The relevance of timing, pauses and overlaps in dialogues: detecting topic changes in scenario based meetings

Saturnino Luz, Jing SuInterspeech 2010

TL;DR

This paper explores how simple acoustic features like speech timing, pauses, and overlaps can effectively predict topic changes in meetings, outperforming methods relying solely on lexical content. The key insight is that the temporal dynamics of conversation, rather than just what is said, hold significant clues for understanding dialogue structure.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Automatically segmenting meeting recordings into distinct topics is crucial for making these recordings searchable and browsable. Imagine trying to find a specific discussion point in hours of meeting footage – topic segmentation aims to provide this structure. However, accurately identifying these topic boundaries is challenging. Traditional approaches often rely on transcribing the speech (using Automatic Speech Recognition, ASR) and then analyzing the text for lexical cohesion. This is computationally expensive and prone to errors from imperfect transcriptions, especially in noisy meeting environments with disfluencies, interruptions, and overlapping speech. This paper investigates whether simpler, audio-based features can achieve comparable or even better results for topic segmentation.

Methods

The authors propose a novel approach to topic segmentation that focuses on "vocalisation events" – talk spurts, pauses, and speech overlaps – rather than just the transcribed text. They represent each vocalisation event using a feature vector that captures its duration, the speaker's role, and the timing of surrounding vocalisation events (both preceding and following). They explore three specific representations:

  • V<sub>v</sub>: Focuses on the durations of surrounding vocalisations.
  • V<sub>g</sub>: Focuses on the durations of surrounding pauses and speech overlaps.
  • V<sub>a</sub>: Combines vocalisations, pauses, and overlaps.

These feature vectors are then fed into a Naive Bayes classifier. This classifier is trained to predict whether a given vocalisation event marks the beginning of a new topic. The authors also experiment with two thresholding strategies (Maximum A Posteriori - MAP, and Proportional Thresholding - PT) and a post-processing step to filter out adjacent boundary predictions.

Datasets

The experiments were conducted on the Augmented Multi-Party Interaction (AMI) corpus, specifically the scenario-based meeting portion. This corpus contains multi-party conversations with annotations for participants, roles, dialogue acts, and importantly, topics. The authors prepared approximately 26 hours of meeting data for their experiments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Timing is Talking: The most surprising finding is that the timing of vocalisations alone, within a limited temporal context, can be a highly effective predictor of topic shifts. This suggests that the rhythm and flow of conversation are as informative as the content itself.
  • Pauses and Overlaps Matter: Surprisingly, pauses and speech overlaps, when considered independently, yielded segmentation accuracy comparable to vocalisations. This highlights the rich information embedded in the non-speech aspects of dialogue.
  • Simplicity Can Be Powerful: The proposed method, relying on relatively simple acoustic features and a Naive Bayes classifier, achieved results competitive with, and in some cases superior to, more complex methods that require extensive speech processing (like ASR).
  • Context is Key: Representing vocalisation events within their immediate temporal context (surrounding vocalisations, pauses, overlaps) proved more effective than just considering isolated events.

Key Results

The paper reports results using two common evaluation metrics for segmentation: P<sub>k</sub> and WindowDiff (WD).

  • All proposed methods significantly outperformed a random baseline.
  • The V<sub>a</sub> representation combined with MAP thresholding and the post-processing step (Af) generally yielded the best scores, achieving a P<sub>k</sub> of 27.67% and a WD of 36.00%.
  • Interestingly, the V<sub>g</sub> representation (pauses and overlaps only) performed remarkably close to V<sub>v</sub> (vocalisations only) in terms of P<sub>k</sub>, suggesting the significant predictive power of non-speech acoustic cues.
  • The WD scores indicated that the V<sub>g</sub> representation tended to lead to overprediction of boundaries, which was mitigated by the post-processing step.
  • The authors' best result (V<sub>a</sub>+MAP+Af) is presented as competitive with other state-of-the-art methods on the AMI corpus, particularly for sub-topic segmentation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Post-processing Improvement: While the post-processing step improved WD scores, the authors suggest there's still room for improvement in this area, as P<sub>k</sub> scores didn't significantly change.
  • Independence Assumption: The Naive Bayes classifier assumes conditional independence between features. The authors suggest relaxing this assumption, perhaps by incorporating ordering dependencies or exploring other models like Hidden Markov Models (HMMs), which could better capture the sequential nature of dialogue.
  • Thresholding Inconclusive: The comparison between MAP and Proportional Thresholding was inconclusive, with the authors noting that proportional thresholding didn't generalize as well, possibly due to the irregular nature of topic shifts in the AMI corpus.
  • Combining with Lexical Features: The authors acknowledge that combining their acoustic features with lexical information could potentially yield even better results.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{luz2010relevance,
  author = {Saturnino Luz and Jing Su},
  title = {{The relevance of timing, pauses and overlaps in dialogues: detecting topic changes in scenario based meetings}},
  booktitle = {Interspeech},
  year = {2010},
}

Loading related content...

Figure