The risk of urban yellow fever resurgence in Aedes-infested American cities

Eduardo Massad, Marcos Amaku, Francisco Antônio Bezerra Coutinho, Claúdio J. Struchiner, Luis Fernández López, Giovanini Evelim Coelho, Annelies Wilder‐Smith, Marcelo Nascimento BurattiniEpidemiology 2018 · DOI

Abstract

Aedes aegypti, historically known as the yellow fever (YF) mosquito, transmits numerous viruses including Dengue, Zika, and Chikungunya. While no urban YF cycle has been reported in the Americas since the late 1950s, the re-establishment of Aedes populations in urban centers poses a significant public health risk. This paper presents a method to estimate the risk of urban YF resurgence by using Dengue outbreak data as a proxy for mosquito density. We demonstrate that if the relative vector competence of Ae. aegypti for YF exceeds 0.7 compared to Dengue, a single viraemic traveler could trigger an urban outbreak.

Introduction: The Threat of Resurgence

Yellow Fever (YF) operates through two transmission cycles: the sylvatic (jungle) cycle, maintained by forest mosquitoes and non-human primates, and the urban cycle, transmitted between humans by Aedes aegypti. Although the urban cycle was largely eradicated in the Americas by the late 1950s, Aedes aegypti has since re-colonized nearly every major tropical city in the region. The increasing movement of non-vaccinated individuals between YF-endemic jungle regions and these Aedes-infested cities creates a potential bridge for the virus to return to urban populations. This study addresses the need for predictive tools to quantify this risk.

Methods: Modeling from Dengue Proxies

The researchers developed a multi-stage mathematical framework to circumvent the difficulty of direct mosquito population counts. By fitting a Gaussian-like function to reported Dengue incidence data from Rio de Janeiro (2011–2012), they "back-calculated" the necessary Aedes population size to sustain such an outbreak.

Dengue incidence in Rio de Janeiro (2011-2012) used to calibrate mosquito population estimates.

This population estimate was then integrated into a Ross-Macdonald model to simulate YF transmission. A stochastic risk assessment, using a non-homogeneous simple birth process, calculated the probability of a single infected traveler producing at least one secondary local (autochthonous) case during their infectious period.

Key Insights: The 0.7 Competence Threshold

The most significant finding is the identification of a critical "vector competence" threshold. Vector competence refers to the mosquito's biological efficiency in acquiring and transmitting a virus. The model shows that if the local Aedes aegypti population is at least 70% as efficient at transmitting YF as it is at transmitting Dengue (a relative competence of 0.7), the expected number of secondary cases crosses the epidemic threshold of 1.0.

Relationship between vectorial competence and the number of secondary cases, highlighting the 0.7 threshold.

Currently, empirical data suggests Brazilian strains of Ae. aegypti exhibit YF competence levels between 0.52 and 0.58. This likely explains why, despite high mosquito densities, major urban resurgences have not yet occurred. However, the risk is highly seasonal, peaking sharply during the months when mosquito populations are at their maximum (roughly 5-6 months into the year in the Rio dataset).

Results and Validation

The model's accuracy was validated by comparing its mosquito density estimates ($8,145 \pm 284$ females in a specific $0.8 \text{ km}^2$ area) with empirical field data ($8,333$ mosquitoes) collected via traps in the same region. While the probability of a single traveler starting an outbreak remains low (calculated at $1.32 \times 10^{-5}$ for 2012 conditions in Rio), this risk scales linearly with the volume of infected travelers entering the city.

Limitations and Future Directions

The model assumes homogeneous mixing of humans and mosquitoes, whereas real-world transmission is often focal. Future work should focus on applying this framework to smaller geographical units and incorporating real-time monitoring of vector competence. As mosquito populations evolve, detecting shifts toward higher YF competence will be vital for preventing a return of the urban cycle.

Summary updated

Abstract

Aedes aegypti, historically known as yellow fever (YF) mosquito, transmits a great number of other viruses such as Dengue, West Nile, Chikungunya, Zika, Mayaro and perhaps Oropouche, among others. Well established in Africa and Asia, Aedes mosquitoes are now increasingly invading large parts of the American continent, and hence the risk of urban YF resurgence in the American cities should because of great concern to public health authorities. Although no new urban cycle of YF was reported in the Americas since the end of an Aedes eradication programme in the late 1950s, the high number of non-vaccinated individuals that visit endemic areas, that is, South American jungles where the sylvatic cycle of YF is transmitted by canopy mosquitoes, and return to Aedes-infested urban areas, increases the risk of resurgence of the urban cycle of YF. We present a method to estimate the risk of urban YF resurgence in dengue-endemic cities. This method consists in (1) to estimate the number of Aedes mosquitoes that explains a given dengue outbreak in a given region; (2) calculate the force of infection caused by the introduction of one infective individual per unit area in the endemic area under study; (3) using the above estimates, calculate the probability of at least one autochthonous YF case per unit area produced by one single viraemic traveller per unit area arriving from a YF endemic or epidemic sylvatic region at the city studied. We demonstrate that, provided the relative vector competence, here defined as the capacity to being infected and disseminate the virus, of Ae. aegypti is greater than 0.7 (with respect to dengue), one infected traveller can introduce urban YF in a dengue endemic area.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{massad2018risk,
  author = {Eduardo Massad and Marcos Amaku and Francisco Antônio Bezerra Coutinho and Claúdio J. Struchiner and Luis Fernández López and Giovanini Evelim Coelho and Annelies Wilder‐Smith and Marcelo Nascimento Burattini},
  title = {{The risk of urban yellow fever resurgence in <i>Aedes</i>-infested American cities}},
  booktitle = {Epidemiology},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1017/s0950268818001334},
}
Figure