Abstract
In recent years, smartphones have changed the way that we interact with the web – and each other. But have they changed the way that we shop online? In a recent study of internet and mobile eBay transactions, Liran Einav, John Levin, Igor Popov and Neel Sundaresan find that mobile adopters tended to be heavy eBay users, and tended to buy more using their mobiles, while their non-mobile purchases stayed largely the same. They also find that their mobile shopping behaviors in terms of prices and products are little different to those on eBay’s internet site.
Introduction
As smartphones became ubiquitous, many predicted a "Web 3.0" revolution that would disrupt retail as significantly as the original internet did in the 1990s. This research seeks to determine if mobile devices actually change consumer behavior or if they simply provide a more convenient interface for existing habits. Specifically, the study investigates whether mobile shopping leads to different product choices, price sensitivities, or a displacement of traditional desktop e-commerce.
Methodology and Data
The researchers conducted a longitudinal study of eBay user behavior during the critical transition period of 2008–2013. They tracked "mobile adoption"—defined as a user’s first purchase via the eBay mobile app—and compared the shopping patterns of these adopters against a control group of non-adopters.
The study utilized a "difference-in-differences" approach, analyzing:
- Pre-adoption activity: Baseline activity levels before mobile integration.
- Post-adoption impact: Whether mobile purchases substituted for or supplemented desktop purchases.
- Behavioral metrics: Comparison of prices paid and product categories across platforms.
- Temporal patterns: The "hour of day" distribution for purchases.
The research relied on a massive, proprietary dataset from eBay, including a sample of approximately 1% of all users from 2008 to mid-2013. In 2012, eBay’s mobile transactions accounted for $13 billion of a $67.8 billion ecosystem.
Key Findings
The "Power User" Selection Bias
Mobile adopters were not random shoppers; they were eBay’s most loyal customers. In early 2011, those about to adopt mobile were already twice as active as those who remained on desktop. Mobile serves as a tool for the "super-shopper" rather than a gateway for new users.
Incremental Growth vs. Cannibalization
A striking finding is that mobile shopping does not "cannibalize" desktop shopping. After adopting the app, a user’s non-mobile purchases remained steady, while their mobile activity drove a doubling of their total platform purchasing on average.
The "Bedtime" Effect
Contrary to the image of mobile shopping happening "on the go," data shows that mobile use peaks in the late evening (9 PM to midnight). This suggests that mobile devices often function as "couch" or "bed" devices, replacing the laptop rather than enabling transit-based commerce.
Behavioral Continuity
Despite the different interface, the nature of consumption remains consistent. Prices paid and the types of products purchased on mobile were remarkably similar to those on the core desktop site.
Results and Future Outlook
Mobile-originated transactions on eBay increased tenfold between 2010 and 2013. By June 2013, over one-third of active monthly users had made at least one mobile purchase. Six months after adoption, the average user's total purchasing volume remained roughly double their pre-adoption levels.
While the data captures the nascent stage of mobile commerce, the authors suggest that the real transformation may lie in how mobile devices bridge the gap to offline shopping—such as in-store price comparisons or location-based coupons. Like many general-purpose technologies, the full societal and economic effects of mobile internet may take decades to manifest as business models and consumer habits reorganize around the new technology.
Summary updated