion

While craftsmanship is not yet a complete economic alternative to mass tourism, it is an essential service for the city's physical survival. The preservation of the urbs (the physical city) is impossible without the preservation of the civitas (the community of skilled practitioners). Future efforts must focus on mapping training opportunities and strengthening the "factory school" model to ensure that iconic Venetian crafts do not become extinct.

Summary updated

Abstract

The case of Venice shows how the overall image, the perception of vernacularity of the historical built aggregates, strongly depends on the ability not only to preserve as much as possible, but also to "replicate" the consolidated building techniques to ensure continuity with the actions of restoration and consolidation. This option also contemplates forms of substitution and refurbishment, in contrast with the principles of conservation which favor the criterion of recognizability of the addition and reject the replacement of components, even when executed in an appropriate and harmonious manner, often the only option possible when attempting to preserve the Venetian character of the city’s buildings.The most pressing issue is that of the progressive disappearance of local craftsmanship. This is particularly dramatic in the case of Venice, where specific knowledge is needed in order to carry out interventions on elements of historical buildings. The objectives of protection are also of relevance in this case as they present particular difficulty for foreign workers or workers who have completed different training. In this regard, this text examines the measures implemented to counteract this phenomenon, particularly the effectiveness and role of each of the hypotheses examined, already partially addressed in the city, training courses for artisans and technicians; public subsidies and incentives and the role of the authorities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{trovo2022role,
  author = {Francesco Trovò and Enrico Vettore},
  title = {{The role of craftsmanship in the conservation of Venice. State of the art and perspective}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings HERITAGE 2022 - International Conference on Vernacular Heritage: Culture, People and Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.4995/heritage2022.2022.15690},
}
Figure