The role of annealing in determining the yielding behavior of glasses under cyclic shear deformation

Himangsu Bhaumik, Giuseppe Foffi, Srikanth SastryProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2021 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Understanding the nature of the yielding transition in amorphous solids is of significant interest conceptually and for practical reasons. We use computer simulations of models of silica—a network glass—and an atomic glass to investigate the effect of annealing on yielding under cyclic shear deformation. We identify a threshold energy toward which poorly annealed glasses evolve as yielding is approached under cyclic deformation, and below which glasses display little change until they yield, with progressively stronger discontinuities as degree of annealing increases. The threshold energy thus separates two distinct regimes of yielding, with increasingly brittle behavior at lower energies. Interestingly, the threshold energy corresponds to well-studied dynamical cross-overs in the corresponding liquids.

Introduction

Amorphous solids, ranging from metallic glasses to polymers and foams, exhibit a wide spectrum of mechanical failure modes. While some materials undergo gradual, ductile deformation, others fail catastrophically through brittle fracture. A central question in glass physics is how the thermal history, or annealing, of a glass dictates its ultimate mechanical response. While monotonic shear has been extensively studied, the response to cyclic shear—repeated loading and unloading—offers deeper insights into the structural stability and "memory" of these disordered systems. This study investigates whether a universal threshold exists that separates these distinct yielding regimes.

Methodology

We employed Athermal Quasistatic (AQS) simulations to investigate the mechanical response of two distinct glass models:

  1. BKS Silica: A representative network glass forming a tetrahedral web.
  2. Kob-Andersen (KA) Binary Mixture: A standard model for atomic glasses.

Simulations were performed at $T=0$ to isolate the purely mechanical response. Samples were prepared by quenching parent liquids from a range of temperatures, resulting in varying degrees of annealing (initial potential energies). Cyclic shear was applied by incrementally increasing the maximum strain amplitude $\gamma_{max}$ and monitoring the steady-state potential energy and stress.

Results and Discussion

The Emergence of a Threshold Energy

Our simulations reveal a fundamental "threshold energy" that governs the yielding transition. For poorly annealed glasses (prepared at high temperatures), cyclic shear acts as a secondary annealing process. As these samples are repeatedly deformed, they settle into progressively lower energy states, effectively "self-correcting" their structure until they reach a characteristic threshold energy.

Conversely, well-annealed glasses—those with initial energies already below this threshold—exhibit minimal structural change during cyclic loading until a critical strain is reached. At this point, they undergo a sharp, discontinuous yielding transition characterized by massive jumps in potential energy and stress.

Yielding behavior of BKS silica under cyclic shear.

Linking Solid Mechanics to Liquid Dynamics

A key finding of this work is the remarkable correspondence between the mechanical threshold energy in the solid glass and the dynamical crossover temperatures in the parent liquid. In the case of BKS silica, the threshold corresponds to the fragile-to-strong crossover temperature ($T \approx 3100K$). For the KA atomic glass, the threshold aligns with the mode-coupling temperature ($T \approx 0.435$).

Yielding behavior of the KA atomic glass.

As the degree of annealing increases (lower initial energy), the yielding transition becomes increasingly brittle. This is evidenced by the sharpening of the discontinuities in stress ($\Delta \sigma$) and energy ($\Delta E$) at the yielding point. The threshold energy thus serves as a boundary between a regime of "rejuvenation" (where shear lowers the energy of poorly annealed samples) and a regime of "over-aging" (where well-annealed samples remain stable until brittle failure).

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that the yielding behavior of glasses under cyclic shear is not merely a function of the material composition but is deeply rooted in its thermal history. The identification of a threshold energy, and its direct link to liquid-state dynamical crossovers, provides a powerful framework for predicting whether a glass will exhibit ductile or brittle failure. Future work will explore how finite temperatures and varying strain rates influence these sharp transitions in real-world materials.

Summary updated

Abstract

Significance Understanding the nature of the yielding transition in amorphous solids is of significant interest conceptually and for practical reasons. We use computer simulations of models of silica—a network glass—and an atomic glass to investigate the effect of annealing on yielding under cyclic shear deformation. We identify a threshold energy toward which poorly annealed glasses evolve as yielding is approached under cyclic deformation, and below which glasses display little change until they yield, with progressively stronger discontinuities as degree of annealing increases. The threshold energy thus separates two distinct regimes of yielding, with increasingly brittle behavior at lower energies. Interestingly, the threshold energy corresponds to well-studied dynamical cross-overs in the corresponding liquids.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bhaumik2021role,
  author = {Himangsu Bhaumik and Giuseppe Foffi and Srikanth Sastry},
  title = {{The role of annealing in determining the yielding behavior of glasses under cyclic shear deformation}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.2100227118},
}
Figure