The Research Progress of Machining Mechanisms in Milling Wood-based Materials

Weihua Wei, Yuantong Li, Tongming Xue, Shiyuan Tao, Changtong Mei, Wandong Zhou, Jian Wang, Tongyue WangBioResources 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This review paper synthesizes current research on the milling of wood-based materials like MDF and WPCs, focusing on critical aspects like tool wear, chip formation, processing stability, and surface roughness. It highlights how cutting parameters, tool design, and machining environments significantly impact these factors, offering insights into improving efficiency and product quality.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wood-based materials, including MDF and WPCs, are increasingly used due to their sustainability and performance advantages. However, their machining, particularly milling, presents unique challenges compared to traditional metals. These materials are heterogeneous, anisotropic, and can soften or degrade at relatively low temperatures, leading to complex tool wear mechanisms, unpredictable chip formation, processing instability, and difficulties in achieving desired surface quality. Existing research has explored various factors influencing these processes, but a comprehensive review is needed to consolidate this knowledge and guide future research and industrial practice.

Methods

This paper is a review article, meaning it synthesizes and analyzes existing research rather than presenting new experimental data. The authors systematically reviewed literature focusing on:

  • Tool Wear: Analyzing the causes and influencing factors of tool wear, including workpiece material properties (hardness, composition), cutting parameters (speed, feed, depth), tool materials and geometry (rake angle, relief angle), and machining environments (temperature, cooling).
  • Chip Formation Mechanisms: Investigating how different wood-based materials form chips (spiral, break-shaped, sheet, powder) and how these chip types affect cutting vibrations, tool wear, and surface quality.
  • Processing Stability: Examining sources of processing noise in high-speed cutting of WPCs, distinguishing between aerodynamic and mechanical noise.
  • Machined Surface Roughness: Reviewing the factors that influence surface roughness, such as cutting parameters, tool geometry, temperature, and material properties.
  • Online Monitoring Systems: Discussing the development and application of systems for real-time monitoring of tool wear and surface roughness.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This is a review article that synthesizes existing research.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Material Complexity is Key: The inherent heterogeneity and anisotropy of wood-based materials, along with their polymeric binders and additives, create a complex machining environment that significantly accelerates tool wear and influences chip formation and surface quality.
  • Tool Wear is Multifaceted: Tool wear in wood-based materials isn't just abrasive; it's a combination of mechanical abrasion, chemical corrosion (due to acidic/alkaline components), and thermal degradation, making tool material selection and coating critical.
  • Chip Formation Dictates Success: The type of chip produced (spiral, break-shaped, sheet, powder) has a direct impact on processing stability, tool wear, and the final surface finish. Producing continuous sheet chips is often ideal for high-speed milling.
  • Environment Matters: Machining temperature, cooling methods, and even the vibration of the machine itself play crucial roles in tool wear and processing stability, often more so than in metal cutting.
  • The Need for Smart Monitoring: Traditional manual tool wear checks are cumbersome and time-consuming. The development of online, real-time monitoring systems using acoustic, force, or optical signals is essential for improving automation and efficiency in wood-based material machining.

Key Results

The paper summarizes findings from numerous studies, indicating that:

  • Fireproof MDF exhibits more severe tool wear than standard or waterproof MDF due to higher impurity content.
  • WPC materials like ChoiceDek show significantly higher tool wear compared to solid wood.
  • Coated carbide tools (e.g., CrCN/CrN+ta-C) demonstrate significantly improved durability (up to five times) compared to uncoated tools.
  • Higher cutting speeds and deeper cutting thicknesses generally lead to increased tool wear.
  • Surface roughness is inversely proportional to milling speed and proportional to feed rate, with a 65° rake angle often yielding the best surface roughness.
  • Online monitoring systems using fused acoustic and force signals, or laser displacement sensors, have shown promising accuracy in predicting tool wear and surface roughness.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while significant progress has been made, several areas require further investigation:

  • Tool Design and Coating: Continued research and development of high-performance, cost-effective milling tools and advanced coating technologies are needed to enhance wear resistance.
  • Online Monitoring Systems: Developing more robust and accurate online tool wear monitoring systems is crucial for ensuring timely tool changes and maintaining processing quality.
  • Chip Formation Mechanisms: A deeper understanding of chip formation mechanisms and the critical conditions for chip conversion is vital for optimizing chip breaking, removal, and overall surface processing quality. Specific focus is needed on achieving continuous sheet chips and controlling chip flow.
  • High-Speed Milling Challenges: For high-speed milling, where chip generation is high, further research into tool geometry (e.g., large spiral angles) is needed to ensure smooth chip removal and prevent tool breakage.
  • Surface Quality Requirements: As demand for higher surface quality increases, more in-depth studies on surface roughness and the development of advanced online detection devices are necessary to meet these demands and provide a basis for practical production.

Summary updated

Abstract

The machining mechanisms in milling for medium-density fiberboard (MDF) and wood-plastic composites (WPC) are reviewed in this article. The study focuses on milling tool wear, chip formation mechanisms, processing stability, and machined surface roughness. The influence law of cutting parameters (cutting speed, feed rate, and cutting thickness), tool materials and geometry (rake angle, relief angle, and size parameters), temperature, and other factors on tool wear and machined surface roughness were considered. Concrete measures to improve tool life and machined surface quality are summarized as well as an online monitoring system of tool wear and machined surface roughness. Future research of tool wear and surface quality in milling wood-based materials is proposed to provide important references for wood-based materials researchers.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wei2017research,
  author = {Weihua Wei and Yuantong Li and Tongming Xue and Shiyuan Tao and Changtong Mei and Wandong Zhou and Jian Wang and Tongyue Wang},
  title = {{The Research Progress of Machining Mechanisms in Milling Wood-based Materials}},
  booktitle = {BioResources},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.15376/biores.13.1.wei},
}
Figure